{"schemaVersion":1,"publication":{"id":"constituted-agency","title":"Constituted Agency","subtitle":"Self-authorship, local control, and conscious participation","description":"Understanding changes what a recommendation is permitted to do. Explore the philosophical argument and the complete finite construction of acquired, selective authority revision.","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23581587","date":"2026-10-22","url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency","pdfUrl":"/publications/consciousness/new-papers/constituted-agency/paper.pdf","markdownUrl":"/publications/consciousness/new-papers/constituted-agency/complete.md","manifestUrl":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/manifest.json","paperSlug":"constituted-agency-2026","headline":"Understanding changes participation.","author":"Jeremy Rodgers"},"kind":"complete-translated-web-edition","chapters":[{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"01-constituted-participation","title":"Agency as constituted participation","description":"Understanding changes participation.","order":1,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/01-constituted-participation","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/01-constituted-participation.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-1","title":"1 Agency as constituted participation"}],"anchors":["section-1"],"words":1048},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"02-constitution-and-authorship","title":"Common constitution and the sources of an act","description":"Dependence does not make a participant disappear.","order":2,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/02-constitution-and-authorship","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/02-constitution-and-authorship.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-2","title":"2 Common constitution and the sources of an act"},{"id":"section-2-1","title":"2.1 Dependence, exercise and authorship"},{"id":"section-2-2","title":"2.2 Four routes to a stronger exclusion"},{"id":"section-2-3","title":"2.3 What evidence for a realized account can establish"},{"id":"section-2-4","title":"2.4 Why self-revision does not create its entire authorization basis"},{"id":"section-2-5","title":"2.5 The cumulative argument and constituted participation"},{"id":"section-2-6","title":"2.6 One physical bearer and the priority of the whole"}],"anchors":["section-2","section-2-1","section-2-2","statement-2-1","statement-2-2","section-2-3","section-2-4","statement-2-3","section-2-5","section-2-6"],"words":3668},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"03-physical-histories","title":"Physical histories and the temporal organization of a participant","description":"A physical history contains change.","order":3,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/03-physical-histories","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/03-physical-histories.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-3","title":"3 Physical histories and the temporal organization of a participant"},{"id":"section-3-1","title":"3.1 Newtonian histories already have a four-dimensional representation"},{"id":"section-3-2","title":"3.2 Relativity makes local order objective without making simultaneity universal"},{"id":"section-3-3","title":"3.3 General relativity supplies conditional initial-value uniqueness"},{"id":"section-3-4","title":"3.4 Quantum theory limits the inference to a unique future"},{"id":"section-3-5","title":"3.5 The strongest physical support for a complete-history interpretation"}],"anchors":["section-3","section-3-1","section-3-2","section-3-3","section-3-4","section-3-5"],"words":1578},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"04-relativity-and-actuality","title":"Relativity, common actuality and causal participation","description":"Causal participation survives a complete spacetime description.","order":4,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/04-relativity-and-actuality","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/04-relativity-and-actuality.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-4","title":"4 Relativity, common actuality and causal participation"},{"id":"section-4-1","title":"4.1 The force of the relativistic argument"},{"id":"section-4-2","title":"4.2 Rietdijk’s stronger claim and its missing transfer"},{"id":"section-4-3","title":"4.3 Complete actuality, dynamical uniqueness and control"}],"anchors":["section-4","section-4-1","statement-4-1","section-4-2","section-4-3"],"words":1689},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"05-determination-and-control","title":"Inside-out determination and the authorship of an occurrence","description":"Choosing a determining slice does not create a chooser.","order":5,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/05-determination-and-control","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/05-determination-and-control.