Section 13.2 · PDF pages 831–833
The zero-free region and the single exceptional zero
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
13.2 The zero-free region and the single exceptional zero
Lemma 13.8 (Local subtraction of zeros, with the exact disks). There is an absolute C > 0 such that, for every family, character and t ∈ℝ, the zeros ρ of F_{χ} in |ρ −(5/4 + it)| ≤3/5 form a finite set Z_{t}, with total multiplicity at most Cℓ(t), and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||||||F_{χ}^{′}(s) ∑_{mρ} |||||| ( )− ≤Cℓ(t) |s −(5/4 + it)| ≤^{1}_{2}, F_{χ}(s) ̸= 0 . (NP.19)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
F_{χ}(s)_{ρ∈Zt}s −ρSource: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassLFunctionLogDerivLocalFormula.lean:11--155; NormOneSubConjMul.lean.
Proof. We give the disk argument used in the source. Suppose g is holomorphic on a neighbourhood of the closed unit disk, |g| ≤M there and g(0) ̸= 0. The mean value of log |z −a| on |z| = 1 is log max(1, |a|): outside the disk this follows by expanding log(1 −z/a), and inside by the same computation after factoring out z on the circle. Factoring the finitely many zeros in any smaller disk and applying the harmonic mean-value identity to the remaining zero-free factor gives Jensen’s inequality. In particular the number N_{0} of zeros, with multiplicity, in |a| ≤6/7 obeys
N_{0} log(7/6) ≤ log(M/|g(0)|).
Zeros are isolated because g(0) ̸= 0, so their set in that compact disk is finite.
Remove their finite Blaschke product B_{0}(z) =∏_{a}((z−a)/(1−az̄ ))^{ma}, and set h = g/B_{0}. Cancellation makes h holomorphic on the unit disk, zero-free on |z| ≤ 6/7, and bounded by M: on the unit circle the product has modulus 1, and then the maximum principle applies to h. Also |h(0)| ≥|g(0)|. A branch of log h exists on |z| < 6/7. The positive-real-part function log M − log h, after subtracting its constant imaginary part, has central real part between 0 and log(M/|g(0)|). The half-plane-to-disk transformation and Schwarz’s lemma give the derivative bound
|h^{′}(z)/h(z)| ≤C_{0} log(M/|g(0)|) (|z| ≤5/7)
for an absolute C_{0}. Explicitly, for an analytic function H with nonnegative real part on radius R, apply Schwarz to (H −H(0))/(H + H(0)) and differentiate; on radius r < R this gives |H^{′}| ≤2RℜH(0)/(R − r)^{2}. If ℜH(0) = 0, the minimum principle makes its real part constant and the derivative is zero. The derivative of the Blaschke product is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B_{0}^{′}_{(z) =}∑_{m} ( 1_{+} ā )_{.}
B_{0a}^{a} z −a 1 −az̄The second summand is at most a fixed constant times N_{0} on |z| ≤5/7, since |a| ≤6/7. Combining these bounds proves the zero-subtraction formula on those radii, with a constant times 1 + log(M/|g(0)|).
Now take c = 5/4 + it and g(z) = F_{χ}(c + 7z/10). Its outer disk lies in ℜs ≥11/20. Lemma 13.4 bounds it by M = 300B(|t| + 3)^{2}. The same exponential-series argument in (NP.11) at real part 5/4 gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|L_{χ}(5/4 + it)| ≥ζ(5/4)^{−2}≥1/25,
∫ ∞because ζ(5/4) ≤1 +_{1} x^{−5/4}dx = 5. The possible factor s −1 has norm at least 1/4 at c, so |g(0)| ≥ 1/100. Put X_{0} = B(|t| + 2) ≥8. Then 300B(|t| + 3)^{2}/|g(0)| ≤X_{0}^{7}: use (|t| + 3)^{2} ≤(9/4)(|t| + 2)^{2}, B ≥4 and X_{0}^{5}≥8^{5}. Thus 1+log(M/|g(0)|) ≤8ℓ(t). The affine map changes radii 6/7, 5/7 into 3/5, 1/2, preserves zero multiplicities and multiplies the logarithmic derivative and each reciprocal-zero term by the same 7/10. Absorbing this fixed factor proves (NP.19).
