Skip to content

Section 8.14 · PDF pages 522–541

The cycles and the finite-difference construction from result 8.67

The notation transcription is provisional. Check it against the printed mathematics when citing or reusing a formula.

Proposition 8.67 (The higher Stickelberger annihilator). For E, F, n, ℓ, e as in Lemma 8.65, with e ≥1, the locally split minus module is annihilated by ℓ^{r} for an integer r satisfying

r log ℓ≤30n(e + 1) log(eℓF).

Consequently (207) holds by Lemma 8.66.

Proof. Put N = ℓF, k = e + 1, a = 2N + 1, and Γ = Gal(E/ℚ). The cyclotomic action gives a surjection f : (ℤ/N)^{×} →Γ, followed by inversion in Γ; this inversion is part of the cohomology action convention. In particular c = f(−1) is complex conjugation and c^{2}= 1 ̸= c. For b ∈(ℤ/N)^{×} use its least nonnegative representative, still denoted b, and define

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{N}k−1
E_{k}(N, b) =_{k} B_{k}(b/N),
Θ_{k}(f) = −∑E_{k}(N, b)[f(b)]^{−1},
b
Y_{k,a}(f) = (1 −a^{k}[f(a)]^{−1})Θ_{k}(f).

We prove that Y_{k,a}(f) has an integral form z ∈ℤ_{ℓ}[Γ] annihilating φ(N)𝒮_{ℓ}(E, e).

For this purpose, at any larger level M = Nℓ^{m}, put t = a^{−1}b,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j(M, a, b) =^{at}_{M}^{ −b} ∈ℤ, E_{1}(M, a, b) =^{a −}_{2}^{1}−j(M, a, b).

The first quotient is integral because at ≡b (mod M), and a is odd. The integral group-ring approximation is ∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Ỹ_{e,a,M} = − b^{e}E_{1}(M, a, b)[f(^{̄}b)]^{−1}.
b∈(ℤ/M)^{×}

Here∏^{̄}b denotes reduction to level N. We check its convergence coefficient by coefficient. Write P_{k} = _{p≤k+1}p and d_{k} = 2kP_{k}. The Bernoulli expansion proved above gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{b}k_{b}k−1_{2M}
E_{k}(M, b) =_{kM} −_{2} + _{dk} z_{b}, z_{b} ∈ℤ.

Indeed the terms of Bernoulli index at least two have one factor M, and P_{k} clears their remaining Bernoulli denominators. Since at = b + Mj, the binomial identities give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(at)^{k}= b^{k}+ kb^{k−1}Mj + M^{2}w,
(at)^{k−1}= b^{k−1}+ Mw^{′},

with integral w, w^{′}. Substitute these in E_{k}(M, b) −a^{k}E_{k}(M, t). The two leading terms become b^{e}{(a − 1)/2 −j}; all other terms belong to (M/d_{k})ℤ. Thus Y_{k,a} at level M differs from Ỹ_{e,a,M} by an element of

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(M/d_{k})ℤ[Γ].

Pushing Y_{k,a} from level M to N gives exactly Y_{k,a}(f). To verify this, M and N have the same prime divisors, so the lifts of a unit b mod N are all b + jN, 0 ≤j < M/N. The Bernoulli distribution identity

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
L∑−1
L^{k−1}B_{k}((x + j)/L) = B_{k}(x)
j=0

then sums the coefficients of Θ_{k}; it follows directly by summing their generating functions as a finite geo-metric series. The factor 1 −a^{k}[f(a)]^{−1} is preserved by reduction too. Since v_{ℓ}(M/d_{k}) →∞, the integral approximations converge to Y_{k,a}(f) in ℚ_{ℓ}[Γ]. Their limit z is integral, because ℤ_{ℓ}[Γ] is closed. More pre-cisely, for every r_{0} and all sufficiently large m,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
Ỹ_{e,a,M} = z + ℓ^{r0}w_{M}, w_{M} ∈ℤ_{ℓ}[Γ].

We now prove the annihilation claim. The classical Stickelberger theorem says

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(ℤ[G_{C}]θ_{C} ∩ℤ[G_{C}])Cl(C) = 0, C = ℚ(µ_{M}), θ_{C} =∑^{b} [σ_{b}]^{−1}.
b^{M}

Here σ_{b}ζ_{M} = ζ_{M}^{b}. This exact form, with no restriction to prime conductor, is Theorem 4.5.6 of Sharifi’s notes, preceded by Definition 4.5.1.^{20} The integral group ring element ∑_{b}j(M, a, b)[σ_{b}]^{−1} belongs to this ideal: it equals (a[σ_{a}−1]−1)θ_{C}. Also ∑_{b}[σ_{b}]^{−1} kills Cl(C), since its action on an ideal class is the extension of its ideal norm to ℚ, hence is principal. It follows that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑E_{1}(M, a, b)[σ_{b}]^{−1}Cl(C) = 0.
b

Fix x ∈𝒮_{ℓ}(E, e). Its continuous cocycle has finite image and is killed by some ℓ^{r0}. Its restriction ϕ to the infinite cyclotomic kernel extends, on a sufficiently deep cyclotomic level, to an everywhere unramified additive character. This is the finite-level argument of Lemma 8.53: make the scalar action trivial on its finite image and on its finitely many local coboundary parameters. The restriction and extension argument remains valid over E without µ_{ℓ} ⊂ E: for odd ℓ, a closed infinite subgroup of ℤ^{×}_{ℓ} is the product of a cyclic prime-to-ℓ group and a principal procyclic group, hence itself topologically cyclic. The proof killing C ∩ ker χ uses only the unbounded ℓ-part of the orders of its finite reductions; all the other extension and coboundary calculations are unchanged.

Choose m sufficiently large for this extension, for ℓ^{r0}-approximation, and for the scalar congruences below. Then C = ℚ(µ_{M}) contains E, and the extended character factors through Cl(C), by unramified reciprocity. For u in the cyclotomic kernel that also fixes µ_{N}, it fixes µ_{M} as well: it fixes µ_{N} and every ℓ-power root. Let σ_{b} denote a lift acting by b on µ_{M}. The action on the restricted cohomology character is conjugation by this lift times the scalar χ(σ_{b})^{−e}. Since χ(σ_{b}) ≡b (mod ℓ^{m}), the factor b^{e} in Ỹ_{e,a,M} cancels this scalar on the ℓ^{r0}-torsion values. Thus the evaluation of res_{∞}(Ỹ_{e,a,M}x) at u is, up to the displayed minus sign, ∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
E_{1}(M, a, b) ϕ(σ_{b}^{−1}uσ_{b}).
b

Artin conjugation identifies this with the character applied to the preceding Stickelberger annihilation of Cl(C). It is zero. The approximation shows the same for zx. Every element of the cyclotomic kernel, raised

^{20}https://www.math.ucla.edu/~sharifi/notes/iwasawa.pdf, printed pp. 113–116.

to φ(N), fixes µ_{N}; this is Euler’s theorem in (ℤ/N)^{×}. Additivity of its restriction consequently gives res_{∞}(φ(N)zx) = 0. Restriction is injective by the same topological-generator coboundary argument as in

Lemma 8.51, using e ̸= 0. Therefore φ(N)zx = 0, as asserted.

It remains to bound a scalar annihilator. In ℤ_{ℓ}[Γ]/([c] −ϵ), with ϵ = (−1)^{k}, multiplication by z has determinant δ; this algebra is free of rank n/2, using representatives of Γ/⟨c⟩. Its matrix has entries z_{gig}−1+

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j

ϵz_{cgigj}−1. The adjugate identity shows that δ is in the ideal generated by z in this quotient. Hence it kills

every c-eigenvector of sign ϵ already killed by z. Applied to φ(N)x, for x in the minus module, this gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
δφ(N)x = 0.

Put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
D_{Y} = Nk(k + 1)!, S_{Y} = 2a^{k}N^{k}k!, B_{X} = D_{Y} S_{Y} .

The rational coefficients of D_{Y} Y_{k,a}(f) are integers. In the Bernoulli expansion, the leading denominator divides Nk, and (k + 1)! clears every Bernoulli denominator of index at most k. Thus

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n/2

X_{0} = D_{Y} det_{c,ϵ}(Y_{k,a}(f)) ∈ℤ.

Over ℂ, the determinant is the product of the character evaluations of Y_{k,a} with η(c) = ϵ. This follows by the character eigenbasis of the regular representation of the finite abelian group, restricted to the indicated sign. Each evaluation is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{−B}(N)
(1 −a^{k}η(a))_{k}^{k,η} ,

where the Bernoulli number uses the character at level N. It is nonzero. Its primitive Bernoulli factor is nonzero by Lemma 8.63; change of level contributes only factors 1 −η_{0}(p)p^{k−1}, which are nonzero for k ≥2, by their absolute values. This change-of-level formula follows by excluding multiples of the newly introduced prime in the Bernoulli distribution sum. The smoothing factor is nonzero too, since a ≥2 and |η(a)| = 1. Thus X_{0} ̸= 0. The Fourier bound for the level-N Bernoulli sum gives |B_{k,η}^{(N)}| ≤N^{k}k!. Together

with |1 −a^{k}η(a)| ≤2a^{k}, it bounds each evaluation by S_{Y} . Consequently |X_{0}| ≤B_{X}^{n/2}. Since z and Y_{k,a} have the same coefficients in ℚ_{ℓ}, their determinants agree there. Hence

δ | ℓ^{r1}, r_{1} = v_{ℓ}(X_{0}), r_{1} log ℓ≤n log B_{X}.