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-5","title":"5 Inside-out determination and the authorship of an occurrence"},{"id":"section-5-1","title":"5.1 What Hoefer proposes and what Brennan challenges"},{"id":"section-5-2","title":"5.2 Full-state uniqueness is not fragmentary power"},{"id":"section-5-3","title":"5.3 A reversible history with directional command efficacy"},{"id":"section-5-4","title":"5.4 From an actual complete history to a limitation on authorship"},{"id":"section-5-5","title":"5.5 Thyssen’s libertarian reconstruction and the remaining selection problem"}],"anchors":["section-5","section-5-1","section-5-2","statement-5-1","section-5-3","section-5-4","statement-5-2","section-5-5"],"words":2483},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"06-compatible-histories","title":"Compatible histories and distributed choices","description":"Possible choices must fit together.","order":6,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/06-compatible-histories","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/06-compatible-histories.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-6","title":"6 Compatible histories and distributed choices"},{"id":"section-6-1","title":"6.1 What pruning does and what infinity does not supply"},{"id":"section-6-2","title":"6.2 From a compatible profile to operative choice"}],"anchors":["section-6","statement-6-1","statement-6-2","section-6-1","statement-6-3","section-6-2"],"words":1267},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"07-self-description-and-source","title":"From a self-description to the organization it describes","description":"A self-description is a record within an organization.","order":7,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/07-self-description-and-source","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/07-self-description-and-source.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-7","title":"7 From a self-description to the organization it describes"},{"id":"section-7-1","title":"7.1 Five uses of source"},{"id":"section-7-2","title":"7.2 Information, access and authority"}],"anchors":["section-7","section-7-1","statement-7-1","section-7-2"],"words":990},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"08-history-and-access","title":"Source, physical history and situated access","description":"Global completeness and situated access coexist.","order":8,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/08-history-and-access","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/08-history-and-access.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-8","title":"8 Source, physical history and situated access"},{"id":"section-8-1","title":"8.1 Two relations, with different obligations"},{"id":"section-8-2","title":"8.2 History targets and the reach of an accessible record"},{"id":"section-8-3","title":"8.3 Why an actual trace is not the whole constitution"},{"id":"section-8-4","title":"8.4 A local present without a second temporal sweep"}],"anchors":["section-8","section-8-1","section-8-2","section-8-3","section-8-4"],"words":1525},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"09-recognition-and-authority","title":"Recognition as a change in warranted authority","description":"Recognition becomes consequential when warranted assessment enters action.","order":9,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/09-recognition-and-authority","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/09-recognition-and-authority.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-9","title":"9 Recognition as a change in warranted authority"},{"id":"section-9-1","title":"9.1 Understanding, assessment and incorporation"},{"id":"section-9-2","title":"9.2 A conditional evaluative principle"},{"id":"section-9-3","title":"9.3 Continuity without an inner proprietor"}],"anchors":["section-9","section-9-1","section-9-2","statement-9-1","section-9-3"],"words":1216},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"10-warranted-judgment","title":"Recognition and the authority of a constituted judgment","description":"A constituted judgment can be a genuine commitment.","order":10,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/10-warranted-judgment","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/10-warranted-judgment.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-10","title":"10 Recognition and the authority of a constituted judgment"},{"id":"section-10-1","title":"10.1 Judgment, avowal and commitment"},{"id":"section-10-2","title":"10.2 Warrant and implementation"},{"id":"section-10-3","title":"10.3 Self-formation and historical ownership"}],"anchors":["section-10","section-10-1","section-10-2","section-10-3"],"words":1890},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"11-acquired-self-model","title":"An acquired self-model that changes its own practical use","description":"The route from understanding to change can be inspected.","order":11,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/11-acquired-self-model","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/11-acquired-self-model.