Section 7.3 · PDF pages 339–358
What the first geometric realization actually supplies
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
7.3 What the first geometric realization actually supplies
The geometric fixed-point formula is used in the Hodge-trace calculation of a tower of smooth projective varieties with Hecke correspondences. One takes an eigenspace of the tower’s Hecke action, cuts to a graded cohomological piece, and twists by a rank-one character. The twist shifts Hodge indices and scales Frobenius roots. This construction supplies the following placewise assertion; it does not yet supply the final row.
Proposition 7.4 (The quantifiers of the geometric assertion). Fix the CM data, ℓ, ι, an odd positive rank a, the auxiliary integer d satisfying FieldOK, and x ∈ E with x^{2} = −d. Fix a finite nonsplit set T, two places w_{0}, v^{′} over ℓ satisfying the stated separation and OneK conditions, a finite set S, and an automorphic unitary representation U satisfying AutOffT, the elliptic condition at w_{0}, the sphericity condition outside w_{0}, S, and the Satake and lacunary-weight conditions at v^{′}. Then the assertion GeoOne has the logical form
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(∃m, ρ B( (U, ρ)) )
∧ ∀v admissible away from ℓ, ∃m, ρ B(U, ρ) ∧ ES_{v}(U, ρ)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(
∧ ∀v admissible above ℓ, (∃m, ρ B(U, ρ) ∧ Crys_{v}(ρ) ∧ Jumps_{v}(U, ρ))
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
)
∧(∃m, ρ B(U, ρ) ∧ PhiKilled_{v}(U, ρ)) .
Here ρ : G_{E} → GL_{m}(ℚ_{ℓ}), and B is exactly the source’s VBase condition. In particular m, ρ may vary with v, and the two representations at a place above ℓ may be different.
Proof. This is the order of the conjunctions and existential quantifiers in the definition of GeoOne. The common base condition is repeated inside each existential. Moving any of these existential quantifiers in front of the universal quantifier over places would strengthen the assertion and is not an allowed reading of it.
Source: Foundations/GaloisRepresentations/IntegralStructures/ GeometricFlagBases/HodgeTrAt.lean:79--90.
The word “lacunary” in this assertion means unequal averages of disjoint nonempty subsets. Explicitly a finite set J of integers is lacunary if, for disjoint nonempty A, B ⊂J,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|B|∑j ̸= |A|∑j. j∈A j∈B
The rich-jump condition says that at one place above ℓ and one embedding, the jump multiset of the geometric representation contains a lacunary set J_{0} of cardinality a. It does not prescribe that representation’s whole dimension or assert that these are its only jumps. This is the exact condition later used in divisor extraction.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Definitions/GaloisGeometry/ DivisionOfDeterminantCharacter.lean:15--18; Inte-gralStructures/ZetaCharacterDivisibility/InsideRefl.lean:53--61.
There are consequently two separate uniformization arguments in the source. The first is a divisibility argument for a single automorphic representation. The second is a trace-limit argument over congruent automorphic representations.
Proposition 7.5 (Untwisting a geometric eigenspace). Suppose the geometric construction has supplied a smooth projective Hecke tower ℋ, an eigensystem θ, an algebraic Hecke character κ, and integer shifts m_{τ}. Suppose the cohomological realization and comparison theorems used in Pack.rep hold. Then a single such geometric object supplies its corresponding witness in Proposition 7.4, with the twists and Hodge indices exactly as there stated.
Proof. Take the continuous semisimple graded eigenspace representation ρ_{0} associated to (ℋ, θ). The character construction gives a continuous one-dimensional ℓ-adic character ξ attached to κ, whose local Frobenius scalar is κ(v) and whose Hodge shift is −m_{τ} in the source convention. Set ρ = ρ_{0} ⊗ξ.
At a good place away from ℓ, the geometric Eichler–Shimura relation for ρ_{0} has roots sκ(v)^{−1}, with s running through the normalized Satake multiset of U. Twisting scales all roots by κ(v). The resulting multiset is exactly the original Satake multiset: the bijection on each entry is (sκ(v)^{−1})κ(v) = s. This also treats all multiplicities and recovers the annihilating polynomial with the source’s normalization, rather than its inverse twist.
At a good place above ℓ, smooth proper comparison makes ρ_{0} crystalline. The rank-one comparison and tensor compatibility keep ρ crystalline. The Hodge-trace assertion says the following: for every complex embedding τ over that place, there is a complex field automorphism σ_{τ} such that every required weight j occurs in the corresponding geometric Hodge group at degree j +m_{τ}, after changing coefficients by σ_{τ}. The Hodge comparison theorem is applied with ι replaced by σ_{τ} ∘ι. It therefore gives the required occurrence in the local jump multiset of ρ_{0}. Tensoring with ξ subtracts m_{τ}; its jump degree becomes j. The automorphism σ_{τ} can depend on τ, precisely as the Hodge-trace assertion allows. It is used to identify the comparison at that embedding; it does not require changing the chosen ρ.
At the distinguished lacunary place, these occurrences give a distinct required Hodge–Tate jumps in the jump multiset of ρ, yielding the rich-jump condition in VBase. Tensoring by a character preserves continuity and semisimplicity, and the geometric congruences outside one finite set give the remaining part of VBase. At any other place for which the same pack has a good Hodge assertion, the same argument gives its crystalline and jump clauses. At a place with a geometric Frobenius polynomial relation, tensor compatibility gives the corresponding Frobenius-annihilation clause; the same inverse scalar cancellation identifies its roots. The Satake multiset has cardinality a, as required in that clause.
Finally the plan-to-pack construction chooses the common standard base, a Kodaira–Spencer exponent and its tower, transfers the plan’s congruences to that tower, and applies its Hodge-trace theorem at the embedding just described. This preserves every place where the original plan supplied one of these properties. Applying the construction to the initial plan, then to the plan for each away-from-ℓ place, and then separately to the two plans at each above-ℓ place gives exactly the conjunction of existential assertions in Proposition 7.4. It does not combine those plans into one common plan.
Source: IntegralStructures/GeometricFlagBases/MapInvMul.lean:39--128, proofs Pack.rep and geoOne_of; PackExOf.lean, proofs Plan.pack and packEx_of.
Lemma 7.6 (A polynomial certificate for one joint eigencharacter). Let A be a finite-dimensional algebra over a field F, let T_{j} ∈A commute, and prescribe scalars α_{j} ∈F, with an arbitrary index set J. There is a finite linear combination s of words in J such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
s(α) = 1, P = s(T), P^{2}= P, (T_{j} −α_{j})^{Nj}P = 0 (j ∈J)for suitable nonnegative integers N_{j}. The idempotent P is permitted to be zero.
Proof. Inside F × A, take the subalgebra D generated by (α_{j}, T_{j}). These generators commute, so D is commutative and finite-dimensional. Projection to F defines a character ϵ : D → F. For an integral element b ∈D, factor its minimal polynomial at c = ϵ(b) as
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m_{b}(X) = (X −c)^{k}r(X), r(c) ̸= 0.Bezout for (X −c)^{k+1} and r gives a(X)(X −c)^{k+1}+q(X)r(X) = 1. The polynomial e(X) = q(X)r(X) has e(c) = 1, and both e^{2}−e and (X −c)^{k+1}e are divisible by m_{b}. Indeed subtracting the Bezout identity gives e^{2}−e = −a(X)(X −c)^{k+1}e, and (X −c)^{k+1}e = q(X)(X −c)m_{b}. Consequently e(b) is idempotent and (b −c)^{k+1}e(b) = 0.
Apply this construction to a finite F-basis b_{1}, . . . , b_{r} of D, and put z =∏_{i}e_{i}(b_{i}). The factors commute, so z^{2} = z and ϵ(z) = 1. Every (b_{i} −ϵ(b_{i}))z is nilpotent. The nilradical of the commutative ring D is an ideal: sums of nilpotents are nilpotent by the binomial expansion, and products with arbitrary ring elements are nilpotent. It is therefore an F-linear subspace. The linear map d →→(d−ϵ(d))z takes every basis element into it, so it takes all of D into it. Idempotence of z then gives, for each d, an exponent with (d−ϵ(d))^{N}z = 0.
An element of the generated algebra D is a finite linear combination of products of its generators. Write z = s((α, T)) in this form, using words to retain the source’s multiplication order. Its first projection is
s(α) = 1, and its second projection is the idempotent P = s(T). Apply the last annihilation identity to d = (α_{j}, T_{j}) and project to A. This gives all the stated powers simultaneously, without restricting the size of J.
Source: ProjectiveAutomorphicHecke/PProjOne.lean, exists\_idempotent\_aeval\_nilpotent\_sub\_of\_isIntegral and pProjOne\_holds.
