{"schemaVersion":1,"publication":{"title":"Relational Development and Conscious Scaffolding","subtitle":"Conceptual Foundations, Strengthened Results, and Research Commitments","fullTitle":"Relational Development and Conscious Scaffolding: Conceptual Foundations, Strengthened Results, and Research Commitments","description":"How acquired relations become retained organisation that shapes later interpretation, reasoning and action. Full philosophical account, continuation and transfer results, diagnostic bounds and a conditional native incorporation witness.","author":"Jeremy Rodgers","authorRole":"Independent Researcher","date":"2026-10-06","version":"Revised preprint","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23190711","doiUrl":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23190711","url":"/consciousness/development","paperSlug":"relational-development-and-conscious-scaffolding","articleUrl":"/articles/agency-and-the-constructed-self","pdfUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.pdf","texUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/development.md","manifestUrl":"/consciousness/development/manifest.json"},"documents":[{"slug":"overview-and-publication-identity","title":"Overview and publication identity","label":"","kind":"frontmatter","order":1,"sections":[{"anchor":"publication-identity","title":"Publication identity","number":"","level":2},{"anchor":"abstract","title":"Abstract","number":"","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/overview-and-publication-identity","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/overview-and-publication-identity.md","stats":{"equations":0,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex"}},{"slug":"orientation-and-contribution","title":"Orientation and contribution","label":"Section 1","kind":"section","order":2,"sections":[{"anchor":"orientation-and-contribution","title":"Orientation and contribution","number":"1","level":2},{"anchor":"contribution-comparison","title":"Contribution comparison","number":"1.1","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/orientation-and-contribution","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/orientation-and-contribution.md","stats":{"equations":0,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":1,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":140}},{"slug":"sources-and-representational-access","title":"Sources and representational access","label":"Section 2","kind":"section","order":3,"sections":[{"anchor":"sources-and-representational-access","title":"Sources and representational access","number":"2","level":2},{"anchor":"evidence-inferential-reach-and-achieved-understanding","title":"Evidence, inferential reach and achieved understanding","number":"2.1","level":3},{"anchor":"source-aperture-readout-and-constructed-representation","title":"Source, aperture, readout and constructed representation","number":"2.2","level":3},{"anchor":"perspective-awareness-and-metacognition","title":"Perspective, awareness and metacognition","number":"2.3","level":3},{"anchor":"functional-perspective-and-internal-arbitration","title":"Functional perspective and internal arbitration","number":"2.4","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/sources-and-representational-access","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/sources-and-representational-access.md","stats":{"equations":4,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":242}},{"slug":"recursive-conscious-scaffolding","title":"Recursive conscious scaffolding","label":"Section 3","kind":"section","order":4,"sections":[{"anchor":"recursive-conscious-scaffolding","title":"Recursive conscious scaffolding","number":"3","level":2},{"anchor":"from-encountered-difference-to-retained-organization","title":"From encountered difference to retained organisation","number":"3.1","level":3},{"anchor":"differentiation-integration-retention-and-revision","title":"Differentiation, integration, retention and revision","number":"3.2","level":3},{"anchor":"the-central-consciousness-hypothesis","title":"The central consciousness hypothesis","number":"3.3","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/recursive-conscious-scaffolding","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/recursive-conscious-scaffolding.md","stats":{"equations":9,"displayEquations":2,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":370}},{"slug":"will-thought-and-embodiment","title":"Will, thought, and embodiment","label":"Section 4","kind":"section","order":5,"sections":[{"anchor":"will-thought-and-embodiment","title":"Will, thought, and embodiment","number":"4","level":2},{"anchor":"relevance-and-directed-reconciliation","title":"Relevance and directed reconciliation","number":"4.1","level":3},{"anchor":"failed-willing-error-and-competing-valuations","title":"Failed willing, error and competing valuations","number":"4.2","level":3},{"anchor":"physiological-and-affective-organization","title":"Physiological and affective organisation","number":"4.3","level":3},{"anchor":"content-organization-and-source-status","title":"Content organisation and source status","number":"4.4","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/will-thought-and-embodiment","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/will-thought-and-embodiment.md","stats":{"equations":1,"displayEquations":1,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":1,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":505}},{"slug":"history-transmission-and-perspective","title":"History, transmission, and perspective","label":"Section 