Section 8.11 · PDF pages 491–496
The equivariant class-group count
The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.
8.11 The equivariant class-group count
Let F/L be cyclic, generated by γ of order n_{0} = ℓ^{ν−c}, where 1 ≤c ≤ν, c ≥2 if ℓ= 2, and suppose F contains a primitive ℓ^{ν}-th root ζ with γζ = ζ^{1+ℓc}. Let E ≥1, a = (1 + ℓ^{c})^{E}, and q = ℓ^{ν}. Use additive notation for Y = F^{×}, let I be the free divisor group, d : Y →I the principal-divisor map, g = γ^{−1}, and g_{I} its induced divisor action. Apply the notation of Lemma 8.20. The character group under consideration is
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
ℰ = Hom I/(dY + (g_{I} −a)I), ℤ/q .
Equivalently its values on primes satisfy φ(γ^{−1}P) = aφ(P) and annihilate every principal divisor. The corresponding multiplicative weighted norm is exactly
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n∏_{0}−1_{j}
𝒩_{a}(α) = (γ^{j}α)^{a} ;
j=0the signs follow from g^{n0−j}= γ^{j}.
Lemma 8.30 (The invariant power classes). With W as above,
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{|W[ℓ]| ≤ℓ}2[L:ℚ]+⌊log_{2} h_{L}⌋+2_{.}Proof. First bound the classes
Sel_{L}(ℓ) = {x ∈L^{×}/(L^{×})^{ℓ}: v_{P} (x) ≡0 (mod ℓ) (P ∤ℓ)}.
Their valuation map lands in the ℓ-torsion of the class group of S_{ℓ}-integers; its kernel is the S_{ℓ}-units modulo ℓ-th powers. The latter have at most ℓ^{2[L:ℚ]} elements: ordinary units have rank r_{2}(L) −1, adjoining the at most [L : ℚ] valuations adds at most that many generators, and the roots of unity add at most one generator modulo ℓ. The ℓ-torsion of a class group of order dividing h_{L} has 𝔽_{ℓ}-dimension at most ⌊log_{2} h_{L}⌋. Thus
| Sel_{L}(ℓ)| ≤ℓ^{2[L:ℚ]+⌊log2 hL⌋}.
The background results used here are finiteness of the class group and Dirichlet’s unit theorem, in J. S. Milne, Algebraic Number Theory, v3.08 (2020), Theorems 4.4, 5.1 and 5.9.^{11} Both apply to the number field L; the stated S_{ℓ}-unit rank upper bound also follows directly by mapping an S_{ℓ}-unit to its valuations and taking ordinary units as kernel.
Multiplication by ℓ sends a representative y ∈U of W[ℓ] to ℓy = (g −a)z + t, with t torsion. Send its class to [z] ∈ Y /(ℓY + tors Y ). The ambiguity in z does not affect this class: (g −a) is injective on Y / tors Y , since g^{n0} = 1 and a^{n0} ̸= 1. Changing y by (g −a)y^{′}+ t^{′} changes z by ℓy^{′} modulo torsion. This map is injective: if z = ℓz^{′}+ t^{′}, the equation makes y −(g −a)z^{′} torsion, and the class of y in W is zero. Since ℓ| a −1, its image is g-invariant. Also dy = (g_{I} −a)D_{0} for some divisor D_{0}. Apply d to the equation and cancel the injective map g_{I} −a on the torsion-free divisor group, to obtain dz = ℓD_{0}. Thus all valuations of z are divisible by ℓ.
It remains to bound these invariant power classes by ℓ^{2}| Sel_{L}(ℓ)|. Choose a generator ρ of the finite roots of unity of F. An invariant class has a representative α with all valuations divisible by ℓ and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
γα = αv^{ℓ}ρ^{r}, 0 ≤r < ℓ.Taking norms gives Norm(v)^{ℓ} = Norm(ρ)^{−r}. There are at most ℓ^{2} possible pairs (r, Norm v). For two classes with the same pair, their ratio α/α^{′} satisfies γ(α/α^{′}) = (α/α^{′})(v/v^{′})^{ℓ} and Norm(v/v^{′}) = 1. Hilbert 90 gives v/v^{′}= w/γw; hence∏ (α/α^{′})w^{ℓ}= x_{0} ∈L^{×}. This Hilbert 90 identity follows, if desired, by taking a nonzero twisted trace ∑_{i}(_{j<i}γ^{j}(v/v^{′}))γ^{i}(t); linear independence of distinct field automorphisms permits a t making it nonzero.