Proposition 7.7 (From weighted traces to Hodge eigenspaces). Let X be one smooth projective complex level of dimension d, and write H^{a,b}= H^{b}(X, Ω^{a}_{X}). Suppose convolution by Hecke functions acts by operators T_{f}^{a,b}, with products and finite sums represented by convolution and finite sums of functions. Fix test functions f_{j}, one function f, desired eigenvalues α_{j}, and pairwise distinct nonnegative integers h_{0}, . . . , h_{n−1}. Assume the following two explicit trace hypotheses.
First, adjacent f_{j}’s commute on every word applied to f; and whenever a word polynomial s satisfies s(α) ̸= 0, there is a word polynomial a such that F = (as)(f_{j}) ∗f is an admissible trace test and its automorphic trace c_{F} is nonzero. Second, for one fixed finite linear combination C^{a,b} of the geometric endomorphism pullbacks, all these admissible tests satisfy
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑d ∑d n∑−1
(−y)^{a} (−1)^{b}Tr(T_{F}^{a,b}C^{a,b}) = c_{F} y^{hi} (y ∈ℂ). (174)
a=0 b=0 i=0Then, for every i, some b and some nonzero x ∈H^{hi,b} satisfy T_{f}^{h}_{j}^{i,b}x = α_{j}x for every j.
Proof. Fix i. In each finite-dimensional W_{b} = H^{hi,b}, let U_{b} be the span of all vectors
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
T_{fj1} · · · T_{fjr} T_{f}z.It is stable under each T_{fj}. The assumed adjacent commutation of word functions, transported through the Hecke action, says precisely that the restrictions S_{b,j} commute on U_{b}: check the equality first on the displayed spanning vectors, then extend it by linearity. Apply Lemma 7.6 in the finite algebra ∏^{d}_{b=0} End_{ℂ}(U_{b}). It gives one word polynomial s with s(α) = 1 and generalized-eigenvalue annihilation for every S_{b,j}.
Choose a and the good test F = (as)(f_{j})∗f from the first trace hypothesis. Equality (174) is an identity of polynomials, since it holds at every complex number. Its coefficient at h_{i} is c_{F} ̸= 0 on the right, because the h_{i}’s are distinct. On the left it is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑d
(−1)^{hi} (−1)^{b}Tr(T_{F}^{hi,b}C^{hi,b}).
b=0If h_{i} > d, that coefficient would instead be zero, which is impossible. At least one summand is nonzero. Its trace being nonzero implies T_{F}^{hi,b} ̸= 0. The convolution action gives T_{F} = a(T)s(T)T_{f}, so s(T)T_{f} ̸= 0. Choose z with v = s(T)T_{f}z ̸= 0. This vector lies in U_{b}, and each (S_{b,j} −α_{j})^{Nj} kills it.
The intersection of these generalized eigenspaces is a nonzero invariant subspace. In it choose a nonzero common invariant subspace of minimal dimension. For each S_{b,j}, algebraic closure of ℂ supplies an eigen-value on this subspace. Its eigenspace is invariant under every other operator by commutativity, so minimal-ity makes it the whole subspace. Thus each operator is scalar there. Its generalized-eigenvalue annihilation forces that scalar to equal α_{j}: a nonzero vector cannot be killed by a nonzero scalar power. Any nonzero vector in the minimal subspace is the required simultaneous eigenvector.
Source: LefschetzSigmaSums/PEigOf.lean, including private common\_eig and wop\_restrict; PCoeffOcc.lean; PHodgeEig.lean.
The distinctness and the uniform geometric exponent used here are also proved in the source. Put
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
C_{t} = ∑ϵ_{τ}∑λ_{τ}(j), λ_{τ}(0) ≥· · · ≥λ_{τ}(n −1).
τ̸=t,t^{̄} jIts two permitted Hodge-exponent lists have the forms
h_{i} = (n −1)m + C_{t} + λ_{t}(i) + n −1 −i, λ_{t}̄(i) = m for all i,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑
h_{i} = m + C_{t} + λ_{t}̄(j) + i, λ_{t}(i) = m for all i.
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j̸=i
In the first case h_{i} strictly decreases with i, by dominance of λ_{t} and the strict term −i. In the second it strictly increases, since removing an antitone entry makes the complementary sum nondecreasing and the term i strictly increases. These observations prove the distinctness required in the proposition.
For n > 0, either constant m is fixed by the coordinate at zero. Hence for fixed (t, ϵ, λ) there are at most two permitted lists h. For n = 0 there is only the empty list. A complex field automorphism only permutes the finitely many embeddings of the number field. There are therefore finitely many conjugate weight arrays, finitely many distinguished embeddings, and finitely many lists. Take the maximum of their individual lower bounds for the geometric power k. This gives one k before choosing any complex field automorphism, level, test family or coefficient-field model. At that k, apply the proposition to each conjugate array and list. This is the source’s uniform step from its trace identity to its Hodge-eigenspace assertion, not an exchange of existential and universal quantifiers.
Source: LefschetzSigmaSums/InvPol.lean:21--29; PHExpInj.lean; PUnifBound.lean; PHodgeEig.lean.
Lemma 7.8 (Integral interpolation of the Schur weight). Let F be a number field and Σ its complex embed-dings. For each τ ∈Σ, fix a dominant nonnegative weight λ_{τ} of length n. There is k_{0} such that, for every k ≥ k_{0}, every nonzero N ∈𝒪_{F} , and every finite B ⊂ ℂ, one can choose a finitely supported function c : 𝒪_{F}^{k} →ℂ with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c(a) ̸= 0 =⇒a_{s} ̸= 0, N | a_{s},
1 −τ(a_{s})b ̸= 0 (s < k, τ ∈Σ, b ∈B),and the following polynomial identity in arbitrary root variables z_{τ,j}:
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑c(a)∏∏∏(1 −τ(a_{s})z_{τ,j}) = ∏s_{λτ} (z_{τ}). (175)
a τ∈Σs<kj<n τ∈ΣHere s_{λ} is the Schur polynomial defined by the Jacobi–Trudi determinant, as in the source.
Proof. Every symmetric polynomial is a polynomial in the elementary symmetric functions. One direct proof subtracts its leading symmetric monomial successively: for a lexicographically leading exponent tuple
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a −a
a_{1} ≥· · · ≥a_{n}, the product e^{a}_{1}^{1−a2}· · · e_{n}^{n}_{−}^{−}_{1}^{1n}e_{n}^{an} has exactly that leading monomial with coefficient one. Subtraction decreases the leading monomial at bounded total degree, so the process terminates. The Jacobi– Trudi determinant is symmetric, since its complete symmetric entries are symmetric. Apply this fact to every Schur factor. There is therefore a k_{0}, depending only on the given weights, such that their product is a linear combination of products of k elementary symmetric factors at each embedding, for all k ≥k_{0}; pad by e_{0} = 1.
Introduce coordinates Y_{τ,s}. Expanding ∏_{j}(1 −Y_{τ,s}z_{τ,j}) gives ∑^{n}_{r=0}(−1)^{r}Y^{ r}_{τ,s}e_{r}(z_{τ}). Consequently it suffices to prescribe finitely many moments, one for each exponent array r_{τ,s} ∈{0, . . . , n}, of the evaluation vectors
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏τ(a_{s})^{rτ,s}) .
τ,s_{r}We prove that those vectors span the full space even with the support restrictions in the statement.
Distinct embeddings on 𝒪_{F} are linearly independent as functions. For if a relation of minimal positive support existed, multiplying it by the value of one embedding at u, then subtracting the relation evaluated at ux, would remove that embedding. Choose u on which it differs from another embedding in the relation; the new relation is nonzero and has smaller support, a contradiction. A linear functional killing all vectors (τ(Na))_{τ} would give just such a relation; all τ(N) ̸= 0. These vectors therefore span ℂ^{Σ}. Applying this independently in each of the k coordinates shows that the additive subgroup
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Λ = {(τ(Na_{s}))_{τ,s} : a_{s} ∈𝒪_{F} }spans the whole coordinate space.
An additive subgroup spanning a complex vector space is Zariski dense. Choose a finite basis from it. A polynomial vanishing on the subgroup vanishes after substitution on every integral grid in that basis; successively using the fact that a one-variable polynomial has finitely many roots proves that the substituted polynomial is zero. The same is true for every translate. Removing the zero set of a nonzero polynomial preserves this density: if P vanished off Q = 0, then PQ would vanish on the original dense set, forcing
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P = 0.
Use the nonzero polynomial ∏
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Q(Y ) = Y_{τ,s}∏(1 −Y_{τ,s}b).