5","kind":"section","order":6,"sections":[{"anchor":"history-transmission-and-perspective","title":"History, transmission, and perspective","number":"5","level":2},{"anchor":"developmental-history-and-the-exact-state-limit","title":"Developmental history and the exact-state limit","number":"5.1","level":3},{"anchor":"memory-reinterpretation-and-continuity","title":"Memory, reinterpretation and continuity","number":"5.2","level":3},{"anchor":"artifacts-and-propagation","title":"Artifacts and propagation","number":"5.3","level":3},{"anchor":"rco-and-the-personal-model","title":"RCO and the personal model","number":"5.4","level":3},{"anchor":"onetworelationreincorporation","title":"One–Two–relation–reincorporation","number":"5.5","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/history-transmission-and-perspective","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/history-transmission-and-perspective.md","stats":{"equations":14,"displayEquations":1,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":681}},{"slug":"published-constitution-and-realization","title":"Published constitution and realisation","label":"Section 6","kind":"section","order":7,"sections":[{"anchor":"published-constitution-and-realization","title":"Published constitution and realisation","number":"6","level":2},{"anchor":"a0a3-and-the-scope-of-the-developmental-proposal","title":"A0–A3 and the scope of the developmental proposal","number":"6.1","level":3},{"anchor":"state-law-predictive-history-and-capability","title":"State, law, predictive history and capability","number":"6.2","level":3},{"anchor":"why-realization-cannot-be-inferred-from-service-behavior","title":"Why realisation cannot be inferred from service behaviour","number":"6.3","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/published-constitution-and-realization","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/published-constitution-and-realization.md","stats":{"equations":0,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":1,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":876}},{"slug":"continuation-sufficient-relational-memory","title":"Continuation-sufficient relational memory","label":"Section 7","kind":"section","order":8,"sections":[{"anchor":"continuation-sufficient-relational-memory","title":"Continuation-sufficient relational memory","number":"7","level":2},{"anchor":"a-finite-costed-model","title":"A finite costed model","number":"7.1","level":3},{"anchor":"snapshot-failure-and-deterministic-repair","title":"Snapshot failure and deterministic repair","number":"7.2","level":3},{"anchor":"stochastic-joint-closure-and-autonomous-modules","title":"Stochastic joint closure and autonomous modules","number":"7.3","level":3},{"anchor":"exact-residual-memory-and-relational-dependence","title":"Exact residual memory and relational dependence","number":"7.4","level":3},{"anchor":"robust-finite-use-substitution","title":"Robust finite-use substitution","number":"7.5","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/continuation-sufficient-relational-memory","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/continuation-sufficient-relational-memory.md","stats":{"equations":88,"displayEquations":7,"theorems":3,"proofs":3,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":1020}},{"slug":"strengthened-transfer-and-diagnostic-results","title":"Strengthened transfer and diagnostic results","label":"Section 8","kind":"section","order":9,"sections":[{"anchor":"strengthened-transfer-and-diagnostic-results","title":"Strengthened transfer and diagnostic results","number":"8","level":2},{"anchor":"transfer-targets-and-the-cost-of-a-code","title":"Transfer targets and the cost of a code","number":"8.1","level":3},{"anchor":"exact-private-randomness-transfer-tradeoff","title":"Exact private-randomness transfer tradeoff","number":"8.2","level":3},{"anchor":"what-shared-randomness-changes","title":"What shared randomness changes","number":"8.3","level":3},{"anchor":"philosophical-significance-and-limits-of-the-transfer-result","title":"Philosophical significance and limits of the transfer result","number":"8.4","level":3},{"anchor":"exact-finite-setting","title":"Exact finite setting","number":"8.5","level":3},{"anchor":"diagnostic-completeness-including-its-exact-converse","title":"Diagnostic completeness, including its exact converse","number":"8.6","level":3},{"anchor":"uniform-adaptive-transfer-from-a-conditioned-diagnostic-basis","title":"Uniform adaptive transfer from a conditioned diagnostic basis","number":"8.7","level":3},{"anchor":"a-sharp-obstruction-to-dimension-only-approximate-certificates","title":"A sharp obstruction to dimension-only approximate certificates","number":"8.8","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/strengthened-transfer-and-diagnostic-results","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/strengthened-transfer-and-diagnostic-results.md","stats":{"equations":182,"displayEquations":16,"theorems":5,"proofs":6,"tables":0,"figures":1,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":1232}},{"slug":"paid-inference-and-reusable-organization","title":"Paid inference and reusable organisation","label":"Section 9","kind":"section","order":10,"sections":[{"anchor":"paid-inference-and-reusable-organization","title":"Paid inference and reusable organisation","number":"9","level":2},{"anchor":"equal-evidence-can-support-unequal-bounded-achievement","title":"Equal evidence can support unequal bounded achievement","number":"9.1","level":3},{"anchor":"compilation-reuse-and-break-even-analysis","title":"Compilation, reuse and break-even analysis","number":"9.2","level":3},{"anchor":"retained-relations-as-intervention-sensitive-organization","title":"Retained