This divisibility uses the integrality of δ and X_{0} = D_{Y}^{n/2}δ, with D_{Y} integral. Similarly φ(N) | ℓ^{r2} in ℤ_{ℓ}, for r_{2} = v_{ℓ}(φ(N)), and r_{2} log ℓ≤ log N. Thus ℓ^{r1+r2} kills the minus module.

Finally, with T = 3eℓF ≥2, the inequalities N, k ≤T, a ≤T^{3}, k + 1 ≤T^{2} give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B_{X}N ≤T^{7k+6}≤T^{10k}.

These follow by bounding the factorials (k + 1)! ≤T^{2k+2}, k! ≤T^{k} in the displayed definition of B_{X}. Also log T ≤3 log(eℓF). Therefore

(r_{1} + r_{2}) log ℓ≤n(log B_{X} + log N) ≤30n(e + 1) log(eℓF).

This is the required exponent estimate.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/StickelbergerElements/StickelbergerBernoulliCoeffExpansionModDenominat.lean:7--46; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/StickelbergerElements/TwistedBernoulliValueCongrPowMulFirst.lean:8--44; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/YLevel.lean:53--91; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/YNear.lean:10--39; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/Automorphic

Varieties/OddResidueBounds/NearLevel.lean:8--76; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/ClKill.lean:7--55; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/ResKill.lean:14--115; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/TotKill.lean:7--46; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/ZKill.lean:9--31; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/StickelbergerCharacterEval/Detint.lean:9--45; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/DetVal.lean:29--65; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/KillPow.lean:31--104; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/OddResidueBounds/BdxLog.lean:5--61

Proposition 8.68 (The reciprocity law used in a Kolyvagin step). Let ℓ be odd, O a finite coefficient discrete valuation ring over ℤ_{ℓ}, D_{O} = Frac(O)/O, and α : G_{ℚ} → O^{×} a continuous character. Put β = χ_{ℓ}α^{−1}. Let 0 ̸= a ∈O, and choose w_{0} ∈D_{O} with annihilator aO. Suppose c, n : G_{ℚ} →D_{O}[a] are continuous cocycles for α, β, respectively. Let N ̸= 0 be divisible by ℓ, and let q ̸= ℓ be prime. Assume the following local conditions, at every conjugate place:

1. Away from the primes dividing Nq, α ≡1 (mod a), and c = n = 0 on inertia.

2. At primes dividing N other than q, c(g) = (α(g) −1)m_{v} on the decomposition group, with am_{v} = 0.

3. At q, both α, β are one modulo a on the decomposition group, and c is zero on inertia.

Then for g ∈D_{q}, τ ∈I_{q}, and y ∈O with n(τ) = yw_{0},

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
y c(g) = 0.

Proof. Use B = O/aO and the identification ι : B →D_{O}[a], ̄z →→zw_{0}. It is injective by the annihilator condition and surjective because D_{O}[a] is a cyclic module of length v_{O}(a). Choose r ≥1 with a | ℓ^{r}; then B is a finite ℤ/ℓ^{r}-algebra. Write c = ιc^{′}, n = ιn^{′}, and reduce α, β to B^{×}. They satisfy αβ = χ_{ℓ} mod B. The cocycle and local conditions pass to these reductions by injectivity of ι. We prove n^{′}(τ)c^{′}(g) = 0 in B.

Let λ : B →ℤ/ℓ^{r} be any ℤ/ℓ^{r}-linear map and form

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
w(g, h) = λ(n^{′}(g)α(g)c^{′}(h)).

The two cocycle identities and αβ = χ_{ℓ} give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
χ_{ℓ}(g)w(h, k) −w(gh, k) + w(g, hk) −w(g, h) = 0.

For example expand the two middle terms; the n^{′}(g)α(g)α(h)c^{′}(k) terms cancel, and the remaining terms agree because α(g)β(g) = χ_{ℓ}(g). Thus w is a continuous two-cocycle with coefficients ℤ/ℓ^{r}(1). It factors through the Galois group unramified outside Nq. Indeed the common kernel of the scalar characters and both cocycles contains all the excluded inertias and is closed and normal; the identity

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c^{′}(gug^{−1}) = c^{′}(g) + α(g)c^{′}(u) + α(gu)c^{′}(g^{−1})

shows its normality, and the same calculation applies to n^{′}.

At v | N, v ̸= q, write the local coboundary parameter as m^{′}_{v}∈B. Then the local restriction of w is the coboundary of

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
b_{v}(g) = −λ(n^{′}(g)α(g)m^{′}_{v}).

Expanding db_{v}(g, h) gives exactly w(g, h); the cross terms cancel by the product character identity. At all excluded primes the local class is unramified of degree two and is zero. The sum of the local invariants of the global degree-two class is zero. This is the degree-two localization exactness in Milne, Arithmetic

Duality Theorems, I, Theorem 4.10(b), already used in Proposition 8.29. At the real place the odd-primary cohomology vanishes by averaging over its group of order two. All invariants except possibly that at q have therefore vanished; the invariant at q is zero too. The local invariant is injective for these coefficients by finite local Tate duality. Consequently w|_{Dq} is a coboundary.

We spell out the local consequence, since the unramified condition on c^{′} matters. Fix a Frobenius σ at q. Any continuous additive homomorphism from D_{q} that vanishes on I_{q} and at σ is zero: it factors through D_{q}/I_{q} ≃ ℤ̂, where the powers of Frobenius are dense. For every unramified character x : D_{q} → ℤ/ℓ^{r}, apply this observation to the B-valued homomorphism

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
h −−→x(h)c^{′}(σ) −x(σ)c^{′}(h).

It gives x(h)c^{′}(σ) = x(σ)c^{′}(h). The function f(g) = λ(n^{′}(g)c^{′}(σ)) is a ℤ/ℓ^{r}(1)-cocycle on D_{q}: the two reduced actions are trivial there, and λ is scalar-linear. Moreover

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
f(g)x(h) = x(σ)λ(n^{′}(g)c^{′}(h)) = x(σ)w(g, h).

Thus its cup product with every unramified x is zero. The unramified subgroups are exact annihilators under local Tate duality: Milne, I, Theorem 2.6, printed pp. 30–31. Its hypotheses hold here because the module ℤ/ℓ^{r} is finite and unramified, and q ̸= ℓ. Hence f is unramified. The cyclotomic character is trivial on inertia at q, so every coboundary vanishes there, and f(τ) = 0. We have proved λ(n^{′}(τ)c^{′}(σ)) = 0. Apply the Frobenius-density observation again to g →→λ(n^{′}(τ)c^{′}(g)). It is zero for every g ∈D_{q}.

Finally these linear maps λ separate the points of B. To see this, decompose its finite ℤ_{ℓ}-module into cyclic modules ℤ/ℓ^{si}, s_{i} ≤ r. A nonzero coordinate is detected by projection followed by multiplication by ℓ^{r−si} into ℤ/ℓ^{r}. It follows that n^{′}(τ)c^{′}(g) = 0. Since n^{′}(τ) = ̄y, applying ι gives y c(g) = 0, as required.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/OverIff.lean:23--367; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ChiDvd.lean:37--154

Lemma 8.69 (The Jacobi-sum Kummer elements). Let K = ℚ(µ_{M}), M ≥1, write σ_{t}ζ_{M} = ζ_{M}^{t}, and fix 0 ≤b < M. For a nonzero integral ideal I of K there is X_{I} ∈K^{×} with

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X_{I}X_{I} = 1, (X_{I}) = ∏ (σ_{t}^{−1}I)^{hb(t)}, h_{b}(t) =⌊̃^{tb}⌋−⌊^{−}̃^{tb}⌋.
t∈(ℤ/M)^{×MM}

Two elements satisfying these identities for the same I, b differ by a root of unity of order dividing 2M.

Proof. First let I = P have rational prime norm p, with p ∤ M. The reduction of ζ_{M} is primitive, so M | p −1 and p splits completely in K. Let π : O_{K} → F_{p} have kernel P, put d = (p −1)/M, and choose the multiplicative character ξ : F^{×}_{p} →µ_{M} whose reduction is x →→x^{d}. It has order exactly M: evaluate at a generator of F^{×}_{p}. Extend nontrivial characters by zero at zero. For 1 ≤j < b, put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ b∏−1
J_{j} = ξ(x)ξ^{j}(1 −x), J = J_{j}.
x∈Fp j=1

The characters ξ, ξ^{j}, ξ^{j+1} are nontrivial since j +1 ≤b < M. Finite character orthogonality gives J_{j}J_{j} = p. One derivation writes the Jacobi sum as τ(ξ)τ(ξ^{j})/τ(ξ^{j+1}) by grouping the terms in the product of two Gauss sums according to their sum, and uses the Gauss norm computation above. Thus J_{j} is a nonzero integral divisor of p.