τ,s b∈BIts nonvanishing gives all the desired support restrictions on points of Λ. If the moment vectors on these points failed to span, a nonzero linear functional would give a nonzero linear combination of their distinct monomials vanishing on a dense set. This is impossible. The prescribed moment tuple is therefore a finite linear combination of such vectors. Its coefficients give c. Expanding the determinant products and com-paring the prescribed moments proves (175). Because this is a polynomial identity, it remains valid after substitution in every commutative complex algebra. In particular k_{0} was chosen before N, B and all root variables.
Source: SchurDeterminants/PESpan.lean; PSpanE.lean; PSpanProd.lean; PSpanTop.lean; PDenseSub.lean; PDenseOff.lean; PDenseCoset.lean; PExtract.lean; PInterp.lean; PInterpNF.lean.
Lemma 7.9 (The two marked Schur identities). For pairwise distinct complex numbers z_{0}, . . . , z_{n−1}, n ≥1, write z^{[i]} for the list with z_{i} replaced by yz_{i}, and z^{[̸=i]} for the list with all other entries multiplied by y. Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑s_{λ}(z^{[i]})∏^{zj −yzi} = s_{λ}(z)∑y^{λi+n−1−i},
∑i ∏j̸=i^{zj −zi} ∑i ∑
s_{λ}(z^{[̸=i]})^{zi −yzj} = s_{λ}(z) y^{j̸=iλj+i}.
i j̸=i^{zi −zj} iProof. Put V (z) = ∏_{i<j}(z_{i} −z_{j}) and e_{i} = λ_{i} + n −1 −i. The Jacobi–Trudi determinant satisfies s_{λ}(z)V (z) = det(z_{j}^{ei}). Here is an explicit verification of that identity. Partial fractions of ∏_{j}(1 −z_{j}t)^{−1},
or Lagrange interpolation of monomials, gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑_{z}m+n−1
h_{m}(z) = ∏^{j} (m ≥1 −n),
_{j} r̸=j^{(zj −zr)}where h_{0} = 1 and h_{m} = 0 for negative m. Thus the Jacobi–Trudi matrix (h_{λi−i+j})_{i,j} factors into (z_{r}^{ei})_{i,r} and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
(z_{r}^{j}/_{q̸=r}(z_{r} −z_{q}))_{r,j}. The second determinant is 1/V (z), by the Vandermonde determinant and pairing the factors in its denominator. This proves the identity when the roots are nonzero and distinct, and then as a polynomial identity everywhere by density, including zero roots.
Expand the alternant by permutations. In the sum where one column at a time is scaled, each permutation term is multiplied in total by ∑_{i}y^{ei}. Hence the sum of those altered alternants is the original alternant times that power sum. Divide by∏ V (z). The ratio of the altered Vandermonde to the original is exactly _{j̸=i}(z_{j} −yz_{i})/(z_{j} −z_{i}). This proves the first identity. For the second, scale all columns except one. The same permutation expansion gives powers ∑_{j̸=i}e_{j}. The Vandermonde ratio also contains the common factor y^{(n−1)(n−2)/2}, from pairs omitting the unscaled column. Cancel it as a polynomial factor; the remaining exponent is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑e_{j} −(n −1)(n −2)/2 =∑λ_{j} + i.
j̸=i j̸=iThe other factors are ∏_{j̸=i}(z_{i} −yz_{j})/(z_{i} −z_{j}). This proves the second identity also at y = 0, by polynomial identity rather than division by its value there.
Source: SchurDeterminants/SchurYClrOf.lean; PMixDet.lean; SchurYOf.lean; POffPow.lean; POffRed.lean; SchurYOffOf.lean; PVdmSplit.lean; Vdm.lean.
Proposition 7.10 (Construction of the finite Hodge cut). The root-weight identity used in (174) admits a finite cut by nonzero even integral endomorphisms. Its lower bound on the number of fiber factors depends only on the weight array. The two exponent lists are exactly the two lists displayed above, including their constant shifts.
Proof. Take the interpolation coefficients of Lemma 7.8 with N = 2 and B empty. At a distinguished pair of embeddings t,t^{̄}, order the roots so that z_{t,j}̄ = z_{t,j}. This is possible because conjugation maps the root multiset of a polynomial to that of its conjugate polynomial; separability makes the orderings related by a permutation. Schur polynomials are symmetric, so this permutation has no effect on any Schur factor.
For a root marked by i, substitute into (175) the following root arrays: scale only entry i at t, all entries except i at t^{̄}, and all entries by y^{ϵτ} at each other embedding. Multiply by
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B_{i}(y) =∏^{zt,j −yzt,i},
j̸=i^{zt,j −zt,i}then sum over i. Expanding the determinant products shows that each summand on the left is precisely the source’s local fiber weight times its ball-tangent weight. For example its two distinguished factors for one integral endomorphism a are
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(1 −t(a)yz_{t,i})∏(1 −t(a)z_{t,j}),
∏j̸=i
(1 −t^{̄}(a)z_{t,i}) (1 −t^{̄}(a)yz_{t,j}).
j̸=iThe other embedding factors are ∏_{j}(1 −τ(a)y^{ϵτ} z_{τ,j}). These are all factors of the local weight; none is dropped by the interpolation.
If λ_{t}̄ is the constant m, its Schur polynomial is the determinant character (∏_{j}z_{t,j}̄ )^{m}. Scaling all but one
entry contributes y^{(n−1)m}, independently of the mark. Homogeneity gives y^{Ct} from the other embeddings. The first identity of Lemma 7.9 now gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏_{sλτ (zτ)}) ∑_{y}(n−1)m+Ct+λt(i)+n−1−i_{.}
τ iHomogeneity and the determinant-character formula follow at once from the alternant identity: a common scaling gives total degree ∑_{i}λ_{i}, and adding m to every λ_{i} factors ∏_{j}z_{j}^{m} from the alternant columns.
If instead λ_{t} is the constant m, that factor contributes y^{m}. In this branch the roots at t have common squared absolute value q ̸= 0, as required by the source. Therefore z_{t,j}̄ = q/z_{t,j}, and direct cancellation gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{z}t,j^{ −yz}t,i_{=}^{z}t,i^{̄ −yz}t,j^{̄}_{.}
z_{t,j} −z_{t,i} z_{t,i}̄ −z_{t,j}̄Apply the second marked Schur identity at t^{̄}. Its result is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏_{sλτ (zτ)}) ∑_{y}m+Ct+∑_{j̸=i}λ_{t}̄(j)+i_{.}
τ iThese are exactly the two required Hodge lists. The coefficients c are independent of all root values, the marked index, and y, and their support consists of nonzero multiples of two. This proves the asserted finite cut and its order of quantifiers.
Source: SchurDeterminants/FibreSum.lean; PFibre.lean; PFibreOff.lean; SphericalCoordinates/PRootSumW.lean; PRootSumWOff.lean; LefschetzSigmaSums/PRootW.lean.
Lemma 7.11 (The even integral cut has no fixed tangent direction). Let an abelian scheme over a complex base carry an 𝒪_{F} -action. Every nonzero a ∈𝒪_{F} acts by a finite etale surjective isogeny, and so does a product of such actions on a fiber power. In the local lattice calculation, if an integral endomorphism has complex eigenvalue e, and τ : F ↪→ℂ, then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 −τ(2a)e ̸= 0 (a ∈𝒪_{F} ).Proof. For nonzero a, the finite quotient 𝒪_{F} /(a) is killed by its positive order M. Hence M = ab for an integer M > 0 and some b ∈𝒪_{F} . The corresponding endomorphisms commute and both composites are multiplication by M. Multiplication by M on a characteristic-zero abelian scheme is finite etale and surjective. Its differential is M times the identity. The differential of the a-action is therefore invertible. The two factorization identities also make the a-action surjective and put its kernel in the finite group scheme of M-torsion. Properness and these finite fibers make it finite; the differential criterion makes it etale. The product argument applies coordinate by coordinate, and conjugating by the tower’s specified isomorphisms preserves these properties.
For the second assertion, use the integral characteristic polynomial of the lattice endomorphism. Cayley– Hamilton annihilates it on the lattice and hence on its real span, which is the full complex vector space in the period model. Thus its complex matrix is annihilated by that monic integer polynomial, and each eigenvalue e is an algebraic integer. So are τ(a) and their product. If 1 −τ(2a)e = 0, then τ(a)e = 1/2 would be an algebraic integer. Substituting 1/2 in a monic integer polynomial of degree r, then multiplying by 2^{r}, would give an odd integer equal to zero. This is impossible. This proves the assertion even when a = 0.
Source: IsogenyEtaleTranslation/PAlFEt.lean:50--83; SphericalCoordinates/PEvIntegral.lean.