relations as intervention-sensitive organisation","number":"9.3","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/paid-inference-and-reusable-organization","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/paid-inference-and-reusable-organization.md","stats":{"equations":18,"displayEquations":1,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":1710}},{"slug":"native-incorporation-witness","title":"Native incorporation witness","label":"Section 10","kind":"section","order":11,"sections":[{"anchor":"native-incorporation-witness","title":"Native incorporation witness","number":"10","level":2},{"anchor":"an-explicit-logical-realization","title":"An explicit logical realisation","number":"10.1","level":3},{"anchor":"installing-and-testing-a-relational-result","title":"Installing and testing a relational result","number":"10.2","level":3},{"anchor":"conditional-phenomenal-point-separation","title":"Conditional phenomenal point separation","number":"10.3","level":3},{"anchor":"countermodels-that-delimit-the-inference","title":"Countermodels that delimit the inference","number":"10.4","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/native-incorporation-witness","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/native-incorporation-witness.md","stats":{"equations":41,"displayEquations":1,"theorems":1,"proofs":1,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":1804}},{"slug":"literature","title":"Literature","label":"Section 11","kind":"section","order":12,"sections":[{"anchor":"literature","title":"Literature","number":"11","level":2},{"anchor":"closest-conceptual-antecedents","title":"Closest conceptual antecedents","number":"11.1","level":3},{"anchor":"predictive-state-value-and-computational-control","title":"Predictive state, value and computational control","number":"11.2","level":3},{"anchor":"causal-abstraction-and-the-contribution-boundary","title":"Causal abstraction and the contribution boundary","number":"11.3","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/literature","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/literature.md","stats":{"equations":0,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":1934}},{"slug":"research-programme","title":"Research programme","label":"Section 12","kind":"section","order":13,"sections":[{"anchor":"research-programme","title":"Research programme","number":"12","level":2},{"anchor":"a-sequence-of-discriminating-studies","title":"A sequence of discriminating studies","number":"12.1","level":3},{"anchor":"experience-facing-content-and-rco-studies","title":"Experience-facing content and RCO studies","number":"12.2","level":3},{"anchor":"hard-cases-and-competing-explanations","title":"Hard cases and competing explanations","number":"12.3","level":3},{"anchor":"concrete-outstanding-obligations","title":"Concrete outstanding obligations","number":"12.4","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/research-programme","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/research-programme.md","stats":{"equations":1,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":2,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":2067}},{"slug":"coverage-and-provenance","title":"Coverage and provenance","label":"Section 13","kind":"section","order":14,"sections":[{"anchor":"coverage-and-provenance","title":"Coverage and provenance","number":"13","level":2},{"anchor":"conceptual-coverage-and-source-limitations","title":"Conceptual coverage and source limitations","number":"13.1","level":3},{"anchor":"proof-and-computation-audit","title":"Proof and computation audit","number":"13.2","level":3},{"anchor":"attribution-and-research-support","title":"Attribution and research support","number":"13.3","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/coverage-and-provenance","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/coverage-and-provenance.md","stats":{"equations":2,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":0},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":2302}},{"slug":"references-and-access-record","title":"References and access record","label":"Section 14","kind":"section","order":15,"sections":[{"anchor":"references-and-access-record","title":"References and access record","number":"14","level":2},{"anchor":"programme-publications","title":"Programme publications","number":"14.1","level":3},{"anchor":"external-primary-sources","title":"External primary sources","number":"14.2","level":3}],"paperId":"development","publicationId":"development","url":"/consciousness/development/references-and-access-record","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/sections/references-and-access-record.md","stats":{"equations":0,"displayEquations":0,"theorems":0,"proofs":0,"tables":0,"figures":0,"bibliographyEntries":15},"source":{"texFile":"/publications/consciousness/development/relational_development.tex","texStartLine":2354}}],"figureStatus":"resolved-author-supplied-original","figureNote":"Figure 1 uses the original PNG and vector PDF supplied by the author. The downloadable paper PDF is the author-supplied corrected edition containing the figure.","coverageUrl":"/publications/consciousness/development/source-coverage.json","sourceNote":"The supplied 6 October 2026 revised preprint controls this edition. The foundational monograph and Papers 2–4 retain their own publication identities and claims.","article":{"title":"Agency and the constructed self","url":"/articles/agency-and-the-constructed-self","sourceNote":"Citation [11] is unresolved in the supplied Word document; the web edition preserves the marker and documents the omission."}}