Write P_{t} = σ_{t}^{−1}P. Reducing the Jacobi sum after σ_{t} gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
π(σ_{t}J_{j}) = ∑x^{d}̃^{t}(1 −x)^{djt}̃.
x∈Fp

Both exponents lie strictly between zero and p−1. Expanding the second factor and using ∑_{x}x^{A} = 0 unless positive A is a multiple of p −1, when the sum is −1, shows that this expression is zero exactly when the two exponents sum to less than p −1. If their sum is at least p −1, precisely one exponent in the expansion is a multiple, and its binomial coefficient is nonzero modulo p, since its top is less than p. Therefore

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
J_{j} ∈P_{t} ⇐⇒ ̃t + ̃jt < M.

The primes P_{t} are distinct and pO_{K} =∏_{t}P_{t}. Divisibility by p consequently determines the entire ideal of J_{j} from this membership test. If carry(u, v) is one when ̃u + ̃v ≥M, and zero otherwise, the exponent of P_{t} in (J) is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑b−1 ⌊̃_{tb}⌋

r_{t} = {1 − carry(t, jt)} = b −1 − .

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
j=1^{M}

The last identity telescopes ⌊̃t(j +1)/M⌋−⌊̃tj/M⌋= carry(t, jt). For b = 0, 1 the products are empty and the conclusion follows directly with X = 1. For b ≥2, put X_{P} = J/J. It has norm one under conjugation, and the exponent at P_{t} is r_{−t} −r_{t} = h_{b}(t). This proves the assertion for P.

For a general I, choose a prime P of rational prime norm outside M in the inverse ideal class of I. The Hilbert class field and Chebotarev provide such a prime. Explicitly its Hilbert class field is Galois over ℚ, by uniqueness and the normality of the cyclotomic base. Choose a Frobenius conjugacy class in that field restricting to the identity on K and to the inverse class under Artin over K; a choice of prime above the resulting rational prime realizes the required member of this conjugacy class. The rational prime then splits in K, so its chosen prime has degree one. It can avoid any prescribed finite set by Lemma 8.43. Write IP = (z), z ̸= 0. For a principal ideal set

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
X_{(z)} =∏σ_{t}^{−1}(z)^{hb(t)}.
t

Since h_{b}(−t) = −h_{b}(t), this element has norm one; its ideal is the required product. Then X_{I} = X_{(z)}/X_{P} has both required properties by multiplication of fractional ideal identities.

For uniqueness let U = X_{I}/X_{I}^{′}. It is a unit and U^{ ̄}U = 1. Complex conjugation commutes with all embeddings of the cyclotomic field, so every complex conjugate of U has absolute value one. The powers U^{n} have monic integral characteristic polynomials of bounded degree and bounded coefficients, by the elementary-symmetric formulas. There are only finitely many such polynomials and finitely many roots of each; two powers agree, making U a root of unity. If its order is t, then ℚ(µ_{lcm(M,t)}) = K. Comparison of the cyclotomic degrees φ(lcm(M, t)) = φ(M) forces t | 2M: increasing any existing prime exponent raises the degree, and a new prime raises it unless it is a single factor two with M odd. For M = 1, 2, the field is ℚ, and the same conclusion follows directly from its roots ±1.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XJacPowNe.lean:11--184; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XEx.lean:12--55; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XUniqConj.lean:6--84

Lemma 8.70 (Norm and congruence of the Kummer elements). Let M ≥ 1, let q ∤ M be prime, put K = ℚ(µ_{M}), K^{′}= ℚ(µ_{qM}), and write u = q mod M. Fix b < min(M, q). Suppose I^{′}̸= 0 is an integral ideal of K^{′}, and let X^{′} and X be Kummer elements of Lemma 8.69 for I^{′} and N_{K}′_{/K}I^{′}, respectively. Then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
N_{K}′_{/K}X^{′}= ζ_{σu−}^{X}_{1X ,} ζ^{2M} = 1.

If I^{′} is coprime to q, there is also η ∈µ_{2qM}(K^{′}), independent of the prime v | q, such that

X^{′}≡η σ_{u}^{−1}X (mod v) (v | q).

Here a congruence of these generally fractional elements means equality of their images in the residue field of the local ring; all the elements being compared are units there.

Proof. We first prove the distribution identity responsible for both assertions. With the exponent h_{b} of

Lemma 8.69, it is ∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
h_{b}(t^{′}) = h_{b}(t) −h_{b}(u^{−1}t). (221)
t_{t}^{′}_{′}∈_{mod}(ℤ/_{ M}qM_{=})^{×}_{t}

Indeed the representatives in the residue class ̃t mod M are ̃t + iM, 0 ≤i < q. Precisely one is divisible by q, namely qũ^{−1}t; the others are units modulo qM. For 0 < b < q, the residues of c + ib modulo q permute the residues 0, . . . , q −1. Summing quotient and remainder in division by q, and subtracting the same identity for c = 0, gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑^{q−1}⌊c + ib⌋_{= c +}∑^{q−1}⌊ib⌋_{.}
i=0^{q} i=0^{q}

Applying division first by M, this yields

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑^{q−1}⌊(̃t + iM)b⌋_{=}⌊̃tb⌋_{+}∑^{q−1}⌊ib⌋_{.}
i=0^{qMM} i=0^{q}

Delete the one nonunit term and subtract the corresponding formula for −t. The constant sums cancel, proving (221). For b = 0 all terms are zero.

Extend the fractional ideals of K to K^{′}. The extension of NI^{′} is ∏_{ρ∈Gal(K}′_{/K)}ρI^{′}. This follows prime by prime: if a prime above a base prime has ramification index e and residue degree f, its norm is the f-th power of the base prime, and both products have exponent ef at each conjugate prime. The norm of X^{′} is the product of its conjugates. Use the prescribed ideal of each factor, and group the exponents by their image in (ℤ/M)^{×}. Formula (221) shows that the result is the extended ideal of X/σ_{u}^{−1}X. Extension is injective on fractional ideals, since at a prime above P it multiplies the exponent at P by a positive ramification index. The two principal ideals in K therefore agree. Both generators have norm one under complex conjugation: conjugation commutes with the norm and with σ_{u}. Their quotient is thus a norm-one unit. The uniqueness part of Lemma 8.69 makes it a 2M-th root of unity, proving the norm relation.

For the congruence we first treat principal ideals. Let y ∈O_{K}′ be a unit at every prime above q, and set

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
A^{′}=∏σ_{t}^{−}_{′} (^{1} y)^{hb(t′)}, A =∏σ_{t}^{−1}(N_{K}′_{/K}y)^{hb(t)}.
t^{′} t

We claim that A^{′}≡σ_{u}^{−1}A at every v | q. Fix such a v and its reduction map π. For each t choose a lift s(t) modulo qM and put f(t) = π(σ_{s}^{−}_{(}^{1}_{t)}y). These values are nonzero and do not depend on the lift. To check this last point, a primitive qM-th root generates O_{K}′ as a ℤ-algebra. Two reduction homomorphisms whose

values on its q-th power agree have equal values on the root, because Frobenius is injective in the residue field of characteristic q. They are therefore the same homomorphism. Restriction to K determines the image of that q-th power. The same argument applied to a lift of u proves that its action on residues is the q-power Frobenius. Consequently

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
f(t) = f(ut)^{q}.

All q −1 = [K^{′}: K] conjugates in the relative norm have the same reduction. Grouping the product for A^{′} by fibers and applying (221) now gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
π(A^{′}) =∏f(t)^{hb(t)−hb(u−1t)}
t
∏(_{ f(t)} )h_{b}(t) ∏
= = f(ut)^{(q−1)hb(t)}= π(σ_{u}^{−1}A).
t^{f(ut)} t

Negative exponents are legitimate because the residues are nonzero. More explicitly, represent each factor by an integral numerator and denominator prime to v; multiplying these representations and clearing their unit denominators proves the asserted congruence in the local ring. No global integrality of A^{′} is required.

Next suppose I^{′}= P^{′}= ker(O_{K}′ → F_{p}), where p ∤qM is rational prime. Its relative norm is the kernel of the restricted map on O_{K}: both residue fields are F_{p}, so the residue degree is one. In the Jacobi-sum construction of Lemma 8.69, choose characters ξ^{′} at level qM and ξ at level M with the specified reductions modulo P^{′}. Reduction is injective on the prime-to-p roots involved, and their defining powers give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(ξ^{′}(x))^{q}= ξ(x) (x ̸= 0).

Write g = σ_{u}^{−1} on K. Since g(z)^{q} = z for z ∈µ_{M}, at any v | q the two elements ξ^{′}(x) and g(ξ(x)) have equal q-th powers. Injectivity of Frobenius in the residue field implies equality of their reductions. The same is true after complex conjugation, which acts by inversion on roots of unity. It follows term by term in each Jacobi sum, and then by multiplication, that

J^{′}≡g(J), J^{′}≡g(J) (mod v).