Proposition 7.12 (The marked ball tangent calculation). In the source’s complex period linear algebra, sup-pose the commuting 𝒪_{F} -action and an invertible endomorphism H are simultaneously diagonalized by B, with embedding types τ_{i} and eigenvalues e_{i}. Suppose a distinguished type t occurs once, at i_{0}, its conjugate occurs n −1 times, and every other conjugate pair has only one nonzero type multiplicity. Put µ = e_{i0}. On the constrained period tangent space, the action Q →→HQH^{−1} has eigenvalues
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{^{ µ}_{ej} : τ_{j} = t^{̄}}.In particular its dimension is n −1. If {µ} ⊔{e_{j} : τ_{j} = t^{̄}} is the distinct-root list z_{0}, . . . , z_{n−1} of the source polynomial, with µ = z_{i}, its normalized determinant is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏
det(1 −yT) z_{j} −yz_{i}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
.
det(1 −T) ^{=} z_{j} −z_{i}
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j̸=i
Proof. First consider symmetric matrices S satisfying
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
S_{ij}τ_{j}(a) = τ_{i}(a)S_{ij} (a ∈𝒪_{F} ).A nonzero entry forces τ_{j} = ̄τ_{i}, since equality on 𝒪_{F} implies equality on its fraction field. The multiplicity assumptions then force i = i_{0} or j = i_{0}. Thus such a matrix is uniquely determined by its row (S_{i0j})_{τj=̄t}. Conversely any such row defines a permitted symmetric matrix by putting the same entries in the corre-sponding column and zero elsewhere. The diagonal entry at i_{0} is zero because t ̸= t^{̄}. This gives a linear isomorphism with ℂ^{n−1}.
We check that this calculation applies to the actual period coordinates rather than only to an assumed symmetric coordinate model. Let M_{0} be the positive definite Hermitian matrix for the polarized period lattice, and put P = B and N = B^{t}M_{0}P. The adjointness of the 𝒪_{F} -action for the polarization gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ρ(a)^{t}M_{0} = M_{0}ρ(̄a).This equality follows already from the lattice pairing: its two imaginary parts agree on lattice vectors; real spanning extends the equality to all vectors, and testing a coordinate vector and its multiple by ^{√}−1 recovers both real and imaginary matrix entries. After diagonalization it says that N commutes with each diagonal type matrix. Since type t occurs once, column i_{0} of N is zero off the diagonal. Its diagonal entry is nonzero: it is the positive Hermitian squared length of the nonzero i_{0}-column of B.
For the constrained tangent matrices Q, the source’s period equations say precisely that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
S = P^{t}Q^{t}M_{0}Pis symmetric and satisfies the displayed embedding constraints. All matrices used in this change of coordi-nates are invertible. Writing R = B^{−1}QP, the equality S = R^{t}N and symmetry give S_{i0j} = R_{i0j}N_{i0i0}. The nonzero constant N_{i0i0} shows that the row of R is also a coordinate isomorphism on this space. Under the given endomorphism it changes by
R −−→ diag(e_{i})R diag(e_{i})^{−1}.
Its distinguished row is therefore multiplied entrywise by µ/e_{j}. This proves the asserted spectrum and dimension.
Take the determinant of 1−yT in these coordinates. The distinctness of the root list and nonvanishing of its entries show that none of the ratios is one. The denominator at y = 1 is consequently nonzero. Dividing its product formula gives exactly the stated normalized determinant, including the orientation of its ratios.
Source: SphericalCoordinates/PTspDiag.lean; PBallChar.lean, including the private adjointness identity andthe coordinate changes P, N and the distinguished row; PEigTop.lean.
Proposition 7.13 (Summing the fiber fixed points). On a local branch of a finite-etale correspondence, suppose a base fixed point has tangent matrix T from Proposition 7.12, and the fiber is a complex abelian variety A = V /Λ on which the branch is the affine map x →→Dx+b. Suppose DΛ ⊂Λ and det(1−D) ̸= 0. The sum of the local holomorphic Lefschetz terms over all fiber fixed points is
det(1 −yT) det(1 −yD) det(1 −D). det(1 −T)
For the even integral cut this is exactly its marked local weight used in Proposition 7.10.
Proof. Since 1 −D is invertible on V , it induces a surjective isogeny of the complex torus. The equation (1 −D)x = b has a solution, and its solutions are a torsor under Λ/(1 −D)Λ. The index of this lattice is the absolute value of the real determinant of 1 −D, namely | det_{ℂ}(1 −D)|^{2}. One can check the index by taking a Z-basis of the lattice and comparing fundamental parallelotope volumes; the real determinant of a complex matrix is its determinant times its complex conjugate. The number of fixed points is therefore exactly det(1 −D)det(1 −D).
The total tangent map is block triangular, with diagonal blocks T, D: differentiation of the map on the base gives the first block, while differentiation along the fiber gives the second. Consequently each fixed point has local term
det(1 −yT) det(1 −yD) det(1 −T) det(1 −D)^{.}
Multiplying by the number of fixed points cancels exactly the holomorphic fiber denominator and gives the displayed answer. It retains its antiholomorphic determinant factor; discarding that factor would change the root-weight identity.
For a fiber power and a diagonal integral endomorphism a, the eigenvalues of D are τ_{i}(a_{s})e_{i}, for all s, i. If every a_{s} is even, their factors at one in det(1 −D) are nonzero by Lemma 7.11. The base denominator is nonzero by the distinct-root assertion in the preceding proposition. Thus all the fixed points in this calculation are transverse. Group the eigenvalues by embedding type. At t the list is {µ}, at t^{̄} it is the conjugates of the other roots, and the remaining multiplicities are the prescribed ϵ_{τ}-lists. Expanding det(1 −yD)det(1 −D) now gives exactly the distinguished and remaining factors written in the proof of Proposition 7.10. Its base factor is B_{i}(y). This proves the final identification and its signs.
Source: SphericalCoordinates/PFibDet.lean; PFibW.lean; PEigTop.lean; EtaleClopenDescent/ComplexCountRegularMarkedPoints.lean; IsogenyEtaleTranslation/PBridge.lean.
Lemma 7.14 (Even sign changes that are finite-adelic norms). Let M be a CM field, with conjugation c, and let S be a conjugation-stable set of complex embeddings with 4 | |S|. For every rational prime p, there are a ∈(M^{+})^{×} and u ∈(𝔸^{(}_{f}^{p)}⊗_{ℚ} M)^{×} such that τ(a) < 0 exactly at the embeddings in S, and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
uū = 1 ⊗a.
The positive signs hold at every embedding outside S, rather than only at a chosen set of representatives.
Proof. First take two distinct real places of K = M^{+}. Form a K-idele y equal to −1 there, to +1 at its other infinite places, and to one at all finite places. In the quadratic extension M/K, its Artin image is one: the two real components each give the nontrivial element, while all other factors are trivial. Finite global reciprocity, in the norm-quotient form used in Lemma 7.77, therefore writes y = h Nm(z) with h ∈K^{×} and
z an M-idele. At infinity a norm from ℂ^{×} is positive, so h is negative precisely at the prescribed two places. At every finite place 1 = h Nm(z_{v}), so h = Nm(z_{v}^{−1}). The finite components z_{v}^{−1} form one finite idele of norm h. This is the source’s two-place construction, including its finite norm equation.
Embeddings of a CM field come in pairs under conjugation. The set S therefore represents |S|/2 real places of M^{+}, an even number. Partition them into pairs. Apply the two-place construction to each pair and multiply the resulting elements and finite ideles. A place in the set acquires one negative factor, and every other factor is positive there; outside the set all factors are positive. Norms multiply, giving a finite idele of norm the desired nonzero a.
We spell out the tensor model in the statement. For any number field L, the canonical map
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
𝔸_{f,ℚ} ⊗_{ℚ} L −→𝔸_{f,L}is an algebra isomorphism. At each rational prime it is the usual product decomposition ℚ_{q} ⊗L =∏_{w|q}L_{w}. An integral basis of 𝒪_{L} identifies the integral lattice on both sides: completion of the finite free ring 𝒪_{L} is ∏_{w|q}𝒪_{Lw}, by the Chinese remainder theorem at powers of the primes above q. Thus coordinates in that basis are integral at almost all primes in both directions. This proves the restricted product, and not just the separate local, isomorphism. It respects field automorphisms and the diagonal copy of L. Transport the finite norm witness by this isomorphism and omit the factor at p. Multiplication and conjugation are preserved, giving exactly uū = 1 ⊗a.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ ExistsGlobalIffEtaProd.lean; ExistsBaseElementNegativeAtTwoEmbeddings.lean; ExistsRealSubfieldNegativeTwoPlacesNormEverywher.lean; ExistsTotallyRealEvenNegPlacesLocalNorm.lean; AdelicLatticeProofs/ExistsTensorFiniteAdeleEquiv.lean.