The extension F/L is unramified away from ℓ. Indeed inertia fixes the reduction of ζ there, where it still has order ℓ^{ν}; writing an inertia element as γ^{j} gives ℓ^{ν}| (1 + ℓ^{c})^{j}−1. Lifting the exponent implies ℓ^{ν−c}| j, so the element is one. Consequently the valuations of x_{0} outside ℓ are divisible by ℓ, and [x_{0}] ∈ Sel_{L}(ℓ). In each of the at most ℓ^{2} fibres, fix one representative; every other class is it times the image of such an x_{0}. This bounds each fibre by | Sel_{L}(ℓ)| and proves the result.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/SelInvLe.lean:7--227; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/ActU.lean:6--34;Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/PowEqOneOfDvd.lean:12--117
Proposition 8.31 (The class-character cardinality). Suppose a bound B holds for every finite set of α ∈F^{×} with divisor dα = (g_{I} −a)D_{α} whose values 𝒩_{a}(α)^{ℓb} are pairwise distinct modulo q-th powers. Then ℰ is finite and
|ℰ| q^{r2(L)}≤B ℓ^{(b+vℓ(E))g+c+vℓ(E)}, g = 2[L : ℚ] + ⌊log_{2} h_{L}⌋+ 2.
Proof. Let C = I/(dY +(g_{I}−a)I), the cokernel of g_{I}−a on the finite class group of F. Let 𝒰 = O_{F}^{×}/µ(F). Dirichlet’s logarithmic embedding identifies 𝒰 ⊗ℝ, equivariantly, with the sum-zero hyperplane on the complex places of F. The cyclic group Gal(F/L) permutes these places in r_{2}(L) cycles of length n_{0}. Thus the determinant of g −a on this hyperplane has absolute value
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(a^{n0}−1)^{r2(L)}_{.}
a −1It is nonzero; the index of g −a on the integral unit lattice equals this determinant. Denote its cokernel by E_{Q}. The divisor map gives a map W onto the kernel of g_{I} −a on the class group, with kernel E_{Q}: the
^{11}https://www.jmilne.org/math/CourseNotes/ANT.pdf, printed pp. 70–71, 85 and 88.
equation dy = (g_{I} −a)D determines D uniquely, and changing y by (g −a)z changes D by dz. Kernel and cokernel of an endomorphism of a finite group have the same cardinality. Hence W is finite and
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|W| = |E_{Q}||C|, |E_{Q}|(a −1) = (a^{n0}−1)^{r2(L)}.Lifting the exponent gives, with f = v_{ℓ}(E),
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v_{ℓ}(a −1) = c + f, v_{ℓ}(a^{n0}−1) = ν + f.Write a^{n0}−1 = qℓ^{f}u_{0}, ℓ ∤ u_{0}. Lemma 8.20, with s = ℓ^{b}, gives a map W → Y /(qY + tors Y ) whose kernel is killed by ℓ^{b+f}u_{0}. Its image has at most B elements: choose a representative y for each image value. If two corresponding weighted norms differ by a q-th power, their images in this quotient are equal, so the chosen finite set satisfies the hypothesis of the proposition. The prime-torsion bound of Lemma 8.30 therefore yields
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{ℓ}v_{ℓ}(|W|)_{≤Bℓ}(b+f)g_{.}Every map C → ℤ/ℓ^{ν} factors through the ℓ-primary part of C, so |ℰ| ≤ ℓ^{vℓ(|C|)}; for a product of cyclic ℓ-groups this follows by counting the choices for each generator. Taking valuations in the unit-index identity gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v_{ℓ}(|E_{Q}|) + c + f = r_{2}(L)(ν + f).Consequently
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{|ℰ| ℓ}νr_{2}(L)_{≤ℓ}v_{ℓ}(|C|)+v_{ℓ}(|E_{Q}|)+c+f_{= ℓ}v_{ℓ}(|W|)+c+f_{≤Bℓ}(b+f)g+c+f_{.}Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts.lean:16--111; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/PermDet.lean:8--161;Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/CardEQ.lean:10--128;Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/SelmerOrderCounts/EqHomLe.lean:5--139
Lemma 8.32 (Detecting a global power at degree-one primes). Let F/L be a finite Galois extension of number fields, µ_{q} ⊂F, q ≥1, and β ∈F^{×}. If β is a q-th power in the residue field at every prime P of F, outside a fixed finite set, for which O_{L} →O_{F} /P is surjective, then β ∈(F^{×})^{q}.