Every Jacobi factor divides p, as proved above, hence is a unit at v | q. We may divide these congruences. Thus the canonical quotients J^{′}/J^{′} and g(J/J) agree modulo every v | q. Replacing the canonical quotients by X^{′} and X multiplies them by roots of unity of orders dividing 2qM and 2M. Their quotient produces a single η ∈µ_{2qM}(K^{′}), valid simultaneously at all v | q.

Finally let I^{′} be arbitrary and coprime to q. Choose a degree-one prime P^{′} in its inverse ideal class, away from qM, by the Hilbert-class-field argument already given, and write P^{′}I^{′}= (y). Then y is a unit at every prime above q. The principal Kummer products A^{′}, A just defined satisfy

A^{′}/X^{′} is a Kummer element for P^{′}, A/X is one for NP^{′}.

The prime-ideal case supplies a single η_{1} ∈µ_{2qM} with

A^{′}/X^{′}≡η_{1} g(A)/g(X) (mod v), A^{′}≡g(A) (mod v).

All these quantities are local units. For clarity, the unit assertion for a Kummer element follows directly from its ideal: if 1 = a + rq with a ∈I^{′}, then 1 = σ_{t}^{−1}a + σ_{t}^{−1}r q shows that no conjugate of I^{′} is contained in v | q. Every exponent of its prescribed principal ideal at v is zero. Divide the two congruences to obtain X^{′}≡η_{1}^{−1}g(X) (mod v). This proves the assertion with one root of unity for all the primes.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ThDist.lean:6--162; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XNormDiv.lean:272--338; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XCongPrin.lean:9--220; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/XCongJac.lean:12--171; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/AlgStep.lean:12--203

Lemma 8.71 (A strict cyclotomic Euler system). Let ℓ be an odd prime, m ≥1, (N_{0}, ℓ) = 1, and F = N_{0}ℓ^{m}. Let r ≡1 (mod F) be prime, b < F, and fix a place A_{0} of ℚ above r. Call a prime q admissible if

q ≡1 (mod F), q ̸= r, ℓ∤ ord_{q}(r).

Call d admissible if it is squarefree and all its prime factors are admissible. Let δ ∈G_{ℚ} act on µ_{ℓ}m by the a-th power, with a ≥0. There exist nonzero X_{d} ∈ℚ(µ_{Fd}) and integers s(d, q) prime to ℓ, for admissible qd, such that, on putting

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(_{δX} )2N_{0}d
x_{d} =_{a}^{d} , s^{′}(d, q) = q s(d, q),
^{X}d

the following identities hold. The elements x_{d} are units away from r. If τ fixes µ_{Fd} and generates the Galois group at q, and if φ acts on µ_{Fd} by the q-th power, then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q∏−2_{′}
τ^{i}x_{qd} = (x_{d}/φ^{−1}x_{d})^{s(d,q)}, (222)
i=0_{′}

x_{qd} ≡(φ^{−1}x_{d})^{s(d,q)} (mod A) (A | q). (223)

Moreover, with normalized valuation ord_{A0} r = 1, and with σ_{t} any lift of t ∈(ℤ/F)^{×},

ord_{A0}(σ_{t}X_{1}) = h_{b}(t).

All identities concern the fixed elements in ℚ; they do not require a new choice of X_{d} for each pair (d, q).

Proof. For each d ̸= 0, restrict A_{0} to ℚ(µ_{Fd}), obtaining a prime P_{d} above r, and choose X_{d} for this ideal by

Lemma 8.69. It is nonzero, fixed by the subgroup fixing µ_{Fd}, and a unit away from r, since its ideal involves only conjugates of P_{d}. The field ℚ(µ_{F} ) is unramified and split at r, since r ≡1 (mod F). Its conjugate primes are distinct and have ramification index one. Reading the exponent of P_{1} in (σ_{t}X_{1}) gives exactly h_{b}(t), proving the last assertion.

Suppose qd is admissible. Then q ∤Fd, q > F > b, and r ∤Fqd. The relative norm of P_{qd} is P_{d}^{s}, where s is its residue degree over P_{d}. In the unramified cyclotomic extension its residue degree divides ord_{Fqd}(r). The latter is prime to ℓ: the component modulo F has order one, and by the Chinese remainder theorem the remaining components have the specified prime-to-ℓ orders at the distinct prime factors of qd. Thus ℓ∤s. The element X_{d}^{s} has the prescribed Kummer ideal for NP_{qd}, and still has norm one under conjugation.

Lemma 8.70, with M = Fd, gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q∏−2
τ^{i}X_{qd} = ζ (X_{d}/φ^{−1}X_{d})^{s},
i=0

X_{qd} ≡η (φ^{−1}X_{d})^{s} (mod A) (A | q),

with ζ, η ∈µ_{2Fqd}. Here the relative norm is the displayed product because q ∤Fd and τ generates its group of order q −1. The chosen embeddings of the fields are compatible inside ℚ, and σ_{q}^{−1} in the preceding lemma is the restriction of φ^{−1}. This proves both relations for the already chosen X_{d}, X_{qd}. Choose one such residue degree s(d, q) for each admissible pair.

Write P_{δ}(z) = δz/z^{a}. It is multiplicative and commutes with integer powers. On a cyclotomic field all Galois actions commute, so it also commutes there with τ and φ. For ϵ^{2Fn}= 1 we have

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P_{δ}(ϵ)^{2N0n}= P_{δ}(ϵ^{2N0n}) = 1,

because ϵ^{2N0n} is an ℓ^{m}-th root and δ acts on those roots by the a-th power. Apply P_{δ} to the first lax relation and raise to 2N_{0}qd. The root-of-unity factor disappears; the remaining exponent is 2N_{0}qd s = (2N_{0}d) s^{′}. This gives (222).

For the local relation, apply the lax congruence both at A and at δ^{−1}A, which is also above q. Applying δ to the latter gives the congruence of the δ-images at A. All quantities are units at A, because q ̸= r. Multiplication, inversion, and positive powers preserve congruence of units in the local ring. Dividing by the a-th power of the original congruence and raising to 2N_{0}qd therefore gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P_{δ}(X_{qd})^{2N0qd}≡P_{δ}(η(φ^{−1}X_{d})^{s})^{2N0qd}.

The same root-of-unity calculation removes η, and commutativity of the actions identifies the right side with (φ^{−1}x_{d})^{s′}. This proves (223). The unit and fixed-field properties of x_{d} follow from those of X_{d}; conjugating a place does not change its underlying rational prime. Finally q ̸= ℓ, since q ≡1 (mod F) and ℓ| F, so s^{′}= qs remains prime to ℓ.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/PlaceEmb.lean:18--231; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/SysOfLax.lean:12--153

Lemma 8.72 (Derivative classes and their local step). Retain Lemma 8.71, put M = ℓ^{m}, H = G_{ℚ(µF )}, and fix a primitive M-th root ζ. For every prime q choose τ_{q} which generates the action on µ_{q} and fixes all roots of unity of order prime to q. Define, multiplicatively,

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q∏−2
D_{q}u = (τ_{q}^{i}u)^{i}, D_{L} = D_{q1} · · · D_{qj}, y_{L} = D_{L}x∏_{L},
i=0

where L = (q_{1}, . . . , q_{j}) has distinct admissible entries. For every g ∈H there is z_{g} ∈ℚ(µ_{F}∏_{L})^{×} with z_{g}^{M} = g(y_{L})/y_{L}. Choose Y_{L}^{M} = y_{L} in ℚ, and put P_{δ}v = δv/v^{a}. There is a uniquely determined continuous homomorphism κ_{L} : H →ℤ/M satisfying

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ζ^{κL(g)}=_{P}^{g}_{δ}^{(}_{Y}^{P}_{L}^{δ}_{ P}^{YL}_{δz}^{)}_{g}. (224)

It is independent of all choices of roots. It is unramified away from Fr∏L. If q is admissible and not in L, A | q, φ is a Frobenius at A, and t ∈I_{A} acts on µ_{q} as τ_{q}, then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
κ_{q::L}(t) = −s^{′}(∏L, q) κ_{L}(φ) in ℤ/M. (225)

Proof. The stated choices of τ_{q} exist in inertia at q. Indeed Φ_{q}(1 + T) is Eisenstein at q, so ℚ_{q}(µ_{q})/ℚ_{q} is totally ramified of degree q −1 and inertia maps onto (ℤ/q)^{×}. A lift of a generator has the required action. Prime-to-q roots of unity are unramified, since their reduction is separable and their lifts are unique by Hensel’s lemma; inertia fixes them. These assertions also apply to any conjugate place above q, and give the elements t in the statement.

Each D_{q} is multiplicative, commutes with integer powers, and preserves nonzero elements and units away from r. On a cyclotomic field it commutes with every Galois action, since the Galois group is abelian.