Proposition 7.15 (The polynomial change to a definite pair). Fix the source’s unitary datum with one infinite place v of signature (1, n −1), all other signatures negative definite, and odd n. Fix an irreducible regular polynomial P_{0} of degree n, and a root µ at v. There is a polynomial A, depending only on P_{0}, µ, v, which converts every definite pair with polynomial P_{0} into a pair marked by µ, and conversely. It preserves the similitude element, its multiplier and the finite-adelic isometry class. The two operations are inverse on the source’s scalar-conjugacy classes.
Proof. We make the objects in this assertion explicit. Let C be the central simple algebra of the datum, with involution ∗. A pair has a unit β = β^{∗}, an invertible γ ∈C, and a rational multiplier c_{0} ̸= 0, satisfying
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
γβγ^{∗}= c_{0}β.Its regularity says that the minimal polynomial of γ has degree n and is separable. It also includes the specified finite-adelic trivialization of β. At a complex splitting ψ_{w} of C, use the Hermitian matrix H_{β,w} = G_{w}ψ_{w}(β^{−1}). A definite pair means that this matrix is positive definite at v and negative definite elsewhere. A marked pair means it has the original signature (1, n −1) at v, with a positive γ-eigenline of eigenvalue µ, and is negative definite elsewhere. These are the source’s sign conventions.
If neither kind of pair exists, the assertion is vacuous and take A = 1. Otherwise a pair fixes a positive multiplier c_{0}, and every conjugate root of P_{0} has squared absolute value c_{0}. For a definite pair, evaluate the similitude identity on an eigenvector of its definite Hermitian form and cancel its nonzero squared length. For a marked pair, its positive eigenline at v is nondegenerate and has a negative definite orthogonal complement. That complement is γ-stable: the similitude identity and the nonzero eigenvalue make orthogonality to the line invariant. On the line and on its complement the same definite calculation gives squared modulus c_{0}. At the other infinite places the whole form is negative definite. These assertions cover every complex embed-ding, using conjugation for the other representative at each infinite place. The eigenvalue list is exactly the
root list of P_{0}: its n independent powers remain independent after scalar extension, and the complex splitting of the central simple algebra is faithful. Hence the complex matrix has minimal-polynomial degree at least n, while its characteristic polynomial has degree n; Cayley–Hamilton and the mapped annihilating polynomial force both to equal the monic mapped P_{0}. The multiplier is then determined by |µ|^{2}, independently of the chosen pair.
Put M = F[X]/(P_{0}), with generator x. The common absolute-value identity equips M with conjugation extending that on F, and sends x to c_{0}/x. To verify this algebraically, compose the embedding of M at one root with complex conjugation. Its image is still in that embedded field, because the conjugate of x is c_{0}/x and the conjugates of the coefficients lie in F. Transporting back gives the required automorphism. It squares to one on F and x, and the absolute-value identity shows that every complex embedding intertwines it with complex conjugation. It is nontrivial on the CM field F. Its fixed field is therefore totally real and M is CM.
Choose the embedding η : M ↪→ℂ over v with η(x) = µ. Let S consist of the other embeddings over v, together with their conjugates. Separability gives exactly n embeddings over each embedding of F, and a CM embedding cannot equal its conjugate. Consequently |S| = 2(n −1), divisible by four since n is odd. Apply Lemma 7.14. It gives a = ̄a, positive at η and ̄η, negative at the other embeddings over v, positive at every other embedding, and a finite-adelic norm witness. Write a = A(x). This single polynomial is chosen before any particular pair with polynomial P_{0}.
For each such pair there is an embedding j : M ↪→ C with j(x) = γ. It is obtained by evaluating polynomials in γ; irreducibility of P_{0} makes this a field embedding. The similitude identity gives on all of
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
M
β j(b)^{∗}= j(^{̄}b) β.Check it first on F and x, where it is exactly the involution on coefficients and the similitude identity, and extend by addition, multiplication and inversion. Thus j(a)β is again symmetric and satisfies the same similitude identity.
Starting with a definite pair Q, set β_{P} = j(a)β_{Q}. In a γ-eigenbasis the Hermitian form H_{βQ,w} is diag-onal. Indeed distinct eigenvalues λ_{i} with |λ_{i}|^{2}= c_{0} satisfy λ_{i}λ_{j} ̸= c_{0} for i ̸= j, so the similitude identity forces all off-diagonal Gram entries to vanish. Every element j(b) is diagonal in the same basis, with entries the embeddings of b over w. Replacing β_{Q} by β_{P} therefore divides each real Gram entry by the correspond-ing embedding of a. At v it leaves the marked entry positive and makes the other n −1 entries negative. Elsewhere all entries remain negative. This is the required signature, with the same marked eigenline. Con-versely put β_{Q} = j(a^{−1})β_{P} . Multiplication of the marked form’s Gram entries by the embeddings of a makes them all positive at v, and keeps them negative elsewhere. Nonzero Hermitian diagonal entries with the same numbers of positive and negative signs give congruent forms: rescale each coordinate by the posi-tive square root of its absolute value and permute coordinates. This supplies the real trivializations required of the constructed pairs.
Map the finite norm witness u into the adelic algebra by j, and denote its image by U. It commutes with γ. The displayed involution identity gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Uβ_{Q}U^{∗}= j(uū)β_{Q} = j(a)β_{Q} = β_{P} .Thus U transports the finite form, and its inverse transports it back. In particular an existing finite-adelic trivialization remains one after composing with this isometry. The two operations multiply by j(a) and j(a)^{−1}, so they are inverse on representatives with the same γ. They also respect conjugation and positive rational rescaling: polynomial evaluation commutes with conjugation, and the polynomial depends only on the common P_{0}. They therefore descend to inverse maps on the scalar-conjugacy classes.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ ExistsPolynomialMoveDefiniteSimilitudePairMarked.lean, especially dexists\_basis, dreal\_move, real\_back, card\_sset, core and move\_definite; MarkedFieldPairsEquivDefiniteFieldPairsOdd.lean.
Lemma 7.16 (Preservation of the orbital stabilizer weights). The two pairs in Proposition 7.15 have equal orbital terms for the same test functions, including the reciprocal stabilizer-cardinality factors and the aux-iliary local term at p.
Proof. For a regular irreducible γ, its centralizer in C is the field F[γ]. Indeed after a complex splitting, its distinct eigenvalues make its matrix centralizer the n-dimensional diagonal algebra. The n independent powers of γ already span a subalgebra of that dimension, proving equality by extension of scalars. The same centralizer identity holds after extension to the adelic coefficient ring: the centralizer is the kernel of the linear map x →→xγ −γx, and extension from a field preserves that kernel. It is consequently commutative there as well.
The rational centralizer group for a pair is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Z_{β,γ} = {(y, s) : yγ = γy, yβy^{∗}= sβ}.For β_{P} = A(γ)β_{Q}, every y commuting with γ commutes with the invertible factor A(γ). Cancelling that factor shows Z_{βP ,γ} = Z_{βQ,γ} as actual subgroups, with the same multiplier coordinate s.
Let (x, t) be a finite trivialization for Q. The compatible trivialization for P is (xU^{−1}, t), where Uβ_{Q}U^{∗}= β_{P} and Uγ = γU. For every element of the rational centralizer, commutativity of the extended centralizer gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
xU^{−1}yUx^{−1}= xyx^{−1}.Thus its embeddings in the finite adelic group, computed in these two trivializations, are equal. Their auxil-iary p-embeddings are also equal; they use the unchanged γ, c_{0}. The distinguished element of the centralizer is the same pair (γ, c_{0}).
The orbital term is the sum over the resulting double-coset orbits of the product of the two test-function values, multiplied by the inverse cardinality of its stabilizer. Equal embedded groups have equal orbit re-lations and stabilizers, and the preceding identities make the test arguments equal on every representative. Hence the terms are equal term by term. Changing a trivialization conjugates the embedded group; mul-tiplication by that conjugating element gives the inverse bijections of the orbit sets and their stabilizers. Conjugation-invariance under the level groups makes the summands independent of the chosen representa-tives. Therefore the calculation applies to the arbitrary trivializations selected in the definitions. Finally the condition for the auxiliary local term to exist depends only on γ, c_{0}. If it fails both terms are zero; if it holds, take the same witness in the two equal point sums.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ KottwitzTermEqDefinitePairOfLocalIsometry.lean, pointSum\_equiv, cent\_eq, termAt\_eq and term\_eq\_of\_local\_isom; KottwitzPairTermEqPointSumAnyTrivialisation.lean.
Proposition 7.17 (Regrouping marks into the full root sum). Assume the finite-support assertion for the nonzero regular marked orbital terms of the chosen compact tests. Assume also that reducible polynomial classes have zero term, which is part of the source’s good-test condition. Then the marked-class sum equals the definite-class sum weighted by the sum over all roots:
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑ (( ∑ )
c(P_{0}, µ_{P} ) term(P) = c(P_{0}, µ)) term(Q).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
[P] mmarked [Q] mdefinite,irr µ:P_{0}(µ)=0On each side P_{0} denotes the polynomial of the class in that summand, with roots at the unique distinguished infinite place.