Proof. If it is not a q-th power, the Kummer extension F(β^{1/q})/F is nontrivial and Galois. Choose an automorphism nontrivial on a q-th root, and extend it to a Galois closure M/L. It fixes F. Chebotarev’s theorem gives a prime of L with that conjugacy class of Frobenius, outside the finite excluded set, all ramified primes, the primes above q, and the numerator and denominator primes of β. Choose the prime of M so that its Frobenius is the chosen automorphism itself. Its restriction to F is one, so the intervening residue degree over L is one, which is the required surjectivity. At this prime a q-th power residue of β would make Frobenius fix a root of X^{q}−β. It fixes µ_{q}, so fixing one root would fix all; the chosen action fixes none. This contradicts the residue-power hypothesis. Here Chebotarev is used only for a finite Galois extension of number fields and a conjugacy class, with finitely many primes removed. A precise reference is Milne, Class Field Theory, v4.03 (2020), V, Theorem 3.23, printed p. 164.^{12}
Source: Development/EtaleCohomology/CyclotomicDiscriminants/FinSDetect.lean; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/LemmaKOfSteps.lean:109--115
^{12}https://www.jmilne.org/math/CourseNotes/CFT.pdf.
Proposition 8.33 (The exact cycle-evaluation requirement). Use the cyclic layer above. Let M = 2E + 1 and suppose M < ℓ^{c}, r_{2}(L). Suppose that for every α with dα = (g_{I} −a)D_{α}, a cycle y_{α} in degree M of some GL_{Nα}(O_{L}) and a nonzero denominator b_{α} ∈O_{F} are constructed with the following property. At every prime P of F away from ℓb_{α}, of residue degree one over L, there is a primitive family Φ_{P} , the same for all α, such that
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∏ ( )
Φ_{P} (y_{α}) = p_{E} v_{P} (𝒩_{a}(α) mod P), p_{E} = (1 + ℓ^{c})^{E}−(1 + ℓ^{c})^{j} . (213)
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
0≤_{j̸=}j<M_{E}Here v_{P} : k(P)^{×} →ℤ/q is an epimorphism with kernel (k(P)^{×})^{q}. Assume (208) and homology stability as in Proposition 8.19. Then the hypothesis of Proposition 8.31 holds with
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
b = 2E + M(c + M), B = q^{r2(L)}T_{2E+1}(L, 4E + 6)T_{2E}(L, 4E + 6).Proof. The reduction of ζ at P ∤ℓ still has order q. Indeed if an order-ℓ power reduced to one, its geometric sum would reduce ℓ to zero, which is impossible. Therefore q | |k(P)^{×}|. This cyclic finite group has an epimorphism v_{P} with the indicated kernel. For j ̸= E, lifting the exponent gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
v_{ℓ}((1 + ℓ^{c})^{E}−(1 + ℓ^{c})^{j})= c + v_{ℓ}(|E −j|) < c + M,since 0 < |E −j| < M. Hence p_{E} divides ℓ^{M(c+M)} in ℤ/q. ∏Take any finite set S as in the separation hypothesis of Proposition 8.31. Exclude the finite denominator ℓ_{α∈S}b_{α}. Take the product, over all remaining degree-one primes, of the functionals Φ_{P} ; products pre-serve the three primitive-family identities coordinatewise. Suppose two elements of S have equal values of ℓ^{2E}Φ(y_{α}). Multiplying (213) by a witness for the divisibility just proved gives
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
( )
v_{P} (𝒩_{a}(α)/𝒩_{a}(α^{′}))^{ℓb} mod P = 0
at every indexed prime. Lemma 8.32 makes this ratio a global q-th power. The defining separation of S forces α = α^{′}. Thus the values of ℓ^{2E}Φ(y_{α}) distinguish all elements of S. Apply Proposition 8.19 with k = 2E. The degree is k + 1 = M < r_{2}(L), and 2k + 6 = 4E + 6. It bounds |S| by exactly the stated
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B.
Source: Development/EtaleCohomology/CyclotomicDiscriminants/SFewOfCut.lean:9--211; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/LatticeBlockClasses/CJoin.lean:5--187
Combining Propositions 8.33 and 8.31 cancels the factor q^{r2(L)}. It gives the class-character bound, inde-pendent of ν, assumed in Proposition 8.21. The cancellation explains why a finite-level count can bound the intrinsic cohomology group: every finite set of unramified equivariant characters on ker χ_{ℓ} descends to one sufficiently high cyclotomic layer and is killed by ℓ^{ν} at a still higher common level. Artin reciprocity iden-tifies its lifts with the class characters just counted. Restriction from the Selmer group to ker χ_{ℓ} is injective: the quotient cyclotomic image is procyclic, and a scalar cocycle there is a coboundary, since multiplication by χ_{ℓ}(γ)^{−E}−1 ̸= 0 is surjective on ℚ_{ℓ}/ℤ_{ℓ}. Thus each finite subset of the Selmer group has cardinality at most the same bound, forcing the group to be finite. The necessary common-level descent also preserves local triviality at ℓ; an arbitrary continuous extension of characters would not suffice for this step.