Thus the different D_{q}’s commute there and D_{L} is unchanged on permuting the list. The elementary telescop-ing identity is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{τq(Dqu)u}q−1
= ∏_{q−2 i} if τ_{q}^{q−1}u = u. (226)
^{Dqu} i=0^{τ}q^{u}

To check it, shift the index in the numerator: each middle conjugate has exponent −1, the last has exponent q −2, and the first has exponent zero. Replacing the last conjugate by u gives the right side.

We prove the assertion about z_{g} by induction on the length of L. For the empty list y_{L} = x_{1} is fixed by H, and z_{g} = 1 works. Suppose a prime q is added, put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n =∏L, y^{′}= D_{L}x_{n}, w = D_{L}x_{qn}, c = s^{′}(n, q), D = D_{q}w, q −1 = Mk.

Let φ act on µ_{Fn} by the q-th power. It belongs to H, since q ≡ 1 (mod F). By induction choose z_{0} ∈ ℚ(µ_{Fn}) with z_{0}^{M} = φ^{−1}y^{′}/y^{′}. Apply D_{L} to the strict norm relation:

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
q∏−2
τ_{q}^{i}w = (y^{′}/φ^{−1}y^{′})^{c}.
i=0

Formula (226) implies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
^{τ}_{D}^{qD} =(w^{k}z_{0}^{c})^{M}.

The element w^{k}z_{0}^{c} lies in ℚ(µ_{Fqn}). This constructs the required root for the generator τ_{q}. For a fixed y_{L}, the property that such a root exists in ℚ(µ_{F}∏_{L}) is closed under products of g’s: if z_{g}, z_{h} are roots, g(z_{h})z_{g} is a root for gh. It holds on the subgroup fixing that field, with root one. The quotient of H by this subgroup is the product of the cyclic groups (ℤ/q)^{×}, q ∈L, by the Chinese remainder theorem. Its generators are the images of the τ_{q}’s. For each generator permute q to the head of L and apply the construction just made to the shorter list. Every coset is a product of these generators and every element of the kernel already has the property. This proves the induction.

The right side of (224) has M-th power one: raise to M, use Y_{L}^{M} = y_{L}, z_{g}^{M} = g(y_{L})/y_{L}, and commuta-tivity of g, δ on the cyclotomic element y_{L}. It therefore defines κ_{L}(g) uniquely modulo M. If two roots have the same M-th power, their quotient lies in µ_{M} and P_{δ} of their quotient is one. This proves independence both of Y_{L} and of z_{g}, even if a different root z_{g} is used outside the cyclotomic field. For g, h ∈ H, use g(z_{h})z_{g} for z_{gh}. The actions of g, δ commute on z_{h}, and g fixes µ_{M}. Multiplying the formulas for g, h there-fore gives ζ^{κL(gh)}= ζ^{κL(g)+κL(h)}. Primitivity of ζ proves additivity. Its kernel contains the open subgroup fixing both ℚ(µ_{F}∏_{L}) and the algebraic number P_{δ}Y_{L}: for such a g take z_{g} = 1. Thus the homomorphism is locally constant.

At a place A ∤ Fr∏L, inertia fixes y_{L}, since the cyclotomic field is unramified there. In (224) take z_{g} = 1 for g ∈I_{A}. The element P_{δ}Y_{L} is a unit at A: its M-th power and that of its δ-conjugate are units away from r, and a nonzero valuation with M-th power one equals one. Inertia acts trivially on its residue. Hence ζ^{κL(g)} ≡ 1 (mod A). Reduction is injective on µ_{M} at residue characteristic prime to M. For example, after factoring (T^{M}−1)/(T −1), a root congruent to one would give the unit M equal to zero modulo the maximal ideal unless it were one. Thus κ_{L}(g) = 0.

It remains to prove the local step, where both the norm and the congruence are needed. Use n, y^{′}, w, c, D, k, z_{0} as above, now with φ the specified local Frobenius. The inertia element t and τ_{q} have the same action on µ_{q}, and both fix µ_{Fn}, so they agree on ℚ(µ_{Fqn}). Consequently tD = τ_{q}D, and Z = w^{k}z_{0}^{c} is an allowed root for tD/D. Take Y^{M} = D, Y^{′M} = y^{′}, and put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P = P_{δ}Y, P^{′}= P_{δ}Y^{′}, v = φ^{−1}y^{′}, U = φ^{−1}P^{′}.

The formulas defining the two κ’s and multiplicativity of P_{δ} give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
_{ζ}κ_{q::L}(t)_{ tP} (_{ P} ′)^{c}
_{(ζκL(φ−1))c} =_{PUq} (P_{δ}(w/v^{c}))^{−k}. (227)

For verification, U^{M} = P_{δ}v; as q = 1 + Mk, U^{q} = U(P_{δ}v)^{k}. Substitute these identities and P_{δ}Z = (P_{δ}w)^{k}(P_{δ}z_{0})^{c} into (224); cancellation gives exactly (227).

Each factor on its right is congruent to one at A. The first is so because P is a local unit and t is inertia. For the second, U is a local unit and φU = P^{′}; Frobenius gives P^{′} ≡ U^{q}. For the last, apply D_{L} to the strict congruence of Lemma 8.71. Congruence to one at every place above q is preserved by Galois conjugation, products, and integer powers. It follows that w/v^{c}≡1 at every such place. The same is true of its δ-conjugate, so P_{δ}(w/v^{c}) ≡1. The left side of (227) is an M-th root of unity; q ∤M makes reduction injective, so it equals one. Primitivity gives κ_{q::L}(t) = cκ_{L}(φ^{−1}). Additivity gives κ_{L}(φ^{−1}) = −κ_{L}(φ), proving (225).

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/IneTau.lean:8--52; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/DerBasic.lean:11--179; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/DerInv.lean:14--268; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/KolEx.lean:7--37; Devel-opment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/KolHom.lean:10--136; Develop-ment/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/KolUnr.lean:8--59; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/KolStep.lean:15--259

Proposition 8.73 (The equivariant system and its initial value). Let O be the ring of integers of a finite extension of ℚ_{ℓ}, and D_{O} = Frac(O)/O. Retain F = N_{0}ℓ^{m}, M = ℓ^{m}, and assume a character α : G_{ℚ} → O^{×} satisfies

α|_{H} ≡1 (mod MO), α(g) ≡−1 (mod MO) if g|_{µF} = −1, H = G_{ℚ(µF )}.

Suppose some δ ∈G_{ℚ} has α(δ) −χ_{ℓ}(δ) ∈O^{×}. Fix lifts σ_{t} of all t ∈(ℤ/F)^{×}, b < F, and w ∈D_{O}[M]. Write ∑

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
β = χ_{ℓ}α^{−1}, z_{b} = h_{b}(t)α(σ_{t})^{−1}.
t

For each prime r ≡1 (mod F), and each place A_{0} | r, there are continuous homomorphisms ν_{L} : H → D_{O}[M], indexed by admissible lists, with these properties:

1. ν_{L}(gug^{−1}) = β(g)ν_{L}(u) for g ∈G_{ℚ}, u ∈H; ν_{L} is unramified outside Fr∏L.

2. If q :: L is admissible, A | q, and φ is a Frobenius at A, then some t ∈I_{A} and unit u ∈O^{×} satisfy

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{q::L}(t) = uν_{L}(φ).

3. Some t_{0} ∈I_{A0} and u_{0} ∈O^{×} satisfy ν_{∅}(t_{0}) = u_{0}z_{b}w.

All these properties hold for the same system.

Proof. Choose a representing the action of δ on µ_{M}, so χ_{ℓ}(δ) = a + Me for some e ∈O. Use this δ, a in Lemmas 8.71 and 8.72. On H, both χ_{ℓ} and α are one modulo MO; hence so is β. Define

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{L}(u) = ∑ κ_{L}(σ_{t}^{−1}uσ_{t}) β(σ_{t})w. (228)
t∈(ℤ/F)^{×}

Multiplication by a class in ℤ/M is well defined since Mw = 0. Additivity and local constancy follow term by term from those of κ_{L}; the sum is finite. Every term is killed by M. Conjugating an inertia group conjugates its place without changing the underlying rational prime. The unramified assertion therefore follows from that for κ_{L}.

Here is the equivariance, including its independence from the chosen lifts. If g has cyclotomic residue b_{0}, then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
σ_{b0s} = gσ_{s}k_{s} (k_{s} ∈H).

An additive homomorphism on H is unchanged by conjugation by k_{s}. Also β(k_{s}) acts as one on w, since it is one modulo MO. In (228) for gug^{−1}, reindex t = b_{0}s. The t-th summand becomes

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
κ_{L}(k_{s}^{−1}σ_{s}^{−1}uσ_{s}k_{s})β(g)β(σ_{s})β(k_{s})w = β(g) κ_{L}(σ_{s}^{−1}uσ_{s})β(σ_{s})w.

Summation proves property (1).