Proof. For each monic degree-n polynomial choose an ordering µ_{0}, . . . , µ_{n−1} of its complex roots. The relevant polynomials are separable, so this list has no repetitions. A regular pair has at most one positive eigenline mark. Its eigenspaces are one-dimensional. Distinct eigenspaces are orthogonal for its Hermitian form, by the similitude identity and their common squared modulus. Two different positive eigenlines would therefore span a positive definite plane, contrary to positive index one. Thus if a marked pair has mark µ_{i}, exactly one index in the ordered list gives its summand; all other mark conditions fail.
Split the marked sum into its n sums according to that index. A class with no mark contributes zero. A marked class with reducible polynomial has zero orbital term by hypothesis, so it contributes zero as well. For fixed i, the polynomial change in Proposition 7.15 is a bijection from the irreducible classes marked by µ_{i} to all irreducible definite classes. It preserves the polynomial, and Lemma 7.16 preserves every orbital term. Reindexing that sum therefore gives ∑_{[Q]}c(P_{0}, µ_{i}) term(Q).
The finite-support hypothesis justifies these reindexings and the interchange with the finite sum over i. It also implies finite support on the definite side: use any one root selector and the term-preserving bijection to transport the supporting set. Sum over i, then group the root weights inside each definite summand. This proves the formula, retaining each stabilizer factor exactly once and each root exactly once. No division by the number of roots or by the number of marks occurs.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ MarkedFieldPairsSumEqDefinitePairsSum.lean; MarkWeightedFixedPointDefinitePairOddOfCounts.lean:14--114.
Proposition 7.18 (The finite automorphic trace formula). Let Γ be a subgroup of a group H, let K ⊂H, and let ρ : Γ → GL(V ) be a finite-dimensional complex representation. Suppose Γ\H/K is finite, each Γ_{x} = Γ ∩xKx^{−1} is finite, and F : H →ℂ is bi-K-invariant with finite support on H/K. On the space of functions satisfying
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ϕ(γxk) = ρ(γ)ϕ(x),
define T_{F} ϕ(x) =∑_{hK}F(h)ϕ(xh). Then
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑_{F(x}−1_{γx)}
Tr(T_{F} ) = Tr(ρ(γ))_{−1} . (176)
[γ]_{Γ} x∈C_{Γ}(γ)\H/K^{|CΓ(γ) ∩xKx|}All the sums have finite effective support.
Proof. Choosing one representative for each of the finitely many double cosets identifies the form space with ⊕_{x}V^{ Γx}. The condition at the stabilizer is necessary for a value at x to extend consistently; it is also sufficient by the displayed equivariance rule. Thus this space is finite-dimensional. Bi-invariance of F makes the right-coset sum independent of representatives and right K-invariant; left Γ-equivariance follows by linearity of ρ(γ). Hence T_{F} acts on this form space.
The diagonal block at x receives exactly the cosets with xh ∈ΓxK. Write hK = x^{−1}γxK; two γ’s give the same coset exactly when they differ by right multiplication by Γ_{x}. On V^{Γx} the block therefore is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
M_{x} = ∑ F(x^{−1}γx)ρ(γ).
γ∈Γ/ΓxOnly finitely many cosets occur. The Reynolds operator P_{x} = |Γ_{x}|^{−1} ∑_{δ∈Γx}ρ(δ) projects V onto V^{ Γx}: averaging is invariant, and it fixes each invariant vector. If the displayed finite sum is viewed as an operator on all of V , its product with P_{x} has range in that invariant space. In a basis adapted to the space, its trace on V is the trace of the diagonal block on V^{Γx}. Expanding that product, and using right K-invariance for the ambiguity γδ, gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
1 ∑
Tr(M_{x}) = F(x^{−1}γx) Tr(ρ(γ)).
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|Γ_{x}|_{γ∈Γ}This inner sum is finite: a contributing right coset belongs to the finite support of F, and has at most |Γ_{x}| lifts to Γ.
Sum over the finitely many x’s. To regroup this sum by conjugacy, fix a Γ-conjugacy class of γ. For fixed ΓxK, the group Γ_{x} acts on its conjugates by conjugation. Both the test value and the representation trace are constant on those orbits. An orbit has size |Γ_{x}|/|C_{Γ}(γ^{′})∩Γ_{x}|. Its contribution to the averaged sum is therefore divided by precisely the cardinality of that intersection. These orbits are in bijection with the C_{Γ}(γ)-double cosets inside ΓxK: send the conjugate ηγη^{−1} at x to the class of η^{−1}x. Changing η by its centralizer and changing the conjugate by Γ_{x} give exactly the two quotient relations. Its stabilizer cardinality is that in (176). This proves the formula. The original finite support of all the diagonal blocks also proves finite support after regrouping, so no convergence assertion is hidden in this interchange of sums.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ HeckeTraceDefiniteFormEqSumConjClasses.lean, hecke, heckeTrace\_eq and heckeTrace\_eq\_orbital; UnfoldedEqOrbitalReps.lean; the finite\_trace\_formula calledthere.
For a fixed definite form in the source, the finiteness hypotheses here have the following concrete expla-nation. Its rational group is the group of pairs (g, c) with gβg^{∗}= cβ, c ∈ℚ^{×}. Over an algebraic closure it is a product of general linear groups and one common multiplier torus: the involution exchanges the two mem-bers of each CM embedding pair, and the equation determines the second matrix from the first and c. It is therefore a connected reductive ℚ-group. Borel’s class-finiteness theorem used in Proposition 7.98 gives its finite double-coset set at every compact open level. A multiplier torus does not obstruct this class-finiteness theorem; the no-character hypothesis was used for volume statements, not here.
The away-from-p factor and the auxiliary local factor in the source are its finite adelic points in the chosen trivializations. At p, the involution interchanges the two CM factors; the chosen matrix factor and the common multiplier recover the other as its adjoint inverse times the multiplier. This gives the product identification and its inverse. The commensurable level subgroups are compact open under that identifi-cation. The diagonal rational embedding is injective, as evaluation in any completion is injective on the finite-dimensional rational algebra.
Its level stabilizers are finite. A compact subgroup of ℚ^{×}_{q} has zero valuation, since its valuation image is a finite subgroup of Z. Thus a rational multiplier in a level stabilizer has valuation zero at every finite prime. It is positive by the definite real form, and hence is one. The real matrices of such an element lie in compact unitary groups for the definite forms. Its finite adelic coordinates lie in a fixed compact set, so, in any rational basis of the algebra, their denominators have one common bound. Real compactness bounds their real coordinates. A bounded subset of M^{−1}Z^{r} is finite, proving the stabilizer assertion. Finally a compactly supported test function has finite support on right cosets of a compact open subgroup: its image in the discrete quotient is compact. These verify every finiteness hypothesis for the fixed-form trace calculation.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ FiniteDoubleCosetDefiniteHermitianFormLevel.lean; DefiniteFormStabilizerFiniteAwayFromP.lean; HeckeTestProductSupportFiniteLeftCosets.lean; SimilitudePairAdelicProdUnramifiedEmbeddingInjec.lean.
Lemma 7.19 (Finitely many involution norm classes). Let E be a finite-dimensional reduced commutative ℚ-algebra with involution τ. Suppose some unit j satisfies τ(j) = −j. Fix a finite set of rational primes S. Among fixed units a = τ(a), consider those which, at every prime ℓ∈/S, are a rational local scalar times an involution norm, up to a local integral unit. There are only finitely many such classes modulo
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ℚ^{×}{eτ(e) : e ∈E^{×}}.The same conclusion applies to the source’s two-sided integral-ratio formulation of this local condition.
Proof. A reduced finite-dimensional commutative algebra is a product of number fields: it is Artinian, has finitely many maximal ideals with zero intersection, and the Chinese remainder theorem identifies it with their field quotients. The involution either exchanges two factors, or fixes a factor with an involution on that field. On an exchanged pair its norm map onto the fixed subalgebra is surjective: (b, 1) has fixed norm (b, b), with the inter-factor isomorphism understood. On a stable field factor the involution is nontrivial, because a fixed involution would give j = −j in that factor, contrary to invertibility. Thus it gives a quadratic extension L_{i}/K_{i}. The fixed units of E modulo involution norms reduce to the products of K_{i}^{×}/N_{Li/Ki}L^{×}_{i}.
Enlarge S by the finitely many primes ramifying in these number fields and extensions. Away from it, each local quadratic factor is split or unramified. In an unramified quadratic factor, all units are norms and the valuation of a norm is even; this follows from local reciprocity, whose unit subgroup acts trivially on that unramified extension. Split factors have no norm restriction.