Lemma 13.9 (The positive character combinations). Put D_{χ}(s) = ∑_{n}λ_{χ}(n)n^{−s} on ℜs > 1. Then, for
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
σ > 1,
D_{1}(σ) ≥0,
3D_{1}(σ) + 4ℜD_{χ}(σ + it) + ℜD_{χ}2(σ + 2it) ≥0,
D_{1}(σ) + D_{χ}(σ) ≥0 (χ^{2}= 1),
D_{1}(σ) + D_{χ}(σ) + D_{ψ}(σ) + D_{χψ}(σ) ≥0 (χ^{2}= ψ^{2}= 1).Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassLFunctionFamilyLogDerivPositivity.lean:8--103.
Proof. All series converge absolutely by |λ_{χ}(n)| ≤2Λ(n). For each g, n, weight by the nonnegative real number λ_{g}(n)n^{−σ}. For the second inequality put z = χ(g)e^{−it log n}, whose modulus is 1; the remaining factor is 3 + 4ℜz + ℜz^{2} = 2(1 + ℜz)^{2} ≥ 0. For the last two use respectively 1 + χ(g) ≥ 0 and (1 + χ(g))(1 + ψ(g)) ≥0, since the quadratic values are ±1. Summing proves every assertion.
Proposition 13.10 (The family’s zero-free region). There is an absolute c_{4} > 0 such that any zero ρ = β+iγ with β ≥3/4, which is not real for a quadratic character, satisfies
β < 1 −c_{4}/ℓ(γ). (NP.20)
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassLFunctionZeroFreeRegion.lean:40--311.
Proof. Every zero has real part at most 1, by Lemma 13.4. Equation (NP.19), its real part and (NP.11) imply the following upper bound, for 0 < a ≤1/2:
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ 1
ℜD_{χ}(1 + a + it) ≤P + Cℓ(t) − ℜ . (NP.21)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{ρ∈S} 1 + a + it −ρHere S is any selected finite set of zeros in its 3/5 disk, and P ≥0 bounds the pole 1_{χ=1}a/(a^{2}+t^{2}). Indeed every reciprocal-zero term has nonnegative real part, and its actual multiplicity is at least one. Dropping the unselected terms and reducing multiplicities can only increase the upper bound. We use also ℓ(0) ≤ ℓ(γ) and ℓ(2γ) ≤2ℓ(γ), immediate from the definition.
Write δ = 1 −β and suppose 0 ≤δ ≤ε with 0 < ε ≤1/400. We prove
ε^{−1}≤300Cℓ(γ). (NP.22)
First suppose χ^{2}= 1 and |γ| < 30ε. The excluded real-quadratic case gives γ ̸= 0. Conjugation supplies the distinct second zero β −iγ. Both are in the disk of (NP.21) at t = 0. Use a = 60ε. Positivity of D_{1} if χ = 1, or of D_{1} + D_{χ} otherwise, and (NP.21) give
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{2} 60ε + δ_{ ≤} 1_{+ 2Cℓ(0).}
(60ε + δ)^{2}+ γ^{2} 60εThe fraction is at least 60/(4621ε), since its numerator is at least 60ε and its denominator is at most (61^{2}+ 30^{2})ε^{2}. Thus (120/4621 −1/60)ε^{−1}≤2Cℓ(0), which implies (NP.22), as 120/4621 −1/60 > 1/150.