For (2), choose t ∈I_{A} with its action on µ_{q} equal to that of τ_{q}, as in the preceding lemma. For every c ∈(ℤ/F)^{×}, conjugating by σ_{c}^{−1} gives inertia and Frobenius at the conjugate place. Conjugation leaves the action on µ_{q} unchanged, since its Galois group is abelian. Thus (225) gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
κ_{q::L}(σ_{c}^{−1}tσ_{c}) = −s^{′}(∏L, q)κ_{L}(σ_{c}^{−1}φσ_{c}).

Multiply by β(σ_{c})w and sum. The scalar −s^{′}(∏L, q) is a unit of O, because it is prime to ℓ. This proves (2).

For the initial evaluation choose ρ^{M} = r. There is t_{0} ∈I_{A0} with t_{0}ρ = ζρ. One can see the precise surjectivity as follows. Inertia fixes µ_{M}, since r ∤M. Therefore t →→tρ/ρ is a homomorphism from inertia into µ_{M}. Let its image have order d. Then ρ^{d} is inertia-fixed. The fixed field of inertia in the local algebraic closure is unramified and its normalized value group is ℤ. As v_{r}(ρ^{d}) = d/M, we obtain M | d. But d ≤M, so d = M. This gives the required t_{0}, and is the valuation argument used for the source’s radical-inertia supplier.

We record the local calculation that fixes the normalization. If Y^{M} = y, y ∈ ℚ(µ_{F} ), and ord_{A0}(σ_{c}P_{δ}y) = k(c), put W = σ_{c}P_{δ}Y . Then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(W/ρ^{k(c)})^{M} = σ_{c}P_{δ}y/r^{k(c)}

is a local unit fixed by t_{0}. The quotient t_{0}(W/ρ^{k(c)})/(W/ρ^{k(c)}) is an M-th root of unity congruent to one, since t_{0} is inertia. It is one, because r ∤ M. Hence t_{0}W/W = ζ^{k(c)}. On the other hand, (224), with g = σ_{c}^{−1}t_{0}σ_{c}, has z_{g}^{M} = 1, so P_{δ}z_{g} = 1. Applying σ_{c} to that formula gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c κ_{∅}(σ_{c}^{−1}t_{0}σ_{c}) = k(c) in ℤ/M.

In our construction y = x_{1} = (P_{δ}X_{1})^{2N0}, and the initial valuation function of X_{1} is h_{b}. If d ∈(ℤ/F)^{×} is the residue of δ, applying P_{δ} changes a valuation function h to c →→h(cd) −ah(c). Thus here

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
k(c) = 2N_{0}{h_{b}(cd^{2}) −2ah_{b}(cd) + a^{2}h_{b}(c)}.

As χ_{ℓ}(σ_{c}) ≡c (mod MO), formula (228) and the preceding local calculation imply

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{∅}(t_{0}) = ∑k(c)α(σ_{c})^{−1})w.
c

For any integer-valued h, reindexing c →→cd, and using σ_{cd}^{−1}σ_{c}δ ∈H, gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
∑ ∑

{h(cd) −ah(c)}α(σ_{c})^{−1}≡(α(δ) −a) h(c)α(σ_{c})^{−1} (mod MO).

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c c

Apply this identity twice, and multiply by 2N_{0}. The terms in MO kill w, yielding

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
ν_{∅}(t_{0}) = 2N_{0}(α(δ) −a)^{2}z_{b}w.

Finally α(δ) −a = α(δ) −χ_{ℓ}(δ) + Me is a unit: its first summand is a unit and its second is in the maximal ideal, since m ≥1. Also 2N_{0} is a unit since ℓ is odd and (N_{0}, ℓ) = 1. Thus the displayed multiplier is the required unit u_{0}.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ValAddSmul.lean:8--107; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/IneRad.lean:8--123; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/KolInit.lean:7--114; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ZSumPKey.lean:6--41; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/NuSysEx.lean:21--275

Lemma 8.74 (Choosing a prime with two prescribed values). Use the hypotheses on α, F, M of Proposi-tion 8.73. Let r ∤F be prime, T ̸= 0, and let c, ν : H →D_{O}[M] be continuous homomorphisms equivariant under α and β = χ_{ℓ}α^{−1}, respectively. If c ̸= 0, there is an admissible prime q ∤T, a place A | q, and a Frobenius φ ∈H at A such that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
c(φ) ̸= 0, ν(H) ⊆Oν(φ).

Proof. Choose ρ^{M} = r, and put J = H ∩ Stab(ρ). This is an open subgroup. We use the following elementary radical calculation. If an equivariant homomorphism f : H →W[M], of character γ, vanishes on J, then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
(γ(g) −χ_{ℓ}(g))f(u) = 0 (g ∈G_{ℚ}, u ∈H). (229)

Indeed uρ = ξρ with ξ ∈µ_{M}. If k represents χ_{ℓ}(g) mod M, then gug^{−1}ρ = ξ^{k}ρ = u^{k}ρ. Thus gug^{−1}= u^{k}v with v ∈J. Applying f gives γ(g)f(u) = kf(u) = χ_{ℓ}(g)f(u); the last equality uses Mf(u) = 0.

Let B = ker c, an open subgroup of H. It does not contain J: otherwise (229), with γ = α, and the unit α(δ) −χ_{ℓ}(δ), would force c = 0. The compact group H has finite image under ν. The cyclic submodules of D_{O} are totally ordered by inclusion: a nonzero element represented by π^{−j}v, v ∈O^{×}, generates exactly D_{O}[π^{j}]. Choose u_{∗} ∈ H with maximal cyclic module Oν(u_{∗}). It contains the entire image of ν. If that image is zero put K = B. Otherwise put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
P = 𝔪_{O}ν(u_{∗}), K = {u ∈H : ν(u) ∈P}.

This too is an open subgroup, and J is not contained in it. For if it were, apply (229) to ν mod P. For a lift g of −1 mod F, α(g) + 1 ∈MO ⊂𝔪_{O}. Consequently 1 −α(g) is a unit: otherwise their sum 2 would be in 𝔪_{O}, contrary to ℓ̸= 2. But β(g) −χ_{ℓ}(g) = β(g)(1 −α(g)) is then a unit, forcing ν(u_{∗}) ∈P. This means ν(u_{∗}) = vν(u_{∗}) for some v ∈𝔪_{O}. As 1 −v is a unit, it forces ν(u_{∗}) = 0, a contradiction. For φ /∈K, its coefficient in ν(φ) = vν(u_{∗}) is a unit; thus ν(φ) generates the O-span of ν(H).

The third subgroup to avoid is C = G_{ℚ(µF ℓ)}. We claim J ⊂⊂C. Choose u, g ∈G_{ℚ} acting on µ_{Fℓ} as 1 + F and −1. The first is a unit modulo Fℓ, since ℓ| F. Then u ∈H, and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
gug^{−1}u ∈J.

For verification, write uρ = ξρ and g^{−1}ρ = ηρ, with ξ, η ∈µ_{M} ⊂µ_{F} . The element u fixes η, g inverts ξ, and gug^{−1} fixes ξ, giving gug^{−1}uρ = ρ. Its action on µ_{Fℓ}, however, is (1 + F)^{2}. If it lay in C, then Fℓ| F(F + 2), whence ℓ| 2, which is impossible.

We need one element of J outside K ∪B ∪C. Here is the group argument with its oddness hypothesis explicit. A group cannot be the union of two proper subgroups: elements outside each give, if necessary,

their product outside both. Suppose a group J is a union of three proper subgroups A, B, C, and each x ∈J has x^{k} ∈B for one fixed odd integer k. Choose x /∈B ∪C and y /∈A ∪C. The covering forces x ∈A, y ∈B, and xy ∈C. Now x^{2}y lies in neither A nor C: membership in A would put y in A, and membership in C, together with xy ∈ C, would put x in C. Thus x^{2}y ∈ B, so x^{2} ∈ B. Since k = 2j + 1, also x = x^{k}(x^{2})^{−j} ∈B, a contradiction. Apply this argument to the three intersections with J. Here x^{M} ∈B, since c(x^{M}) = Mc(x) = 0, and M is odd. We obtain a nonempty open set

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
V = J \ (K ∪B ∪C).

All the subgroups removed are open and closed; thus V is open in G_{ℚ}.

By Lemma 8.43, there are q ∤TFℓr, a place A | q, and a Frobenius φ ∈V . For precision, Chebotarev gives a finite quotient conjugacy class contained in the image of V ; choosing the prime above q chooses the required member, so no conjugacy-invariance of V is being assumed. Since φ ∈H, its action on µ_{F} gives q ≡1 (mod F); write q = 1 + Fk. Since φ /∈C, ℓ∤k. It fixes ρ, whereas Frobenius acts on its residue by the q-th power. As q ̸= r, ρ is a local unit, and

ρ = φρ ≡ρ^{q}= ρ r^{N0k} (mod A).

It follows that r^{N0k}≡1 (mod q). Thus ord_{q}(r) | N_{0}k, which is prime to ℓ. This proves admissibility. The exclusions from B and K give the two required values.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/RadEqv.lean:6--92; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/AddPowNsmul.lean:12--277

Proposition 8.75 (Discharging the descent inputs). In the notation of Proposition 8.17, take z = z_{b} from

Proposition 8.73. If a_{0}z | M, then all three construction, prime-choice, and reciprocity assertions preceding that proposition hold. Consequently

length_{O} 𝒞(1) ≤v_{O}(z).