For a given fixed unit a, choose a nonzero integer D making both Da and Da^{−1} integral in every factor. Outside the primes dividing D, the element is a unit. At a prime dividing D but outside S, write the rational scalar in the local hypothesis as ℓ^{kℓ}u_{ℓ}, with u_{ℓ} an ℓ-adic unit. Set
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q = ∏ ℓ^{kℓ}∈ℚ^{×}.
ℓ|D, ℓ∈/SAt that prime, q differs from the specified scalar by a local unit, which is a norm in every unramified factor. At other primes q is a local unit. It follows that a/q is a norm at all places outside the fixed finite set above S. In the source’s formulation, the ratios and their inverses are integral after multiplication by an integer prime to ℓ; therefore they are local units. This proves the same implication from its exact two-sided equations.
Now record at the places above S and at infinity the local norm classes of a/q. There are finitely many possible tuples. Each local quadratic norm quotient has order at most two, by local reciprocity; at a real nonsplit place it is the sign quotient, and at a complex or split place it is trivial. Two elements with the same tuple differ by a local norm everywhere. The cyclic Hasse norm theorem in Proposition 10.46 then makes their quotient a global norm in every quadratic factor. They are the same involution-norm class. Choose one representative of each tuple that actually occurs, and assemble representatives in the product algebra. The resulting finite list represents all the required classes, with the factor q accounting for the rational scalar.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ FiniteClassesFixedUnitsModRatNorms.lean; NormClassFiniteOfReducedRatAlgebra.lean; InvolutionNormClassRemoveRationalFactor.lean; FiniteFixedUnitClassesCentralizerRegular.lean.
Lemma 7.20 (Finiteness from one denominator bound). Fix a number field F, a degree n, and a positive integer N. There are only finitely many monic polynomials P ∈ F[X] of degree n with the following properties: all conjugate roots have one common absolute value r_{P} > 0, and for every such root z, both Nz and Nz^{−1} are algebraic integers.
Proof. For a root z, every conjugate of the nonzero algebraic integer Nz^{−1} has modulus N/r_{P} . Its absolute norm to ℚ is a nonzero integer, so (N/r_{P} )^{d}≥1, where d is its degree. Thus r_{P} ≤N. In particular every conjugate of Nz has modulus at most N^{2}, and its degree is at most [F : ℚ]n.
There are finitely many algebraic integers of bounded degree with all conjugates in a fixed disk. Indeed their monic minimal polynomials have integer coefficients. Each coefficient is an elementary symmetric sum of conjugates, bounded by the corresponding binomial coefficient times a power of the radius. There are finitely many integer coefficient tuples in these bounds, and finitely many roots of each resulting nonzero polynomial. Apply this to Nz. Hence all the roots z, in one fixed complex embedding, belong to one finite set. A monic degree-n polynomial is determined by its root multiset; only finitely many multisets of size n can be chosen from that set. Injectivity of F ↪→ℂ then proves the assertion over F.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ FiniteMarkedPairClassesDegreeOneTermNeZero.lean, norm\_le\_of\_isIntegral\_inv and finite\_pol\_marked'; FiniteMonicRootsBddMulIsIntegral.lean; FinitePolynomialsBoundedDenom.lean.
Lemma 7.21 (The cofinite local norm condition for pair ratios). Fix a regular pair (β_{0}, γ, c_{0}) and the com-pact support of an away-from-p test. There is one finite set of rational primes S such that every pair (β, γ, c_{0}) with a nonzero orbital test value satisfies the local scalar-norm hypothesis of Lemma 7.19 for
E = Cent_{C}(γ), τ(b) = β_{0}b^{∗}β_{0}^{−1}, a = ββ_{0}^{−1}.
Proof. The regular separable polynomial makes E a commutative reduced algebra: over a splitting field, γ has distinct eigenvalues and its centralizer is the diagonal algebra. The ratio a commutes with γ, by comparing the two similitude equations and cancelling their nonzero common multiplier. Symmetry of β, β_{0} then gives τ(a) = a. The same equations make τ an involution of E. A nonzero purely imaginary element of the central CM field is an invertible element j ∈E with τ(j) = −j.
Choose an integral model of the algebra, its involution, β_{0}^{±1} and γ^{±1}. Invert one integer to clear their structure constants and the nonzero discriminant of the regular polynomial. Outside the resulting finite set, the order in E generated by γ is a maximal unramified etale order. The ambient central simple order is a matrix order over each local center. Here is the usual integral justification of that last assertion. The map from the algebra tensored with its opposite to its endomorphism ring is an isomorphism over its center; invert its determinant too. Its residue algebra is then central simple over a finite field, hence a matrix algebra by Wedderburn’s theorem. A primitive diagonal idempotent lifts over the complete discrete valuation ring: Newton iteration for e^{2}−e applies, since 2e −1 is invertible modulo the maximal ideal. Its corner has rank one, by reduction and Nakayama, and its column has rank n. The action on that column is an isomorphism onto its matrix endomorphism ring, since its reduction is one and its determinant is a unit. This proves the claimed matrix order. The finite-field input is the exact statement of Milne, Chapter IV, Theorem 4.1, p. 138.[23]
Enlarge the finite set by p and by the exceptional primes of the compact test support. At every remaining prime all test values lie in the integral unit group. A nonzero orbital summand provides a trivialization and a conjugating matrix k such that kγk^{−1} and its inverse are integral, and kβk^{∗}= λI for some rational local scalar λ ̸= 0.
The lattice k^{−1}𝒪^{n} is stable under the maximal etale order generated by γ. The representation has rank one over that order: regularity gives one occurrence of each root, and the sum of the local field degrees is n. A lattice of rank one over a product of unramified discrete valuation rings is a product of principal fractional ideals. Consequently k^{−1}𝒪^{n}= z𝒪^{n} for some z ∈E_{ℓ}^{×}, and m = kz is an integral invertible matrix.
Substitute β = aβ_{0} and the relation β_{0}z^{∗}= τ(z)β_{0} in its trivialization equation. It says that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
m(_{zτ}^{a}_{(z)}β_{0})m^{∗}= λI.Both m and β_{0} are integral units. Hence a/(λzτ(z)) is an integral unit in the matrix order, and belongs to E_{ℓ}. The intersection of the centralizer with this order is its maximal etale order: in the rank-one etale module its centralizer is the order itself. The ratio is therefore a fixed unit of that etale order. Norms onto fixed units are surjective on its unramified quadratic factors by local reciprocity, and on its exchanged factors explicitly. It follows that a is a scalar times an involution norm at this prime. All excluded primes depended only on the fixed pair and the compact support, not on the varying pair.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ KottwitzPairFormRatioLocalScalarNorm.lean; EventuallyKottwitzLatticeSeparableMinpoly.lean; EventuallyTauFixedUnitCentralizerIsNorm.lean; ExistsHodgeLatticeGermSystem.lean; FiniteFixedUnitClassesCentralizerRegular.lean.
Proposition 7.22 (Finiteness of the global marked sum). For the source’s degree-one compact regular tests, only finitely many marked scalar-conjugacy classes have nonzero orbital term. Thus the finite-support hy-pothesis in Proposition 7.17 holds for these tests.
Proof. First find one denominator bound for all contributing γ and γ^{−1}. Away from p, a nonzero orbital summand conjugates the element into the fixed compact support of f. The characteristic polynomial of left multiplication on the rational algebra is invariant under this conjugation. Its coefficients therefore have uniformly bounded denominators away from p. Precisely, one positive integer D, prime to p, makes each such coefficient belong to D^{−1}Z[1/p]. To see uniformity, write a rational basis of the algebra. The coefficient maps are polynomials in its coordinates. A compact adelic set has bounded coordinates at finitely many primes and integral coordinates elsewhere. The same argument applies to the compact inverse support.
At p, use the auxiliary test, where the degree is one and its twisting automorphism is the identity. Its nonzero summand puts the selected local matrices, their inverses, and the common multiplier c_{0} and its inverse in one compact set, up to conjugation. Choose k bounding their eigenvalue norms by p^{k}. Such a bound follows from bounded entries: for an eigenvector, a coordinate of maximum norm and the ultrametric inequality bound its eigenvalue by the maximum matrix entry. The other CM factors are adjoint inverses times c_{0}, by the similitude equation. Their roots are therefore bounded by p^{2k}. Together the selected and conjugate factors contain all roots of the rational left-multiplication characteristic polynomial, with their multiplicities.
Let d = dim_{ℚ} C. The ultrametric bound on each root and the elementary symmetric coefficient formula bound every coefficient by p^{2kd}. Taking N = Dp^{2kd} > 0 makes the coefficients of the characteristic polynomials of Nγ and Nγ^{−1} integral at p and at all other finite primes. Being rational, these coefficients are integers. Cayley–Hamilton proves that both elements are integral over Z. Every complex eigenvalue z therefore has both Nz and Nz^{−1} integral.
