Section 13.1 · PDF pages 828–830
The actual effective exceptional-zero gap
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
13.1 The actual effective exceptional-zero gap
Lemma 13.4 (Continuation, growth and the right-hand logarithm). Every family in Definition 13.1 has F_{χ} holomorphic on ℜs > 1/2, with
|F_{χ}(s)| ≤300B(|s| + 1)^{2} (ℜs ≥11/20). (NP.10)
For ℜs > 1 its Dirichlet series L_{χ} is nonzero, F_{χ} = (s −1)^{1χ=1}L_{χ}, and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
L^{′}_{χ} ∑− (s) = λ_{χ}(n)n^{−s}, |L_{χ}(2 + it)| ≥_{4}^{1}. (NP.11)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{Lχ} n≥1For quadratic χ it satisfies F_{χ}(̄s) = F_{χ}(s).
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/RayClassLFunctionFamilyContinuationGrowth.lean:91--249; RayClassFamilyLogDerivReGtOne.lean.
Proof. Put a_{χ}(n) =∑_{g}χ(g)a_{g}(n) and R_{χ} = 1_{χ=1}κ|G|. Character orthogonality and the counting estimate give ∑
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
A_{χ}(x) = a_{χ}(n) = R_{χ}x + E_{χ}(x), |E_{χ}(x)| ≤10B^{√}x (x ≥1).
n≤xEach a_{g}(n) ≤κn + 10^{√}n ≤14n for n ≥1, by nonnegativity and the count at x = n. Thus all required ex-∑ ∑ ponentially weighted coefficient sums converge absolutely. Moreover ∑_{n≤x}|a_{χ}(n)| ≤_{gn≤x}a_{g}(n) = O(Bx), so its Dirichlet series is absolutely convergent on ℜs > 1. Abel summation, first on a finite interval and then with the displayed error bound at infinity, gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
R_{χ}s ∫^{ ∞}L_{χ}(s) = + s E_{χ}(x)x^{−s−1}dx. (NP.12)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
s −1 _{1}For nontrivial χ, R_{χ} = 0. The integral and all its local complex derivatives converge uniformly on compact subsets of ℜs > 1/2: powers of log x are dominated by a small positive power of x. It is holomorphic there and has norm at most 10B/(ℜs −1/2). Multiplying (NP.12) by s −1 in the trivial case is exactly the source’s Mellin definition of F_{χ}. Since |R_{χ}| ≤4B, the denominator is at least 1/20 in the stated range and the triangle inequality gives (NP.10). In the quadratic case all coefficients and R_{χ} are real; conjugating the absolutely convergent integral proves the last assertion.
The convolution identity in the family, after finite Fourier transformation, is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
a_{χ}(n) log n = λ_{χ}(u)a_{χ}(v).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
uv=n
Here a_{χ}(1) = 1, λ_{χ}(1) = 0 and |λ_{χ}(n)| ≤2Λ(n). On ℜs > 1 the function
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
H_{χ}(s) =∑^{λχ(n)}log n ^{n−s}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n≥2
converges absolutely and locally uniformly, as does its differentiated series. The Dirichlet coefficients of exp H_{χ} satisfy exactly the displayed convolution recurrence: differentiating its series gives −(exp H_{χ})^{′} = (∑λ_{χ}(n)n^{−s}) exp H_{χ}. For n ≥2 the recurrence determines its coefficient uniquely from smaller divisors by division by log n; its coefficient at 1 is 1. They are therefore a_{χ}(n), and L_{χ} = exp H_{χ}. This proves nonvanishing and (NP.11)’s logarithmic derivative. Finally
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ Λ(n)
|H_{χ}(2 + it)| ≤2_{2} = 2 log ζ(2) ≤2 log 2. n log n
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n≥2 ∫ ∞
The identity follows by expanding the absolutely convergent Euler product; ζ(2) ≤ 1 +_{1} x^{−2}dx = 2. Thus | exp H_{χ}(2 + it)| ≥e^{−2 log 2}= 1/4.
Lemma 13.5 (The theta integrals at s = 1). Write θ_{χ}(t) =∑_{n≥0}a_{χ}(n)e^{−tn}. There is an absolute C > 0 such that for every family and character
|θ_{χ}(t) −R_{χ}/t| ≤CB^{11} min(t, t^{−1}) (t > 0), (NP.13)
and |θ_{χ}(t)| ≤CBe^{−t/2} for t ≥1. For nontrivial χ,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∫ ∞
F_{χ}(1) = θ_{χ}(t) dt. (NP.14)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
0
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/ExpSumBounds.lean:18--127,129--291.
Proof. For 0 < t ≤ 1, sum the family theta-error estimate against χ(g). The main term is R_{χ}/t and the total error is at most |G|B^{10}t ≤B^{11}t. For t ≥1, use |a_{χ}(n)| ≤14Bn and, for n ≥1, e^{−tn}≤e^{−t/2}e^{−n/2}. The convergent series S = 14∑_{n≥1}ne^{−n/2} gives |θ_{χ}(t)| ≤SBe^{−t/2}. Since e^{−t/2} ≤2/t, |R_{χ}| ≤4B and B ≤B^{11}, (NP.13) follows with C = 2S + 4. All interchanges of the finite character sum and the infinite series are justified by the same absolute coefficient bound. ∫
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∞
For nontrivial χ we have R_{χ} = 0 and |A_{χ}(x)| ≤ 10B^{√}x. Using e^{−tn} =_{n} te^{−tx}dx and summing first, we obtain
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∫ ∞
θ_{χ}(t) =_{1} A_{χ}(x)te^{−tx}dx.The iterated absolute integral is finite, since
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∫ ∞ (∫ ∞ ) ∫ ∞
_{1} |A_{χ}(x)|_{0} te^{−tx}dt dx ≤10B_{1} x^{−3/2}dx < ∞.