Proof. The construction is Proposition 8.73, with w = 1/M mod O, whose annihilator is (M). We check that the normalized cocycles and these homomorphisms meet exactly the prime-choice and reciprocity hy-potheses.

Since a_{0} | M, α|_{H} acts trivially on D_{O}[a_{0}]. For a cocycle c ∈𝒞(n) its restriction to H is additive, killed by M, and has conjugation character α: expand the cocycle identity for gug^{−1}, and cancel c(g) + α(g)c(g^{−1}) = 0. It is nonzero if c ̸= 0. Indeed if it vanishes on H, the commutator gδ_{0}g^{−1}δ_{0}^{−1} lies in H, where δ_{0} is the normalizing element with α(δ_{0}) −1 a unit. Comparing c(gδ_{0}) and c(δ_{0}g), using c(δ_{0}) = 0, gives (α(δ_{0}) −1)c(g) = 0. Thus c = 0. Lemma 8.74 applies to c|_{H}, ν_{L}, with T =∏L.

For reciprocity a homomorphism on H must first be extended to a global cocycle. There is d ∈G_{ℚ} with β(d) −1 a unit, since β(d) −1 = −α(d)^{−1}(α(d) −χ_{ℓ}(d)). For an equivariant ν : H →D_{O}, define

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
n(g) = −(β(d) −1)^{−1}ν(gdg^{−1}d^{−1}).

Every commutator lies in H, and the map is locally constant. The identity

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
[gh, d] = g[h, d]g^{−1}[g, d]

and equivariance show that n(gh) = n(g) + β(g)n(h). For u ∈ H, ν([u, d]) = (1 −β(d))ν(u), so n(u) = ν(u). Every value of n is a scalar multiple of a value of ν; in particular any annihilator of ν(H) also kills n.

Let (a^{′}) = ann(ν(H)) and (a) = ann(ν(τ)) at the new prime. Then a | a^{′}| M, and both are nonzero. Write a^{′} = ae, and choose w_{0} of annihilator (a^{′}). Since a^{′}ν(τ) = 0, some y ∈ O has ν(τ) = yw_{0}.

Proposition 8.68 then gives y c(φ) = 0. Its local hypotheses are met as follows. At primes outside Fnq both cocycles are unramified; inertia lies in H, where the extension agrees with ν. At primes over F, the defining local coboundaries for c have primitives killed by a_{0}, hence by a^{′}. At the additional primes over n, c is zero on decomposition groups. At q, the decomposition group lies in H: its inertia fixes µ_{F} and its Frobenius acts by q ≡1 (mod F). Both α and β are therefore one modulo a^{′} there. Finally c is unramified at q. These are precisely the local conditions used in that reciprocity proposition.

To pass from y to e, use the total divisibility order in the discrete valuation ring. If y | a^{′}, write a^{′}= yt. Then tν(τ) = a^{′}w_{0} = 0, so a | t; write t = as. Cancelling a ̸= 0 from ae = yas gives e = ys, and hence e c(φ) = 0. If a^{′}| y, then ν(τ) = 0, so a is a unit. Since a_{0} | a in the descent step, a_{0} is a unit and c = 0, giving the same conclusion.

The remaining kernel identification in the descent is also exact. If c(φ) = 0, then its restriction at q is zero, because it is unramified there and a Frobenius topologically generates the unramified quotient. Conjugation equivariance transports this vanishing to every place over q. Thus the kernel of evaluation imposes exactly the extra splitting condition in 𝒞(nq). All three inputs of Proposition 8.17 are now proved; applying it gives the claimed bound.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ImportsAlt.lean:7--48; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ShtNu.lean:9--85; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ChiDvd.lean:37--154; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/FrobFix.lean:68--305

Lemma 8.76 (The Bernoulli value of the initial class). Let ℓ be odd, e ≥ 1, and ψ a primitive Dirichlet character of conductor f, with values in O, such that ψ(−1) = (−1)^{e+1}. Put α = (χ^{e}_{ℓ}ψ)^{−1}, and suppose α(g)−χ_{ℓ}(g) is a unit for some g ∈G_{ℚ}. Let A_{ψ} ∈O be the integral Bernoulli multiple den(f, e+1)B_{e+1,ψ} used in Proposition 8.64. For every a_{0} ∈O \ {0} there are m ≥1, F = f^{(ℓ)}ℓ^{m}, lifts σ_{t}, and b < F, such that α has the congruence properties in Proposition 8.73 and its initial scalar satisfies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a_{0}z_{b} | ℓ^{m}, z_{b} | A_{ψ}.

Here f^{(ℓ)}= f/ℓ^{vℓ(f)}.

Proof. We use the absolute value of the fixed embedding into ℚ_{ℓ}. On O, |x| ≤1, units have absolute value one, and

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
x | y ⇐⇒ |y| ≤|x| (x ̸= 0).

These statements follow by writing every nonzero element as a unit times a power of a uniformizer. Let

B = B_{e+1,ψ}, T = |B/(e + 1)| > 0, d = 2(e + 1) primorial(e + 2).

The nonvanishing B ̸= 0 is Lemma 8.63. Choose m ≥ max(1, v_{ℓ}(f)) so large that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|ℓ^{m}| < |a_{0}| |d| T.

This is possible because |ℓ| < 1. Then f | F = f^{(ℓ)}ℓ^{m}. For any element acting on µ_{F} by the k-th power, the cyclotomic character is k mod ℓ^{m}, while the Dirichlet character is exactly ψ(k). Consequently

χ^{e}_{ℓ}ψ(g) ≡k^{e}ψ(k) (mod ℓ^{m}O).

For k = 1 this proves α|_{H} ≡1; for k = −1, parity gives α ≡−1.

Choose g in the unit-difference hypothesis and let b be its unit residue representative modulo F. Let χ denote ψ raised to level F, and put

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
S = ∑ h_{b}(t)̃t^{e}χ(t), v = b^{e}χ(b), u = χ(b)b^{e+1}−1.
t∈(ℤ/F)^{×}

Termwise use of the preceding character congruence proves

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|z_{b} −S| ≤|ℓ^{m}|. (230)

We next prove the second approximation, including its denominator:

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
||||| {_{B}gen }|||||
d vS −2u_{e}^{e}_{ + 1}^{+1,χ} ≤|ℓ^{m}|. (231)

Here the superscript means the direct generalized Bernoulli sum at level F. For t a unit, set j = ⌊b̃t/F⌋ and y = b̃t −Fj, so 0 < y < F. Then

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
h_{b}(t) = 2j −(b −1).

Put C(x) = F^{e}B_{e+1}(x/F). The Bernoulli polynomial expansion and the denominator of its coefficients give

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
C(x)_{=} x^{e+1}_{−}x^{e}_{+ 2}F_{z,z ∈ℤ.}
e + 1  (e + 1)F 2  d ^{xx}

Indeed the first two terms are the coefficients B_{0} = 1, B_{1} = −1/2. Each remaining term contains F; the denominators of B_{j}, j ≥2, are squarefree products of primes at most j + 1, by von Staudt–Clausen, and d clears both these denominators and the factor e + 1. This is the same polynomial-denominator calculation used in the higher Stickelberger proof above. Expanding y = b̃t −Fj to first order modulo F^{2} now gives an integer Z_{t} such that

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
{_{2C(y)2b}e+1_{C(}̃_{t)}}
d b^{e}h_{b}(t)̃t^{e}+ _{e + 1} −_{e + 1} = FZ_{t}.

More explicitly, the first-order term of y^{e+1} is −(e+1)(b̃t)^{e}Fj; the term from −y^{e}/2 contributes (b−1)(b̃t)^{e} in this combination. Together they cancel (b̃t)^{e}(2j −b + 1); all remaining terms are the indicated integer multiples of F/d. Multiply by χ(bt) and sum. Reindexing t →→ bt converts the two C-sums to the same generalized Bernoulli sum, and gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
d{vS −2uB_{e}^{gen}_{+1,χ}/(e + 1)}=∑χ(bt)FZ_{t}.
t

Every χ(bt) has absolute value one and F is divisible by ℓ^{m}, so the ultrametric inequality proves (231).

The change-of-level formula is

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
B_{e}^{gen}_{+1,χ}= B∏(1 −ψ(p)p^{e}).
p_{p}|_{∤}F_{f}

It follows directly by deleting the residue classes divisible by the new prime p from the generalized Bernoulli sum, and applying ∑^{p}_{j=0}^{−1}B_{k}((x + j)/p) = p^{1−k}B_{k}(x); iteration proves the formula for F/f. The latter polynomial identity follows by summing its generating functions. The only possible new prime is ℓ. Its factor has absolute value one, since e ≥1 and |ψ(ℓ)| ≤1. Thus

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|B_{e}^{gen}_{+1,χ}/(e + 1)| = T.