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-11","title":"11 An acquired self-model that changes its own practical use"},{"id":"section-11-1","title":"11.1 The task, state and permitted routes"},{"id":"section-11-2","title":"11.2 Acquisition and fresh prediction"},{"id":"section-11-3","title":"11.3 Assessment, retention and installation"},{"id":"section-11-4","title":"11.4 Why this is an interpretation of recognition"}],"anchors":["section-11","section-11-1","equation-1","equation-2","equation-3","equation-4","section-11-2","statement-11-1","section-11-3","statement-11-2","section-11-4"],"words":1363},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"12-recognition-in-a-history","title":"Recognition within a complete history","description":"Learning occurs within a complete history.","order":12,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/12-recognition-in-a-history","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/12-recognition-in-a-history.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-12","title":"12 Recognition within a complete history"},{"id":"section-12-1","title":"12.1 One source point, one complete transaction"},{"id":"section-12-2","title":"12.2 What the participant can predict"},{"id":"section-12-3","title":"12.3 Information acquisition and practical revision"},{"id":"section-12-4","title":"12.4 Reversible preservation is distinct from a memory arrow"},{"id":"section-12-5","title":"12.5 Prepared records, entropy and the practical direction of inquiry"}],"anchors":["section-12","section-12-1","section-12-2","section-12-3","statement-12-1","section-12-4","section-12-5"],"words":2335},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"13-selectivity-and-failure","title":"When recognition earns its cost, and when it fails","description":"Recognition earns its value through warranted selectivity.","order":13,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/13-selectivity-and-failure","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/13-selectivity-and-failure.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-13","title":"13 When recognition earns its cost, and when it fails"},{"id":"section-13-1","title":"13.1 A costed selective target"},{"id":"section-13-2","title":"13.2 Noisy acquisition"},{"id":"section-13-3","title":"13.3 A concrete model error and a repair"},{"id":"section-13-4","title":"13.4 Retention, application and relapse"}],"anchors":["section-13","section-13-1","statement-13-1","equation-5","section-13-2","statement-13-2","section-13-3","section-13-4"],"words":1690},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"14-forecasts-and-choice","title":"Revealed forecasts and choice","description":"A forecast can change the process it predicts.","order":14,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/14-forecasts-and-choice","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/14-forecasts-and-choice.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-14","title":"14 Revealed forecasts and choice"},{"id":"section-14-1","title":"14.1 What the predictor objection actually establishes"},{"id":"section-14-2","title":"14.2 Consistency depends on the receiver’s policy"},{"id":"section-14-3","title":"14.3 A prediction can become part of what it describes"}],"anchors":["section-14","section-14-1","statement-14-1","section-14-2","statement-14-2","section-14-3"],"words":1606},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"15-finite-physical-realization","title":"A local, finite realization of the recognition transaction","description":"Understanding requires a carrier and a schedule.","order":15,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/15-finite-physical-realization","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/15-finite-physical-realization.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-15","title":"15 A local, finite realization of the recognition transaction"},{"id":"section-15-1","title":"15.1 Bank, interfaces and chronology"},{"id":"section-15-2","title":"15.2 Changing authority while retaining the previous selector"},{"id":"section-15-3","title":"15.3 Local compilation and its exact count"},{"id":"section-15-4","title":"15.4 Finite strength, scheduling and retention"},{"id":"section-15-5","title":"15.5 A whole-transaction error certificate"},{"id":"section-15-6","title":"15.6 One causal history across different temporal orderings"},{"id":"section-15-7","title":"15.7 An exhaustive finite instance."},{"id":"section-15-8","title":"15.8 The earlier routed bank as one particular history."}],"anchors":["section-15","section-15-1","section-15-2","statement-15-1","section-15-3","section-15-4","section-15-5","equation-6","section-15-6","equation-7","statement-15-2","section-15-7","section-15-8"],"words":3533},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"16-conscious-participation","title":"Conscious participation without an independent owner","description":"A conscious participant need not have an owner behind it.","order":16,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/16-conscious-participation","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/16-conscious-participation.