For a marked pair all conjugate roots have squared absolute value c_{0} > 0, by the definite orthogonal-complement argument in Proposition 7.15. Lemma 7.20 now leaves only finitely many possible polynomials.
For each one fix a contributing γ_{0}. All regular elements with this separable degree-n polynomial are conjugate in C^{×}. One can check descent of a conjugating matrix directly. The solution space of yγ = γ_{0}y is defined over F. Over an algebraic closure the two matrices with the same distinct eigenvalues have an invertible solution. The polynomial det(L_{y} : C →C) on that solution space is therefore nonzero. Since F is infinite, it is nonzero at some F-point, which is an invertible conjugator in C. Conjugate the varying pairs by it and transfer their finite trivializations too. Their multipliers have at most two values: determinants of the common similitude element fix c^{n}_{0}, which has at most two rational real roots as c_{0} varies.
Fix one of these multipliers and one reference β_{0}. Every ratio a = ββ_{0}^{−1} is a fixed unit in the regular commutative centralizer, for τ(b) = β_{0}b^{∗}β_{0}^{−1}. Lemma 7.21 gives its local norm conditions outside one finite set. Lemma 7.19 then gives a finite list of a_{0}’s with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a = rea_{0}τ(e), r ∈ℚ^{×}, e ∈E^{×}.Thus β = rea_{0}β_{0}e^{∗}. For fixed a_{0}, two such expressions with rational scalars of the same sign give equivalent pairs: conjugate by e^{′}e^{−1} and rescale by the positive number r^{′}/r. There are at most two scalar-conjugacy classes per a_{0}. Combining this finite list with the finite polynomial and multiplier lists proves the proposition.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ FiniteMarkedPairClassesDegreeOneTermNeZero.lean, in-tegral\_of\_term\_ne\_zero', finite\_pol\_marked' and finite\_cls\_term\_one\_a\_one; FiniteKottwitzClassesPerMinpolyAEqOne.lean, finite\_fixed and finite\_classes\_of\_pol\_a\_one; UnitsConjOfMinpolyEqOfSeparable.lean.
Lemma 7.23 (Finiteness of regular orbital terms). For a fixed regular marked pair, the compact degree-one tests have finite support on its rational-centralizer double-coset space. For a fixed adelic coordinate and a fixed positive line, only finitely many rational group elements fixing that line have nonzero test value.
Proof. Let T be the algebraic centralizer of the regular element in its similitude group. It is a torus: in the reg-ular etale algebra its equation is zτ(z) = c with one common rational multiplier. Over an algebraic closure, the involution pairs the coordinates, since its invertible anti-invariant element excludes fixed coordinates. Choose one coordinate in each pair and the multiplier freely; these are torus coordinates.
At each finite place, the orbit map modulo T has local continuous sections on the regular conjugacy orbit. This can be checked without an unproved properness assertion. Solve the linear equations yγ = Ay. A nonzero minor at one invertible solution gives, by elimination, a rational continuous choice of y near that solution. Its determinant stays nonzero on a smaller neighborhood. For elements A of the similitude group, the pulled-back form differs from the original by a fixed unit of the etale centralizer. Near the original solution its normalized ratio is near one. Its square root is defined by the convergent binomial series in the complete local algebra, after making that neighborhood sufficiently small. Multiplying the chosen conjugator by this centralizer square root corrects the form and gives a section in the similitude group.
These regular group orbits are closed. Within the closed regular polynomial fiber their classes are dis-tinguished by the local fixed-unit norm quotients, and there are finitely many of these, by local reciprocity. The local sections show that each class is open in that fiber, hence also closed. A compact subset of the orbit is consequently covered by finitely many compact section images, up to its local centralizer.
Away from finitely many primes the stronger integral assertion holds: the regular polynomial has unit discriminant, and the matrix and etale orders are those constructed in Lemma 7.21. Every stable lattice has rank one over that maximal etale order and is obtained by a centralizer element. The unramified unit-norm correction used there makes the remaining conjugator integral in the similitude group. Thus there is just the integral coset outside one finite set.
It follows that all adelic conjugators whose conjugates meet the fixed compact support belong to T(𝔸_{f})C for one compact set C. There are finitely many right level cosets in C. For each such representative, Borel’s class-finiteness theorem for the torus gives a finite quotient of T(ℚ)\T(𝔸_{f}) by its compact open level intersection. This proves the first assertion.
For the second, a positive fixed line splits the real Hermitian space into that line and its negative definite orthogonal complement. Its stabilizer at multiplier one is compact. Compact finite test support bounds the valuations of the rational multiplier at all primes, so there are finitely many possible positive multipliers. Rescaling by their positive square roots therefore bounds all real matrices fixing the line. The finite compo-nents have one denominator bound. As in the stabilizer proof following Proposition 7.18, bounded rational coordinates with one denominator give only finitely many elements.
Source: AbelianVarietyTheory/Proofs/DivisorProofs/ ClassSummandEqTermOfAOne.lean; FiniteMarkedPairClassesDegreeOneTermNeZero.lean; KottwitzPairFormRatioLocalScalarNorm.lean; FiniteFixedUnitClassesCentralizerRegular.lean.
Proposition 7.24 (The period-domain weighted marked count). In the source’s period-domain descrip-tion, the regular weighted count of fixed points equals the marked scalar-conjugacy-class sum, with weight c(P_{0}, µ) at its positive eigenvalue mark. The equality holds for the compact degree-one tests just considered.
Proof. Fix a form β and its rational similitude group Γ_{β}. The period data consist of a finite adelic level coordinate gK and a positive complex line L, modulo the simultaneous rational action. A rational element γ contributes at this point precisely when it fixes L. Its scalar on that line is µ, and its weight is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c(P_{0}, µ)f(g_{f}^{−1}γ_{f}g_{f})f^{′}(g_{p}^{−1}γ_{p}g_{p}).The point’s contribution is the sum of these weights divided by the cardinality of its rational stabilizer. This is the source’s cxSumAtM definition. The eigenvalue does not depend on a vector representing the line: multiplying a nonzero eigenvector by a nonzero scalar preserves its eigenvalue. Conjugating the element and the line together also preserves it, by applying the conjugating matrix to the eigenvector equation. The test factors are invariant under their level changes. Thus the displayed weight is well defined on the required orbit data.
Regroup pairs consisting of a point and a contributing γ by the conjugacy class of γ. For a fixed point, its finite stabilizer acts on the contributing elements by conjugation. Dividing the number of elements of an orbit by the stabilizer’s order gives exactly the reciprocal order of the centralizer stabilizer. This is the same orbit-size calculation as in Proposition 7.18. Regularity and positive index one give a unique positive fixed eigenline, as proved in Proposition 7.17. Hence, for fixed γ, its fixed period line can be omitted from the orbit data. The resulting sum is precisely the centralizer double-coset orbital term, multiplied by c(P_{0}, µ).
The finiteness required in this regrouping has now been proved. For each marked pair its contributing orbital cosets are finite by Lemma 7.23; there are finitely many marked pair classes by Proposition 7.22. Their pairs of point and element therefore have finite orbit support, and their projection to point classes is finite. The inner sum at each point is finite by the second part of the lemma. Every interchanged sum thus has finite effective support.
Finally sum over the form classes. The passage from a marked pair to its underlying form class and the corresponding element conjugacy class is bijective. Choose an isometry with the representative of that form class and transport γ by it. Two choices differ by an element of its rational similitude group, so give conjugate elements. Conversely such an element with a positive fixed line gives the pair (β, γ, c_{0}). The two operations are inverse modulo positive rational scaling and conjugation. The invariant test arguments and the equal stabilizers proved above preserve every summand under this bijection. This proves the claimed global weighted equality.
Source: EtaleClopenDescent/ComplexCountRegularMarkedPoints.lean, eigL\_smul, eigL\_conj, cxSumAtM\_orbit, cls\_part, cxSumAtM\_unfold, markSumC\_regroup and complex\_count\_regular\_marked\_points.
Combining Propositions 7.24 and 7.17 identifies the period-domain fixed-point count with the definite-pair sum weighted by the full root sum. For the finite cut of Proposition 7.10, that root sum is the algebraic character value times ∑_{i}y^{hi}. Proposition 7.18 identifies the resulting definite sum with the automorphic trace. The good-test condition removes the nonregular and reducible conjugacy classes, and its prescribed algebraic type identifies the coefficient representation’s trace with the product of Schur polynomials. The finiteness argument above also justifies summing over definite form classes: a nonzero regular term comes from one of the finitely many pair classes. This proves the group-side part of (174), with its complete root multiplicities.