In every other case use a = 6ε and the trigonometric combination of Lemma 13.9. The zero β + iγ contributes at least 1/(7ε) in the middle term of (NP.21). If a pole can occur in that middle term, then
χ = 1, forcing |γ| ≥30ε by the case just excluded. Its pole is at most 1/(156ε), since 6ε/((6ε)^{2}+ γ^{2}) ≤ 1/(156ε). The same bound holds for the last pole whenever χ^{2}= 1, since then |2γ| ≥30ε. If the respective characters are nontrivial there is no pole, so these upper bounds remain valid. The first pole is at most 1/(6ε). Substitution into the positive combination yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
0 ≤(^{3}_{6 }+_{156}^{5} −^{4}_{7})ε^{−1}+ 9Cℓ(γ).The coefficient in parentheses is negative, and 9/(4/7−3/6−5/156) < 300, proving (NP.22). All selected zeros lie in the required disks: their horizontal distance is at most 1/4 + ε, and in the two-zero case the additional vertical distance is at most 30ε.
Put K = 300C and c_{4} = 1/(4K + 400). If (NP.20) failed, take ε = 1/((2K + 200)ℓ(γ)). Since ℓ(γ) ≥ log 8 > 2, it is positive and at most 1/400; also δ ≤c_{4}/ℓ(γ) ≤ε. But (NP.22) would say (2K + 200)ℓ(γ) ≤Kℓ(γ), a contradiction. This proves the exact strict zero-free inequality.
Proposition 13.11 (Uniqueness across characters and simplicity). There is an absolute c_{5} > 0 such that, among all quadratic characters, there is at most one zero in β ≥3/4, β ≥1 −c_{5}/ℓ(0), counted with mul-tiplicity. Consequently, if two such zeros are listed, their characters and values coincide and their common zero has nonzero first derivative.
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassLFunctionUniqueSimpleExceptionalZero.lean:13--258.
Proof. Retain multiplicities in the real version of (NP.21). For any selected finite set T of real zeros at least 3/4, and 1 < σ ≤7/4,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{1}χ=1 ∑^{m}βD_{χ}(σ) ≤ + Cℓ(0) − . (NP.23)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
σ −1 _{β∈T}σ −βEvery zero has finite multiplicity, since F_{χ} is holomorphic on the connected half-plane and nonzero on its right-hand part. Take c_{5} = 1/(100(C + 1)) and σ = 1 + 2c_{5}/ℓ(0), which lies in the required interval. For a listed zero, σ −β ≤3c_{5}/ℓ(0); its contribution is at least m_{β}ℓ(0)/(3c_{5}).
If one character has two distinct listed zeros, or one zero of multiplicity at least two, their total contri-bution in (NP.23) is at least 2ℓ(0)/(3c_{5}). Use D_{1} ≥ 0 for the trivial character, and D_{1} + D_{χ} ≥ 0 for a nontrivial quadratic character. If instead two distinct characters have listed zeros, use that same two-term inequality when one is trivial. If both are nontrivial, χψ ̸= 1 and the four-term positive combination applies. In every case there is at most one principal pole, of size ℓ(0)/(2c_{5}), and at most four remainders Cℓ(0). Thus all cases would imply
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
0 ≤^{ℓ}_{2}^{(0)}_{c5} + 4Cℓ(0) −^{2}_{3}^{ℓ}_{c}^{(0)}_{5} .After division by ℓ(0) > 0, this requires 1/c_{5} ≤24C, contradicting 1/c_{5} = 100(C + 1). Hence neither two characters, two values, nor a multiple zero is possible. For a holomorphic function a zero of order one has nonzero first derivative, giving the final assertion exactly as required by ExcZ.
Choose c_{0} = min(1/20, c_{4}, c_{5}), and combine the last two propositions with Corollary 13.7. Every zero in that region is real, belongs to a quadratic character, is the sole possible zero across all characters and is simple. Its gap is at least c_{∗}B^{−46}/18000. The region also has β ≥3/4, since c_{0} ≤1/20 and ℓ(t) ≥1. Thus (NP.2) is fully proved, with A = 46 and c_{9} = min(c_{∗}/18000, 1). The exceptional-term estimate (NP.3) is proved in Proposition 14.4; the following construction verifies the ray family’s coefficient, counting, theta and convolution clauses.