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-16","title":"16 Conscious participation without an independent owner"},{"id":"section-16-1","title":"16.1 The constitution applied, rather than silently revised"},{"id":"section-16-2","title":"16.2 Recognition changes an authority relation within a perspective"},{"id":"section-16-3","title":"16.3 Contribution to a complete occurrence is not its individuation"},{"id":"section-16-4","title":"16.4 Relationships, commitment and the continuity of practical agency"}],"anchors":["section-16","section-16-1","section-16-2","section-16-3","section-16-4"],"words":2038},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"17-authorship-and-meaning","title":"Authorship, recognition and consequential participation","description":"The achievement is consequential participation.","order":17,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/17-authorship-and-meaning","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/17-authorship-and-meaning.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-17","title":"17 Authorship, recognition and consequential participation"},{"id":"section-17-1","title":"17.1 Does a thin mechanism explain understanding?"},{"id":"section-17-2","title":"17.2 Does realization turn the person into a spectator?"},{"id":"section-17-3","title":"17.3 Why this is more than renaming conditioning"},{"id":"section-17-4","title":"17.4 Responsibility and meaning"}],"anchors":["section-17","section-17-1","section-17-2","section-17-3","section-17-4"],"words":1199},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"18-freedom-through-recognition","title":"Conclusion: a participant’s changing relation to its constitution","description":"Freedom through recognition is a definite change in the participant’s relation to its constitution.","order":18,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/18-freedom-through-recognition","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/18-freedom-through-recognition.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-18","title":"18 Conclusion: a participant’s changing relation to its constitution"},{"id":"section-18-1","title":"18.1 Research status and independent review."},{"id":"section-18-2","title":"18.2 Authorship, assistance and funding."}],"anchors":["section-18","section-18-1","section-18-2"],"words":883},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"19-operational-foundations","title":"Retained operational foundations","description":"The operational foundation remains available in full.","order":19,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/19-operational-foundations","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/19-operational-foundations.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-a","title":"A Retained operational foundations"},{"id":"section-a-1","title":"A.1 Observation, task compatibility and control"},{"id":"section-a-2","title":"A.2 Reversible retention and learned regulation"},{"id":"section-a-3","title":"A.3 When an organized description supports its own transitions"},{"id":"section-a-4","title":"A.4 Evaluative revision and finite inquiry"},{"id":"section-a-5","title":"A.5 Preserving revisability and retaining an earlier relation"},{"id":"section-a-6","title":"A.6 Present causal authority and historical evidence"}],"anchors":["section-a","section-a-1","equation-8","statement-a-1","section-a-2","statement-a-2","statement-a-3","section-a-3","equation-9","section-a-4","statement-a-4","equation-10","section-a-5","equation-11","section-a-6","statement-a-5"],"words":1978},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"20-verification-and-dependencies","title":"Verification and dependency summary","description":"Verification has a declared scope.","order":20,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/20-verification-and-dependencies","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/20-verification-and-dependencies.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-b","title":"B Verification and dependency summary"},{"id":"section-b-1","title":"B.1 What carries the conclusions"},{"id":"section-b-2","title":"B.2 Preserved transaction executions"},{"id":"section-b-3","title":"B.3 New history and spacetime executions"},{"id":"section-b-4","title":"B.4 Dependencies of the expanded synthesis"}],"anchors":["section-b","section-b-1","section-b-2","section-b-3","section-b-4"],"words":1303},{"paperId":"constituted-agency","slug":"21-references","title":"References","description":"Sources and publication relationships.","order":21,"url":"/consciousness/constituted-agency/21-references","sourcePath":"content/paper-integrations/constituted-agency/21-references.mdx","sections":[{"id":"section-references","title":"References"}],"anchors":["section-references","ref-anderson","ref-barenco","ref-brennan2007","ref-chalmers","ref-Hoefer2001Draft","ref-hoefer2002","ref-ismael2016","ref-krishnamurti","ref-krishguide","ref-krumm","ref-list","ref-oconnor","ref-putnam1967","ref-rietdijk1966","ref-canonical1","ref-canonical2","ref-canonical3","ref-canonical5","ref-canonical6","ref-rodgersagency","ref-rodgersalignment","ref-rodgersappearance","ref-rodgersboundary","ref-rodgerscontrol","ref-rodgersdevelopment","ref-rodgerslearning","ref-rodgersshadow","ref-rodgerssupplement","ref-rodgerswebsite","ref-sealed","ref-boundedweb","ref-historyweb","ref-sbierski2015","ref-schafferspacetime2009","ref-schaffer","ref-schopenhauer","ref-spinoza","ref-stein1991","ref-strawson","ref-thyssen","ref-timalsina","ref-tumulka2006","ref-tumulka2022"],"words":1484}],"completeMarkdown":"/publications/consciousness/new-papers/constituted-agency/complete.md","originalPdf":"/publications/consciousness/new-papers/constituted-agency/paper.pdf"}