Also |v| = 1, because b is a unit modulo F. We have |u| = 1: if U = χ_{ℓ}(g)^{e}ψ(g) and w = χ_{ℓ}(g), the congruences already proved give

u ≡−(U^{−1}−w)U (mod ℓ^{m}O).

The right side is a unit by hypothesis, so the left side is a unit.

Since |2| = 1, inequality (231) and |ℓ^{m}| < |d|T show, by the strict ultrametric triangle rule, that |S| = T. Then (230), with |ℓ^{m}| < T, gives |z_{b}| = T. Our choice of m therefore implies

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|ℓ^{m}| < |a_{0}| T = |a_{0}z_{b}|,

so a_{0}z_{b} | ℓ^{m}. Finally the denominator factor is an integer and |e + 1| ≤1, whence

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
|A_{ψ}| ≤|B| ≤|B/(e + 1)| = |z_{b}|.

Thus z_{b} | A_{ψ}, as required.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/GenBUnits.lean:10--146; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ZeNorm.lean:17--287

Lemma 8.77 (The exceptional residual cyclotomic character). Let ℓ be odd, O as above, and α : G_{ℚ} →O^{×} a character congruent to χ_{ℓ} modulo the maximal ideal (π) of O. Suppose α is unramified outside ℓ. Then its everywhere-unramified, ℓ-locally trivial group of classes in H^{1}(ℚ, D_{O}(α)) is zero.

Proof. Choose t in inertia at ℓ acting on µ_{ℓ} by inversion. Such a t exists by the inertia surjectivity used in Lemma 8.72. Since ℓ is odd, α(t) −1 ≡−2 (mod π) is a unit. Every cohomology class has a unique cocycle representative c with c(t) = 0: subtract the coboundary of (α(t)−1)^{−1}c(t). If its restriction to G_{ℚℓ} is a coboundary, the primitive must be zero, by evaluating at t. Thus this normalized c vanishes on G_{ℚℓ}. At every other prime inertia acts trivially on the coefficient module; being a coboundary on inertia means that c itself vanishes there.

First suppose πc = 0. The values lie in the residue vector space D_{O}[π], which is killed by ℓ, and the action of G_{ℚ} on it is the scalar mod-ℓ cyclotomic character. Compose with any additive F_{ℓ}-linear functional D_{O}[π] → F_{ℓ}. The resulting cocycle z has the mod-ℓ cyclotomic action and vanishes on inertia at every finite prime. Identify F_{ℓ}(1) with µ_{ℓ} using a primitive root. The elementary Kummer description gives

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
a ∈ℚ^{×}, θ^{ℓ}= a, gθ = ζ_{ℓ}^{z(g)}θ.

For completeness this description follows from multiplicative Hilbert 90 for the root-valued cocycle. In a

Selectable PDF notation • transcription unchecked
−z(g)

finite Galois extension through which it factors, choose x for which the sum ∑_{g}ζ_{ℓ} g(x) is nonzero; such an x exists by linear independence of distinct field automorphisms. Call the sum θ. Changing the index gives the displayed transformation law, so θ^{ℓ} is fixed and lies in ℚ^{×}.

Because z vanishes on inertia, θ is inertia-fixed at each prime. In an unramified local extension its valuation is integral. Thus ℓ | v_{p}(a) for every rational prime p. Unique factorization in ℚ^{×} then gives a = y^{ℓ}, y ∈ℚ^{×}: divide each prime exponent by ℓ and absorb the sign, since ℓ is odd. Therefore θ/y ∈µ_{ℓ}, and z is a coboundary, say z(g) = (χ_{ℓ}(g) −1)j. Its normalization z(t) = 0, with χ_{ℓ}(t) −1 = −2 ̸= 0, gives j = 0, so z = 0. Linear functionals separate the points of a vector space, hence c = 0.

A locally constant cocycle on the compact group G_{ℚ} has finite image, and every element of D_{O} is killed by a power of π. Thus some π^{k} kills c. Induct on k. The cocycle π^{k−1}c satisfies the same normalization and local conditions, and is killed by π; it is zero by the case just proved. Apply the induction hypothesis to c with the smaller exponent. This proves that every normalized representative, and hence every class, is zero.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/RatPlace.lean:12--202

Theorem 8.78 (The good-prime Bernoulli character bound). Inequality (206) holds. In particular the minus estimate of Proposition 8.16 has no remaining Euler-system input.

Proof. First let ψ be primitive of conductor f, order prime to ℓ, and parity ψ(−1) = (−1)^{e+1}, and put α = (χ_{ℓ}^{e}ψ)^{−1}. We prove the bound for its classes over ℚ with coefficients D_{O}(α). At p ̸= ℓ, the cyclotomic character is trivial on inertia, so the action there is ψ^{−1}. A nontrivial root of unity of order prime to ℓ differs from one by a unit of O. Indeed, if x^{h}= 1, x ̸= 1, and ℓ∤h, then ∑^{h}_{i=0}^{−1}x^{i} = 0; reducing x ≡1 modulo the maximal ideal would imply h = 0 in its residue field, a contradiction. Primitivity also ensures that at every prime dividing f some inertia element acts nontrivially under ψ. Otherwise ψ would be trivial on the kernel removing that prime-power component of (ℤ/f)^{×}, and would factor through a proper divisor of its conductor. Inertia maps onto this component by the cyclotomic inertia surjectivity. Outside f, it acts trivially.

If α(g)−χ_{ℓ}(g) is a nonunit for every g, then α ≡χ_{ℓ} (mod π). On inertia away from ℓ this implies ψ^{−1}≡ 1 (mod π). The preceding prime-to-ℓ root-of-unity observation forces ψ = 1 there, so α is unramified outside ℓ. Lemma 8.77 gives zero for the class group in question, which proves the desired inequality.

Otherwise Lemma 8.76 applies. Choose a lift δ_{0} of complex conjugation. The character α(δ_{0}) = −1 exactly, so α(δ_{0})−1 = −2 is a unit. Normalize every cocycle by c(δ_{0}) = 0. Every class under consideration has such a representative in 𝒞(1) for some nonzero a_{0}, with the ramification set the primes dividing fℓ. Here are the local and finiteness details. Its finite image is killed by one nonzero scalar. At ℓ, choose a local coboundary primitive and include its annihilator in that scalar. At a prime p | f, p ̸= ℓ, the class is an inertia coboundary, say c|_{Ip} = (α −1)m_{p}. Choose g_{p} ∈ I_{p} with α(g_{p}) −1 a unit. Any scalar killing c kills m_{p} by evaluating at g_{p}. Moreover the same primitive works on the entire decomposition group: subtract its coboundary; the resulting cocycle vanishes on inertia, and comparison at g_{p} and d^{−1}g_{p}d gives (α(g_{p}) −1)c(d) = 0 for every decomposition element d. Thus c(d) = 0. Conjugating places sends the primitive to α(σ)m_{p} −c(σ); the same scalar kills it. Outside fℓ the coefficient character is unramified, so the local inertia coboundary condition means literal vanishing on inertia. These verifications give exactly the defining conditions of 𝒞(1).

For each nonzero a_{0}, the evaluation lemma supplies m, F = f^{(ℓ)}ℓ^{m}, b with a_{0}z_{b} | ℓ^{m}, z_{b} | A_{ψ}. The sets of primes dividing F and fℓ are identical, since m ≥1. Hence the normalized cocycle module is the same for either ramification integer. Proposition 8.75 gives

length_{O} 𝒞(1) ≤v_{O}(z_{b}) ≤v_{O}(A_{ψ}).

Finally the modules with annihilator π^{k} form an increasing family containing every normalized class. A uniform finite bound on their lengths bounds the length of their union: any finite chain in the union is contained in one member, by taking the maximum of its finitely many indices. Thus the full class group has length at most v_{O}(A_{ψ}).

For an imprimitive Dirichlet character at level F, replace it by its primitive character of conductor f. Its Galois character and parity are unchanged; raising the level is injective on unit characters, so its order is unchanged. Our Bernoulli convention uses this primitive character at both levels. As D(f, e + 1) | D(F, e + 1), its integral Bernoulli multiple divides α_{e+1}(η) at level F. The primitive bound therefore proves the imprimitive one.

To identify this group with the η-eigenspace over E, restrict from G_{ℚ} to G_{E} and twist by η^{−1}. The finite quotient has order [E : ℚ] = n, prime to ℓ; averaging by 1/n makes its positive cohomology zero, so restriction identifies the twisted group with the η eigenspace. This also preserves the local conditions: the identical averaging argument applies to every decomposition or inertia quotient. It gives the source’s (χ^{e}_{ℓ}η)^{−1}

action, rather than an inverse change in the Bernoulli character. This proves (206). Propositions 8.15, 8.64, 8.67, and 8.16 now give the asserted minus estimate.

Source: Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/PrimRam.lean:11--133; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/ShaToShT.lean:12--190; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/PrimCase.lean:19--209; Development/AutomorphicArithmetic/AutomorphicVarieties/PrimitiveFrobeniusFixed/PsiOf.lean:12--64