The actual cycles and functionals in this argument are constructed in Proposition 8.50 and Lemma 8.47.
Lemma 8.53 supplies the common-level passage. The filtered rank statement follows below from the checked stable-cohomology theorem; the torsion and integral-duality bounds have been proved in Propositions 8.28 and 8.29.
Lemma 8.34 (The stable-range hypothesis). For R = O_{L}, stabilisation
H_{m}(GL_{N}(R), ℤ) −→H_{m}(GL_{N+1}(R), ℤ)
is an isomorphism if N ≥2m + 4.
Proof. We check the ring hypothesis rather than identifying the stable range with the Krull dimension without an argument. Let r_{0}, . . . , r_{t}, t ≥2, generate R. If the first t entries are zero, adding the last entry to each makes the shortened tuple unimodular. Otherwise choose r_{j} ̸= 0, j < t, and k < t, k ̸= j. Only finitely many maximal ideals contain r_{j}. By the Chinese remainder theorem choose u congruent to one at those containing r_{k} and to zero at the others. Replace r_{k} by r_{k} + ur_{t}. A maximal ideal containing the shortened tuple contains r_{j}. If it contains r_{k}, it also contains r_{t} because u ≡1; this contradicts original unimodularity. If it does not contain r_{k}, then u ≡0, again contradicting containment of the adjusted entry. Thus R has Bass stable rank at most two.
Apply W. van der Kallen, Homology stability for linear groups, Invent. Math. 60 (1980), 269–295, The-orem 1.1, p. 269.^{13} For stable rank s, its isomorphism range for GL_{n−1} → GL_{n} is n ≥2m + s + 1. Here s ≤2 and n = N + 1; the asserted, slightly larger range satisfies it. The coefficient module is ℤ, on which the elementary group acts trivially, as required in the theorem.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/TensorHomCubes/DedekindSR.lean:5--111; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/LiteratureResults/KTheoryStability/HomologicalStability/KStability.lean
Proposition 8.35 (The filtered rational rank). For totally complex L, even k ≥2, N ≥2(k + 1) + 4, and prime ℓ, (208) holds.
Proof. We use Borel’s stable real cohomology calculation for the arithmetic general linear group. Its special linear calculation is A. Borel, Stable real cohomology of arithmetic groups, Ann. Sci. ENS (4) 7 (1974), 235– 272, §11.5(3), with the primitive-rank statement also recorded in §12.1–12.2.^{14} For the ring of integers of a totally complex number field, the positive odd-degree primitive generators have dimension r_{2}(L) in each degree at least three; the degree-one determinant-unit part has dimension r_{2}(L)−1. The stable cohomology algebra is exterior on these generators.
We explain the general-linear and repetition conventions in this use of the calculation. Determinant splits the stable general linear group over O_{L}^{×}. Conjugation by a diagonal unit is inner on the stable special linear group: compensate with its inverse in one extra coordinate. The special-linear invariant differential-form generators extend to the general linear group by the same trace formulas. Together with logarithmic determinant-unit classes they give the stated exterior algebra, by the cohomology spectral sequence of this split extension. Under block sum they are primitive: trace on block diagonal matrices adds, and logarithm of the determinant multiplies to an additive logarithm. Thus repetition of ℓ blocks acts on a monomial of j generators by ℓ^{j}. In degree k + 1, every such monomial has 1 ≤j ≤k + 1.
Lemma 8.34 identifies degree k+1 integral homology at rank N, at each larger rank N_{t}, and at the stable limit. After tensoring with ℝ, the recurrence defining z_{k} is therefore the operator
Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
k∏+1
(ψ_{ℓ}−ℓ^{i})
i=2on this finite-dimensional stable homology. Dualising the exterior-basis calculation, this operator kills every weight j = 2, . . . , k +1. Its image has dimension at most that of weight one, namely r_{2}(L), since k +1 ≥3
^{13}https://webspace.science.uu.nl/~kalle101/homstab1980.pdf. ^{14}https://www.numdam.org/article/ASENS_1974_4_7_2_235_0.pdf, printed pp. 268, 270–271.
is odd. The integer rank of the image span equals its real dimension after tensoring. This proves (208) in every degree used by Lemma K, where k = 2E ≥2. The stronger condition k + 1 < r_{2}(L) used earlier is compatible with this assertion.
Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/LemmaKOfSteps.lean:11--15; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/ModularityArgument/ClassCounting/HasVal.lean:52--60