∫ ∞ ∫ ∞ ∫ ∞Fubini and _{0} te^{−tx}dt = x^{−2} therefore show that _{0} θ_{χ}(t)dt =_{1} A_{χ}(x)x^{−2}dx. The latter is exactly (NP.12), and the source’s Mellin definition, at s = 1. This proves (NP.14) without appealing to a condition-ally convergent sum of a_{χ}(n)/n.
Proposition 13.6 (The real-character value cannot be too small). There is an absolute c_{∗}> 0, with c_{∗}≤1, such that
|F_{χ}(1)| ≥c_{∗}B^{−45} whenever χ^{2}= 1. (NP.15)
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/NormRayClassFamilyFOneGeOfRealCharacter.lean:11--292,343--422.
Proof. Define the positive kernel
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∫ ∞_{ dw}
W(y) =_{0} e^{−y/w−w}_{w} (y > 0).It is decreasing, W(1) > 0, and W(y) ≤ C_{W} y^{−3} for an absolute C_{W} : the bound e^{−u} ≤ C_{3}u^{−3} gives an integrable majorant C_{3}y^{−3}w^{2}e^{−w}. Near w = 0 the same exponential gives integrability. These bounds justify the absolutely convergent interchanges below. In particular, if |a(n)|, |b(n)| ≤ Dn and a(0) = b(0) = 0, then ∫
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{ ∞} dw ∑θ_{a}(v/w)θ_{b}(w) = a(m)b(n)W(vmn). (NP.16)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{0w} m,n≥1For each term the change of variable in the kernel is u = nw. The absolute series is bounded by a constant times ∑_{m,n≥1}m^{−2}n^{−2}.
For quadratic χ, let a = a_{1} and b = a_{χ}, both real. Their convolution is nonnegative by (NP.1), and a(1) = b(1) = 1. Grouping (NP.16) by mn consequently gives the lower bound W(v∫) for its left side. Put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∞
P(t) = θ_{1}(t), Q(t) = θ_{χ}(t) and ρ = κ|G|. Suppose first χ ̸= 1 and put L_{χ} =_{0} Q(t)dt = F_{χ}(1). This integral is real and absolutely convergent by Lemma 13.5. Set E_{0} = CB^{11}. Writing P(v/w) = ρw/v + (P(v/w) −ρw/v) in (NP.16), and using (NP.13) and min(u, u^{−1}) ≤^{√}u, bounds its value above by ∫
ρ_{2}√^{ ∞} min(w, w^{−1}) L_{χ} + E_{0} v K_{0}, K_{0} = √ dw < ∞. (NP.17)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v_{0} w wIndeed the absolute error integrand is at most E_{0}^{2√}v times the displayed integrand; it is integrable like w^{−1/2} at zero and w^{−5/2} at infinity. This also proves the integrability needed to split the two integrals in (NP.17).
Choose, before the family,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( W(1) )
δ = min 1,_{2} > 0, s = δB^{−22}, v = s^{2}≤1.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
2(C K_{0} + 1)Then E_{0}^{2√}vK_{0} = C^{2}K_{0}δ ≤W(1)/2. Since W(v) ≥W(1), the lower bound from (NP.16) and the upper bound (NP.17) imply
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
W(1)/2 ≤ρL_{χ}/s^{2}≤4B|L_{χ}|/s^{2}.Thus |F_{χ}(1)| ≥δ^{2}W(1)/(8B^{45}). For the trivial character F_{1}(1) = ρ ≥B^{−1} directly from its definition, so the same bound with c_{∗} = min(1, δ^{2}W(1)/8) covers that case as well. This is the source’s positive-convolution kernel argument; its exponent 45 comes from 2 · 22 + 1, with no ineffective constant concealed in a citation.
Corollary 13.7 (The polynomial exceptional-zero gap). For quadratic χ and any real zero β ≥3/4 of F_{χ},
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{∗}1 −β ≥_{46} . (NP.18)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
18000B
Source: Development/AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/GlobalInterpolation/ExistsRayClassLFunctionRealZeroFarFromOne.lean:11--75.
Proof. Lemma 13.4 excludes β > 1. For any z with |z −1| ≤ 1/4, the disk of radius 1/10 about z lies in ℜw ≥ 13/20, |w| ≤ 27/20. Equation (NP.10) therefore bounds |F_{χ}(w)| by 1800B there, since (|w| + 1)^{2}≤6. Cauchy’s derivative estimate gives |F_{χ}^{′}(z)| ≤18000B. The real segment from β to 1 lies in |z −1| ≤1/4. Integrating the derivative along that segment and using F_{χ}(β) = 0 yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c_{∗}B^{−45}≤|F_{χ}(1)| ≤18000B(1 −β).Division proves (NP.18), including β = 1 being impossible.